Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):

    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Desperate For Help

Pink Angel

Recommended Posts

Pink Angel Newbie
Pink Angel
Posted

I am brand new to this forum and am afraid I'm going to ask something g that's been asked before, but...I'm desperate!!

I have had severe GI issues for years (constipation and nausea) I've been told it's severe IBS, which has been frustrating since nothing much can be done for IBS. In July 2008, I became so impacted that I had to have half of my colon removed. I drank 2 doses (2 gallons) of GoLYTELY and produced nothing.

Following the surgery, I was still in severe pain and was kept on a dilaudid drip through PICCADILLY line for 2 months. That caused complete Gastroparesis. Which led to detoxing from Dilaudid. Which led to other complications...argh. It turned out I had a horrible bacterial overgrowth in my small intestine.

Fast forward a year...the constipation returned with a vengeance. I was achy and fatigued all the time, to the point I was missing work. I developed a rash on my back and legs. I developed Raynaud's and mouth ulcers. I had to use an enema i order to have a BM. Things were getting really bad.

I was tested for celiac and blood tests came back negative, so I dismissed it. BUT...when my GI started talking about putting a pace maker into my gut, I got desperate and began a gluten-free diet. Two days later, the fatigue was greatly improved. Five days later, I had a BM without an enema. And then I had two the next day. I've had 2-3 a day since then. My stomach, it turns out, wasn't fat. It's flat, unlike it's distended state prior to gluten-free.

So...is it possible to have Celiac and have a negative blood test? I remember my doctor saying "there are two tests. I'm going to do the better one on you." I've had lots of colonoscopies but never an endoscopy. HELP!

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


mommida Enthusiast
mommida
Posted

I do think it is possible to have had a false negative Celiac test.

It is also possible that gluten can "trigger" other disorders. (Eosinophilic disorders for an example.)

Keep a food journal since many sensitive people have more than one allergen to avoid.

Stormy Rookie
Stormy
Posted

I saw in another post someone had mentioned that a fair amount of blood tests come back falsely negative. If going gluten free is helping, I'd say stick with it. The more research I do, the more I find that Celiac Disease can be doing to your body without realizing it. It's kinda scary.

cassP Contributor
cassP
Posted

I am brand new to this forum and am afraid I'm going to ask something g that's been asked before, but...I'm desperate!!

I have had severe GI issues for years (constipation and nausea) I've been told it's severe IBS, which has been frustrating since nothing much can be done for IBS. In July 2008, I became so impacted that I had to have half of my colon removed. I drank 2 doses (2 gallons) of GoLYTELY and produced nothing.

Following the surgery, I was still in severe pain and was kept on a dilaudid drip through PICCADILLY line for 2 months. That caused complete Gastroparesis. Which led to detoxing from Dilaudid. Which led to other complications...argh. It turned out I had a horrible bacterial overgrowth in my small intestine.

Fast forward a year...the constipation returned with a vengeance. I was achy and fatigued all the time, to the point I was missing work. I developed a rash on my back and legs. I developed Raynaud's and mouth ulcers. I had to use an enema i order to have a BM. Things were getting really bad.

I was tested for celiac and blood tests came back negative, so I dismissed it. BUT...when my GI started talking about putting a pace maker into my gut, I got desperate and began a gluten-free diet. Two days later, the fatigue was greatly improved. Five days later, I had a BM without an enema. And then I had two the next day. I've had 2-3 a day since then. My stomach, it turns out, wasn't fat. It's flat, unlike it's distended state prior to gluten-free.

So...is it possible to have Celiac and have a negative blood test? I remember my doctor saying "there are two tests. I'm going to do the better one on you." I've had lots of colonoscopies but never an endoscopy. HELP!

WOWWWW this is quite a testimony- and could really be so helpful to others who just listen to their doctor say "negative" and then never go gluten free.

1st off- your doctor is wrong to say there are only 2 tests. and how does he decide what is the best test????? so many of us have only had 1 positive out of 3... or very suspicious "weak positives"... some docs think the TTG is the best... others now are saying the Deamidated Antigliadin is the best.. and in other places i have read the Endomysial Antibody is 100% specific to Celiac. this disease is so damn tricky and so misunderstood that you really need ALL 3 of these Tests.. PLUS a Total Iga Serum test. it's just too presumptious to just do one test- these doctors are putting money ahead of our health!!!

your body KNOWS!!! and im so sorry you had to go thru all that pain- but so happy you're deciding your own health now- i hope you continue to recover!!!

fairydust81 Rookie
fairydust81
Posted

I really feel for you, it's so awful what you have been through...

It is always possible to have false negatives and like other diseases even people with coeliac, still with gluten in their diet can have negative bloods - rheumatoid arthritis for example, you can have all the outward symptoms and bloods for inflammation are high, but the key diagnostic test can come back negative - thankfully that is well recognised and is now called sero negative RA -

I have been doing a food diary for the last month and this helped to pinpoint a pattern between my rash and the arthritis flares and all the GI issues, definitely helps to show any patterns/trends between symptoms you have and foods that you eat etc.

I hope things continue to improve for you now you are gluten free

Skylark Collaborator
Skylark
Posted

I'm glad to hear you're better!

Celiac blood tests only detect celiac maybe 70-75% of the time so it's absolutely possible to be celiac and have a negative blood test! It's also possible to be very sick from non-celiac gluten intolerance. Trust your response to the diet above anything else.

Pink Angel Newbie
Pink Angel
Posted
  • Author

Thanks so much, everyone! I'm touched that people who I don't even know would respond to my post!

I have an appointment with my GI tomorrow. I'm dreading telling him that I went gluten-free because along with it, I'll be telling him that I'm not taking the meds he prescribed anymore as well. (He gave me Amitiza and told me to drink GoLYTELY once/month, but since neither worked, I stopped both).

Does anyone have suggestions for what I should be asking him about? Should I have Amy tests done, or does it even matter if I'm not eating gluten anyway?

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


GFinDC Veteran
GFinDC
Posted

The only thing I'd ask your GI is to recommend another GI or doctor who understands celiac disease. And then I'd stop seeing him.

They can do an endoscopy and take biopsy samples from your upper small intestine. Those can be checked under a microscope for villi damage. But if you have been gluten free it isn't likely to show damage after a few weeks.

Same with the blood antibody tests, they are no use after you go off gluten.

ravenwoodglass Mentor
ravenwoodglass
Posted

Thanks so much, everyone! I'm touched that people who I don't even know would respond to my post!

I have an appointment with my GI tomorrow. I'm dreading telling him that I went gluten-free because along with it, I'll be telling him that I'm not taking the meds he prescribed anymore as well. (He gave me Amitiza and told me to drink GoLYTELY once/month, but since neither worked, I stopped both).

Does anyone have suggestions for what I should be asking him about? Should I have Amy tests done, or does it even matter if I'm not eating gluten anyway?

Don't worry about telling the doctor you went gluten free and it is helping as it may help others who come along after you. The rate of false negatives is pretty high with celiac testing but the body knows the answers. It seems pretty clear that the diet is helping you a great deal. Stick with it strictly. Perhaps your experience will help the doctor suggest trying the diet for folks that have negative blood work but still have symptoms suggestive of celiac. Do ask the doctor to run a vitamin and mineral panel to make sure you do not have any defieciencies. If he doesn't want to do it ask your GP.

Pink Angel Newbie
Pink Angel
Posted
  • Author

Here is the oddest thing...I LOVE my GI. He's the director of a top university hospital an specializes in functional motility disorders. When I had the hemicolectomy an went into complete Gastroparesis, he's the one who helped me transfer to his hospital and treated me for narcotic bowel. He deals with people who haven't been believed...and he is the one who ran the controversial hydrogen breath test on me and discovered a horrible bacterial overgrowth. Oh well we shall see how it goes tomorrow! (BTW...I was accidentally given gluten tonight at a restaurant, even after calling ahead and informing the waitress that I needed gluten-free...so I'll see if it does anything)!!! Thanks SO MUCH to all of you. I'm only 2 weeks into gluten-free. I'm hoping it only gets better. :)

T.H. Community Regular
T.H.
Posted

Wishing you the best of luck with this one!

Hopefully, if he's this good, your experience will really help him become even better. There's so much information to learn, these days, that sometimes it's hard for a doctor to keep up. And considering that constipation is only recently recognized as a celiac issue (I had constipation, but not nearly as bad as yours. Mine would come and go).

Your experience might end up helping a lot of his future patients. Maybe even some of his current ones. Let us know how the appointment goes!

mommida Enthusiast
mommida
Posted

You could have the genetic testing done to see if you are positive for known Celiac genes. That is not the "gold standard" diagnoses though.

It is also known that a gluten free diet is helpful in treating IBS and autoimmune disorders.

ravenwoodglass Mentor
ravenwoodglass
Posted

You could have the genetic testing done to see if you are positive for known Celiac genes. That is not the "gold standard" diagnoses though.

It is also known that a gluten free diet is helpful in treating IBS and autoimmune disorders.

That is an option but if you are one of those celiacs that don't carry one of the two most common genes it may end up confusing matters. There are folks who are diagnosed by both blood and biopsy who then get the gene tests done and are told that they couldn't be celiac as they don't have the genes. That happened in my family as we carry a gene that is not a recognized celiac associated gene here when it is a recognized celiac associated gene in other countries.

Also keep in mind that there are folks who have the associated genes and never develop celiac. So in the end while gene testing can be useful it is not diagnostic.

mommida Enthusiast
mommida
Posted

That is correct some genetic testing can just add to the puzzle. They don't know all of the genes associated with Celiac and there is still error rate. At least 30% possibility of human error for any test.

Our genetic testing experience... My daughter positive for DQ2 and DQ8. My testing completely negative for any known Celiac genes and clearly not even showing a genetic link to my own daughter. Prometheus would not retest, just rescinded the 98% accuracy and also declared that genes mutate. They said I must have fallen into the 2% range of known miss and 30% of human error in handling.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):


  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      131,055
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    Jlsmith111
    Newest Member
    Jlsmith111
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.4k
    • Total Posts
      1m
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):


  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • trents
      Blood results

      By trents · Posted

      Well, you've done both stages of testing now, the blood testing and the scope/biopsy so there is no reason to postpone trialing a gluten-free diet. And, yes, we get many reports on this forum from people with similar diagnostic experiences that leave them without desired clarity. My take would be your daughter is in the early stages of developing active celiac disease, perhaps transitioning from NCGS (Non Celiac Gluten Sensitivity) to celiac.
    • Heatherisle
      Blood results

      By Heatherisle · Posted

      Sorry, typing error, not strophic, should read strophic!!!! Did it again, atrophic, not strophic, (flippin technology)
    • Heatherisle
      Blood results

      By Heatherisle · Posted

      Hi  My daughter has had her endoscopy and biopsies done but still none the wiser as to whether it’s coeliac even though she has many of the signs and symptoms. Gastroenterologist not 100% convinced as herEMAb blood test was negative even though her TTG Ab19 was positive at 19, lab range was 0.0-7.0. Bulb D1 biopsy potentially looked a little flat/strophic, D2 relatively unremarkable. Also found some oesophagitis and mild gastritis, biopsy taken from there. She has also to hand take another stool sample for faecal Calprotectin which I’ve never heard of!! Als advised to trial a gluten free diet. Just wondering if anyone has had similar results. Thanks so much
    • knitty kitty
      Nutrient deficiencies despite normal MARSH and strict gluten-free diet

      By knitty kitty · Posted

      Welcome to the forum, @Natalia Revelo! Yes, I've been in a similar situation.  You can read about my journey in my blog here. I found most doctors and others do not pay much attention to vitamins.  Herbal supplements can be helpful, but they can't help as much as supplementing with vitamins.  You're not deficient in herbs, you're deficient in essential nutrients. Vitamins are chemical compounds that our bodies cannot make.  The body must absorb theses essential vitamins from what we consume.  The Gluten Free diet can be low in these vitamins.  Gluten free processed facsimile foods are usually not fortified nor enriched with vitamins to replace those lost in processing like gluten containing foods are required to do.  Malabsorption of celiac disease can cause deficiencies in these essential vitamins as well.  Correction of nutritional deficiencies is essential.  Doctors are not required to complete many hours of nutritional education (twenty hours compared to seven years in medical schools funded by big pharma companies).   There are nine water soluble vitamins, the eight B vitamins and Vitamin C, four fat soluble vitamins, A, D, E and K.  There are about a dozen trace minerals heeded, too.  Without these, our bodies' health slowly deteriorates.   Iron deficiency requires not only iron, but the eight essential B vitamins, and Vitamin C to make red blood cells.  The B vitamins and magnesium and other trace minerals like boron are needed to build the bone matrix.  Vitamin D is needed to regulate the immune system, make hormones and build bones and healthy joints.  Vitamin D helps with depression. The eight essential B vitamins are needed for brain function.  Deficiency in Thiamine B 1 and the other B vitamins can cause weight loss, anorexia, depression, as well as anxiety and panic attacks.   I suffered through the same symptoms because my doctors did not recognize nutritional deficiencies.  I had studied nutrition before switching to Microbiology at university, because I wanted to find out what those vitamins were doing inside the body.  They are instrumental in repairing and healing our bodies.  They are necessary for proper brain function.  Nutritional deficiencies develop over time and our health declines on a sliding scale as our vitamin stores are depleted and not restocked.  Nutritional deficiencies can drag on for years.   Blood tests for nutritional deficiencies in the B vitamins are notoriously inaccurate.  The best way to see if you're deficient is to take B vitamins and look for health improvements.  High dose thiamine can help immensely.  Mitochondria die if there's insufficient thiamine, adding to poor health.  Thiamine Mononitrate is frequently used in vitamin supplements because it won't deteriorate in a jar on a shelf, Thiamine Mononitrate is shelf stable, and is as unreactive in the body as in a jar on a shelf.  Other forms of thiamine are easier for our bodies to utilize.  Benfotiamine promotes intestinal healing.  The form of thiamine called TTFD (tetrahydrofurfuryl disulfide) improves brain function, mental health problems, and therefore body function.   Celiac disease greatly affects ones ability to absorb essential nutrients.  Correction of nutritional deficiencies quickly is important because, well, we've seen how bad our health can get if deficiencies are allowed to drag on for years.  We cannot eat sufficient food to correct  nutritional deficiencies.  Supplementation with essential vitamins and minerals is required.    
    • Natalia Revelo
      Nutrient deficiencies despite normal MARSH and strict gluten-free diet

      By Natalia Revelo · Posted

      TLDR: Despite following a very strict gluten-free diet for 15 years, I have dealt with multiple physical and mental health issues for years, which improved with supplements. My gastro doesn't provide any solution on how to improve nutrient absorption because my MARSH is normal. Dear all, Sorry for the long post but I really need help. I was diagnosed 15 years ago with very severe symptoms (weight loss, tiredness, diarrhea, fainting, hair loss, numbness in hands and feet, anxiety). Since then I have followed a very strict gluten free diet. With time I became extremely sensitive and just a few normal bread crumbs laying on the table while I eat can make me sick if I visit someone. At home my husband and child eat gluten free because I can definitely not have gluten at home. Despite physical improvements after going gluten free, my life as training as a scientist was marked by panic attacks, severe anxiety and depression while trying to obtain my PhD and working as a postdoc. 7 years ago I started to have mini burnouts, fibromyalgia-like symptoms (e.g. unbearable pain in joints and muscles) and not being able to perform at my job. 5 years ago while being pregnant my ferritin levels were practically zero and after delivering my child, my body completely collapsed. I could not walk for the first 2 years postpartum due to severe pelvic floor issues, diastasis, bladder pain and fatigue, which led to me not able to work and getting a massive burnout. Unfortunately my GP was very dismissive of all my symptoms. Eventually I was diagnosed with osteoporosis and this led me to conclude that I have been going through nutrient deficiencies for years, if not decades. With the help of an orthomolecular dietitian I started taking supplements and my pelvic floor and diastasis improved a lot (I think my body was unable to produce collagen for tissue strength) and my burnout started to improve (it seems my brain could not work due to lack of nutrients). My gastroenterologist is too busy to take me seriously, and he doesn't believe my deficiencies are real because he doesn't see it on paper (despite me having low erythrocyte counts and low ferritin). I ended up visiting a functional doctors and she could see deficiencies in magnesium, copper, omega-3, iodine, sodium and markers of inflammation and my microbiota is very imbalanced. She also found that I am allergic to milk protein and eggs and those were giving me IBS symptoms, plus there is a FODMAP group making me sick but haven't found out which. The costs of the supplements I get from the functional doctor and the tests she does are very expensive and I have to pay out of my own pocket. It's very expensive but I'm finally getting stronger and I feel like I have a completely different brain, no anxiety or depression, which is amazing after decades of feeling miserable. I convinced the gastro to check my MARSH score and while in the gastroscopy they did see scar tissue in my duodenum, the histological exam shows no damage in the MARSH score. Therefore, my gastro says I'm fine, but I'm obviously not fine. My question is if anyone has been in this situation, and how can I move forward. I suspect that the inflammation caused by milk and egg could have contributed to poor absortion. The functional doctor gave me iron infusions and my ferritine levels went up and I felt amazing, but after a few months the levels go down again. Somehow I cannot keep the iron in my body. I want to know if there is any possibility of healing my gut. The functional doctor is giving me herb supplements that heal the gut, and I tried taking glutamine but it burns my bladder (I have intersticial cystitis). I really need to go back to work, but first I need my body to have steady health and anergy.  Thanks for any help! 
×
×
  • Create New...