Jump to content
  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.




  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):



    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):


  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Help with test results, negative and weak positives


Sanders

Recommended Posts

Sanders Rookie

I just got my blood test results back and my doctor said that it's indicative of Celiac, wants me to try gluten-free for 2 months, if my symptoms disappear, the diagnosis is basically confirmed. I did Whole30 diet a few months back and my symptoms disappeared (abdominal pain, bloat, hives, rash on back, foggy brain, etc), so I'm assuming they will after 2 months of no gluten. Here are my questions:

I have an "above high normal" Endomysial IgA, Gliadin AB Deamind. IgG and IgA (these both say "weak positive"), but negative TTG IgG and IgA. I know that I've read the TTG is not necessarily as strong of a test, so it might have missed it. Is it safe to say I have Celiac, even with the negative TTG and the "weak positive"?  Here are my results.

ENDOMYSIAL IgA RESULT: 1:40 REFERENCE: <1:10 Titer
Above high normal

GLIADIN AB, DEAMID. IgG  RESULT: 25.6    REFERENCE:                                                                                                                                                                     NEGATIVE U/ML <20
WEAK POSITIVE U/ML 20-30
POSITIVE U/ML >30

GLIADIN AB, DEAMID. IgA RESULT: 24.9 REFERENCE:                                                                                                                                                                     NEGATIVE U/ML <20
WEAK POSITIVE U/ML 20-30
POSITIVE U/ML >30

TTG IgG  RESULT: 2.8 REFERENCE:                                                                                                                                                                                                    NEGATIVE U/ML <6
WEAK POSITIVE U/ML 6-9
POSITIVE U/ML >9

TTG IgA RESULT: 2.5 REFERENCE:                                                                                                                                                                                                    NEGATIVE U/ML <4
WEAK POSITIVE U/ML 4-10
POSITIVE U/ML >10

 

Thanks for the help, I feel pretty lost reading any lab results. 


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



CherylS Apprentice

Hi,

I'm no expert, but I would say that a weak positive is still a positive.  How long have you had gluten back in your diet? How much gluten did you eat in the weeks leading up to your blood test?  I hope someone with more knowledge comes along soon.

nvsmom Community Regular

Yes.  :(  That's celiac. You have three positive tests. Many people only have one positive test, or just a positive endoscopy.  Even though they are not sky high results, they are still positive.

I like to compare a positive celiac test to a positive pregnancy test.  A positive is a positive even if it is a bit weak.

The EMA IgA is about 98% specific to celiac disease, so you have a 2% chance of that test being a fasle positive It generally indicates pretty advanced disease too.  The DG IgA is about the same; again highly specific to celiac disease.  The DGP IgA is a slightly weaker tests with about a 5% chance of getting a false positive.  BUT when you look at them all together, I would say your chances are slim to none of the three positive tests being wrong.  :(

I don't like how your doctor said to try the diet for only 2 months though.  Some people go through a withdrawal when the go gluten-free so they feels worse at first.  Plus, some symptoms can take a good 6 months before they even START to improve (usually ataxia, neuropathies, arthritis, osteoporosis and nutritional deficiencies).  Give the diet a good 6 months before judging it's effectiveness. 

And to be honest, even if you do not notice a great improvement, with three positive tests you should probably stay gluten-free for life.

So... settle in to the gluten-free diet, give yourself time to adjust, and welcome to the boards.  :)

Sanders Rookie

Hi,

I'm no expert, but I would say that a weak positive is still a positive.  How long have you had gluten back in your diet? How much gluten did you eat in the weeks leading up to your blood test?  I hope someone with more knowledge comes along soon.

Thanks, CherylS. I finished the elimination diet at the end of July and then kind of gradually started eating it again. The past month or so it's kind of been a free for all. 

cyclinglady Grand Master

Is there a reason why your doctor did not order an endoscopy to obtain biopsies?  It usually is the final step.  Some people skip this step because of cost (lack of insurance) or long wait times in some countries.  

Sanders Rookie

Yes.  :(  That's celiac. You have three positive tests. Many people only have one positive test, or just a positive endoscopy.  Even though they are not sky high results, they are still positive.

I like to compare a positive celiac test to a positive pregnancy test.  A positive is a positive even if it is a bit weak.

The EMA IgA is about 98% specific to celiac disease, so you have a 2% chance of that test being a fasle positive It generally indicates pretty advanced disease too.  The DG IgA is about the same; again highly specific to celiac disease.  The DGP IgA is a slightly weaker tests with about a 5% chance of getting a false positive.  BUT when you look at them all together, I would say your chances are slim to none of the three positive tests being wrong.  :(

I don't like how your doctor said to try the diet for only 2 months though.  Some people go through a withdrawal when the go gluten-free so they feels worse at first.  Plus, some symptoms can take a good 6 months before they even START to improve (usually ataxia, neuropathies, arthritis, osteoporosis and nutritional deficiencies).  Give the diet a good 6 months before judging it's effectiveness. 

And to be honest, even if you do not notice a great improvement, with three positive tests you should probably stay gluten-free for life.

So... settle in to the gluten-free diet, give yourself time to adjust, and welcome to the boards.  :)

Thanks for the response, nvsmom. I was thinking 2 months didn't sound like a long enough time either. When i did the month long elimination, some of my symptoms disappeared (my rash, etc) but I felt like I still should have kept at it. I'm actually looking forward to having a solid diagnosis and knowing that there's a fix!

With the EMA IgA, what do you mean "It generally indicates a pretty advanced disease"? Would it not show up normally at an early stage? I'm kind of trying to pinpoint when my symptoms would have started, i had my 2nd child 18 months ago and I feel like things have been downhill since then for sure, but I can definitely think of other symptoms I have had before that as well. Thanks for your help, I really appreciate it. 

Sanders Rookie

Is there a reason why your doctor did not order an endoscopy to obtain biopsies?  It usually is the final step.  Some people skip this step because of cost (lack of insurance) or long wait times in some countries.  

Not a reason that I know of. I was kind of expecting that to be the next step, but he said that since I've had luck eliminating gluten from my diet before, and with the positive blood tests that it didn't seem necessary. So, I'm confused about if it is or isn't necessary. 


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



nvsmom Community Regular

Thanks for the response, nvsmom. I was thinking 2 months didn't sound like a long enough time either. When i did the month long elimination, some of my symptoms disappeared (my rash, etc) but I felt like I still should have kept at it. I'm actually looking forward to having a solid diagnosis and knowing that there's a fix!

With the EMA IgA, what do you mean "It generally indicates a pretty advanced disease"? Would it not show up normally at an early stage? I'm kind of trying to pinpoint when my symptoms would have started, i had my 2nd child 18 months ago and I feel like things have been downhill since then for sure, but I can definitely think of other symptoms I have had before that as well. Thanks for your help, I really appreciate it. 

The EMA IgA is not an autoantibody response that first appears.  Usually the tTG IgA is positive first - it's unusual that yours wasn't.  

The tTG IgA starts attacking the villi in the intestines as an autoimmune response to ingested gluten.  With that damage, along with the gluten causing further autoimmune response, the EMA IgA attempts to wipe out the upper villi layer.  It's basically overkill.  Something is hurting the villi so it tries to wipe out that upper layer in an attempt to get an upper hand.... That's what it basically comes down to.

You've probably had celiac for a few years but your second child made symptoms more noticeable.  Even if it was just 18 months ago that you developed celiac disease, that's long enough for plenty of damage and symptoms to occur.  :(

Once a celiac goes gluten-free the EMA IgA will return to normal within a few weeks or months, whereas the tTG IgA may stay positive for many months.  The DGP tests generally return to normal within a few months too.

Sanders Rookie

The EMA IgA is not an autoantibody response that first appears.  Usually the tTG IgA is positive first - it's unusual that yours wasn't.  

The tTG IgA starts attacking the villi in the intestines as an autoimmune response to ingested gluten.  With that damage, along with the gluten causing further autoimmune response, the EMA IgA attempts to wipe out the upper villi layer.  It's basically overkill.  Something is hurting the villi so it tries to wipe out that upper layer in an attempt to get an upper hand.... That's what it basically comes down to.

You've probably had celiac for a few years but your second child made symptoms more noticeable.  Even if it was just 18 months ago that you developed celiac disease, that's long enough for plenty of damage and symptoms to occur.  :(

Once a celiac goes gluten-free the EMA IgA will return to normal within a few weeks or months, whereas the tTG IgA may stay positive for many months.  The DGP tests generally return to normal within a few months too.

I was wondering about the tTg IgA being negative. I thought that was weird. Would there be a reason it was negative? Like certain medications, etc.? I'm on Armour thyroid for hypothyroid, but my understanding (diagnosed 13 years ago) is that it's NOT Hashimoto's. But now that I'm dealing with the other stuff, I'm wondering if it is, and they just didn't know what they were doing when I was diagnosed? Anyway, that's beside the point. :) Would something like that affect the outcome of the results? I guess my question is, with a positive EMA, and positive Gliadin AB IgG and IgA, would a negative tTg discount the other results?

cyclinglady Grand Master

To answer your latest question.....who knows?  I tested positive on just the DGP iga (I have Hashi's and take Armour).   My TTG tests were negative, yet biopsies revealed a Marsh Stage IIIIB ( moderate to severe damage).  When tested recently, i tested exactly the same way.  Just the DGP iga was positive.  I know the TTg tests are supposed to catch the majority of celiacs, but not in my case.  I have searched the Internet for an explanation.  It does happen but the studies I found say that toddlers test out this way.  Go figure!

I say that you most likely have celiac disease.   

Sanders Rookie

To answer your latest question.....who knows?  I tested positive on just the DGP iga (I have Hashi's and take Armour).   My TTG tests were negative, yet biopsies revealed a Marsh Stage IIIIB ( moderate to severe damage).  When tested recently, i tested exactly the same way.  Just the DGP iga was positive.  I know the TTg tests are supposed to catch the majority of celiacs, but not in my case.  I have searched the Internet for an explanation.  It does happen but the studies I found say that toddlers test out this way.  Go figure!

I say that you most likely have celiac disease.   

I was reading that too about toddlers! So strange that it's turning out the same for us. Thanks for your help.

Sanders Rookie

I decided to make an appointment with a Gastro, and after getting off the phone with them, I'm more frustrated. She asked what tests were run with my doctor and I told her which were positive, and she basically said that they would run an HLA blood test to see if I have the disease markers for Celiac, but that wouldn't necessarily confirm the diagnosis either, and that the endoscopy is the only way to do that. Which I understand, but she said "most scopes we do come back negative because the damage just hasn't gotten there yet". Then she said "If you've removed gluten from your diet and had your symptoms go away, i wouldn't worry about removing rye and barley". ?? I did a whole 30, so i removed everything, but isn't gluten definitely in rye and barley? I'm getting more confused and overwhelmed. Questions:

1. what's the point of doing the genetic marker testing if I have already done the above bloodwork? If these are showing as positive and my marker comes back negative, does that mean it's not Celiac? 

2. I would really like to know if i have Celiac, vs a sensitity, i guess that is much more difficult than I imagined. I'm wondering how careful I need to be with cross contamination, etc. But I guess at the end of the day, the official diagnosis doesn't do me much good?

squirmingitch Veteran

Stay away! Stay FAR away from that Gastro!!!!!! Rye & barley ARE gluten!!:blink::blink::blink: They don't know that?????:o

Disregard everything they said because they don't know their head from their behind.

Sanders Rookie

Stay away! Stay FAR away from that Gastro!!!!!! Rye & barley ARE gluten!!:blink::blink::blink: They don't know that?????:o

Disregard everything they said because they don't know their head from their behind.

that's what I was thinking!! In the offices defense, I was just talking to the front desk. Not the actual Doctor. But still. 

bartfull Rising Star

If it were me I would accept the original doctor's diagnosis. If he says you have celiac you have an official diagnosis. It will be in your health records so if you ever need to go to the hospital or whatever, they will have to give you gluten-free food. (Although I have heard from some folks here that they don't anyway. :angry:)

And even if it ISN'T celiac and is "just" NCGS, you still need to be just as strict. You can get neurological damage from NCGS if you continue to eat gluten.

And also, you should get your kids tested, and your parents and siblings. All first degree relatives of a celiac should be tested every two years because it runs in families.

Sanders Rookie

If it were me I would accept the original doctor's diagnosis. If he says you have celiac you have an official diagnosis. It will be in your health records so if you ever need to go to the hospital or whatever, they will have to give you gluten-free food. (Although I have heard from some folks here that they don't anyway. :angry:)

And even if it ISN'T celiac and is "just" NCGS, you still need to be just as strict. You can get neurological damage from NCGS if you continue to eat gluten.

And also, you should get your kids tested, and your parents and siblings. All first degree relatives of a celiac should be tested every two years because it runs in families.

Okay, thanks. That's what I'm thinking as well. I will get my kids tested. I'm adopted, so they're the only blood I know! :) I didn't know about the every 2 years thing, so thank you for that advice!!

 

 

squirmingitch Veteran

Every 2 years or sooner if symptoms present and they will have to do a gluten challenge for the testing if they have been eating gluten free.

Sanders Rookie

Every 2 years or sooner if symptoms present and they will have to do a gluten challenge for the testing if they have been eating gluten free.

my daughter has hives on her back and has had them for several months. I'm thinking this is the answer. 

nvsmom Community Regular

I was wondering about the tTg IgA being negative. I thought that was weird. Would there be a reason it was negative? Like certain medications, etc.? I'm on Armour thyroid for hypothyroid, but my understanding (diagnosed 13 years ago) is that it's NOT Hashimoto's. But now that I'm dealing with the other stuff, I'm wondering if it is, and they just didn't know what they were doing when I was diagnosed? Anyway, that's beside the point. :) Would something like that affect the outcome of the results? I guess my question is, with a positive EMA, and positive Gliadin AB IgG and IgA, would a negative tTg discount the other results?

Steroids can cause a false negative test, but that is the only edication I know of that does. (I could be wrong on that.)  

Hashimoto's is more likely to cause a false positive tTG IgA is anything. It is one of those autoimmune issues (like T1D, liver disease, crohn's and colitis) which can give a weak false positive.

BTW, I have hypothyroidism that is technically not Hashi's either. My TPO Ab was not elevated when my hypothyroidism was discovered so I was told it isn't Hashi's. :rolleyes: Apparently my thyroid spontaneously stopped working and grew nodules, but it isn't due to my autoimmune issues. Uh-huh. Riiiiiight.  ;)

That Gastro sounds incredibly ignorant.  :(  Barley and rye are fine?? He's WAY off on that.

NCGS will NEVER cause a positive EMA IgA.  That's intestinal damage. being caused by those autoantibodies and those with NCGS do not have autoantibody reaction to gluten.

The genetic markers are the DQ2 and DQ8 genes. 97% of celiacs have at least one of those genes. It is possible to test positive for celiac disease but not have the genes, although it is very unusual.

I agree with Bartfull about testing the kids every couple of years.  They'll need to do that for their entire lives (or live gluten-free).

 

Sanders Rookie

Steroids can cause a false negative test, but that is the only edication I know of that does. (I could be wrong on that.)  

Hashimoto's is more likely to cause a false positive tTG IgA is anything. It is one of those autoimmune issues (like T1D, liver disease, crohn's and colitis) which can give a weak false positive.

BTW, I have hypothyroidism that is technically not Hashi's either. My TPO Ab was not elevated when my hypothyroidism was discovered so I was told it isn't Hashi's. :rolleyes: Apparently my thyroid spontaneously stopped working and grew nodules, but it isn't due to my autoimmune issues. Uh-huh. Riiiiiight.  ;)

That Gastro sounds incredibly ignorant.  :(  Barley and rye are fine?? He's WAY off on that.

NCGS will NEVER cause a positive EMA IgA.  That's intestinal damage. being caused by those autoantibodies and those with NCGS do not have autoantibody reaction to gluten.

The genetic markers are the DQ2 and DQ8 genes. 97% of celiacs have at least one of those genes. It is possible to test positive for celiac disease but not have the genes, although it is very unusual.

I agree with Bartfull about testing the kids every couple of years.  They'll need to do that for their entire lives (or live gluten-free).

 

thanks for all of your help! I'm thinking I should just cancel the Gastro appointment. I can't figure out what the point of testing me for the gene would be, if my blood work is showing positives for the other things. And I can't get in till mid November with him, so it'd prob be even later than that if I were to do an endoscopy. Seems like a Long time to go before I could cut gluten out. 

I'm going to make appointments for my kids to get them tested, my daughter has had hives on her back for months now, so I'm assuming she's at least sensitive to gluten. 

And yes, that makes total sense about your thyroid just giving up and growing nodules!! ?

nvsmom Community Regular

Are the hives super itchy? Celiac sometimes (unfortunately) manifests as dermatitis herpetiformis which is a maddening rash.  The area beside the rash can be biopsied for celiac disease autoantibodies.  I believe those with dh have a higher rate of false negative celiac disease blood tests too, so if it is dh it could be harder to diagnose.

Squirmingitch is our resident expert in this.  She can tell you MUCH more about it than I can.

Best wishes.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Celiac.com:
    Join eNewsletter
    Donate

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):





    Celiac.com Sponsors (A17-M):




  • Recent Activity

    1. - knitty kitty replied to pothosqueen's topic in Celiac Disease Pre-Diagnosis, Testing & Symptoms
      16

      Positive biopsy

    2. - knitty kitty replied to Jordan Carlson's topic in Post Diagnosis, Recovery & Treatment of Celiac Disease
      1

      Fruits & Veggies

    3. - knitty kitty replied to pothosqueen's topic in Celiac Disease Pre-Diagnosis, Testing & Symptoms
      16

      Positive biopsy

    4. - trents replied to pothosqueen's topic in Celiac Disease Pre-Diagnosis, Testing & Symptoms
      16

      Positive biopsy

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      133,017
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748

    Kayy
    Newest Member
    Kayy
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):
  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.5k
    • Total Posts
      1m
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):
  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • knitty kitty
      In the study linked above, the little girl switched to a gluten free diet and gained enough weight that that fat pad was replenished and surgery was not needed.   Here's the full article link... Superior Mesenteric Artery Syndrome in a 6-Year-Old Girl with Final Diagnosis of Celiac Disease https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6476019/
    • knitty kitty
      Hello, @Jordan Carlson, So glad you're feeling better.   Tecta is a proton pump inhibitor.  PPI's also interfere with the production of the intrinsic factor needed to absorb Vitamin B12.  Increasing the amount of B12 you supplement has helped overcome the lack of intrinsic factor needed to absorb B12. Proton pump inhibitors also reduce the production of digestive juices (stomach acids).  This results in foods not being digested thoroughly.  If foods are not digested sufficiently, the vitamins and other nutrients aren't released from the food, and the body cannot absorb them.  This sets up a vicious cycle. Acid reflux and Gerd are actually symptoms of producing too little stomach acid.  Insufficient stomach acid production is seen with Thiamine and Niacin deficiencies.  PPI's like Tecta also block the transporters that pull Thiamine into cells, preventing absorption of thiamine.  Other symptoms of Thiamine deficiency are difficulty swallowing, gagging, problems with food texture, dysphagia. Other symptoms of Thiamine deficiency are symptoms of ADHD and anxiety.  Vyvanse also blocks thiamine transporters contributing further to Thiamine deficiency.  Pristiq has been shown to work better if thiamine is supplemented at the same time because thiamine is needed to make serotonin.  Doctors don't recognize anxiety and depression and adult onset ADHD as early symptoms of Thiamine deficiency. Stomach acid is needed to digest Vitamin C (ascorbic acid) in fruits and vegetables.  Ascorbic acid left undigested can cause intestinal upsets, anxiety, and heart palpitations.   Yes, a child can be born with nutritional deficiencies if the parents were deficient.  Parents who are thiamine deficient have offspring with fewer thiamine transporters on cell surfaces, making thiamine deficiency easier to develop in the children.  A person can struggle along for years with subclinical vitamin deficiencies.  Been here, done this.  Please consider supplementing with Thiamine in the form TTFD (tetrahydrofurfuryl disulfide) which helps immensely with dysphagia and neurological symptoms like anxiety, depression, and ADHD symptoms.  Benfotiamine helps with improving intestinal health.  A B Complex and NeuroMag (a magnesium supplement), and Vitamin D are needed also.
    • knitty kitty
      @pothosqueen, Welcome to the tribe! You'll want to get checked for nutritional deficiencies and start on supplementation of B vitamins, especially Thiamine Vitamin B 1.   There's some scientific evidence that the fat pad that buffers the aorta which disappears in SMA is caused by deficiency in Thiamine.   In Thiamine deficiency, the body burns its stored fat as a source of fuel.  That fat pad between the aorta and digestive system gets used as fuel, too. Ask for an Erythrocyte Transketolace Activity test to look for thiamine deficiency.  Correction of thiamine deficiency can help restore that fat pad.   Best wishes for your recovery!   Interesting Reading: Superior Mesenteric Artery Syndrome in a 6-Year-Old Girl with Final Diagnosis of Celiac Disease https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31089433/#:~:text=Affiliations,tissue and results in SMAS.  
    • trents
      Wow! You're pretty young to have a diagnosis of SMA syndrome. But youth also has its advantages when it comes to healing, without a doubt. You might be surprised to find out how your health improves and how much better you feel once you eliminate gluten from your diet. Celiac disease is an autoimmune disorder that, when gluten is consumed, triggers an attack on the villous lining of the small bowel. This is the section of the intestines where all our nutrition is absorbed. It is made up of billions of tiny finger-like projections that create a tremendous surface area for absorbing nutrients. For the person with celiac disease, unchecked gluten consumption generates inflammation that wears down these fingers and, over time, greatly reduces the nutrient absorbing efficiency of the small bowel lining. This can generate a whole host of other nutrient deficiency related medical problems. We also now know that the autoimmune reaction to gluten is not necessarily limited to the lining of the small bowel such that celiac disease can damage other body systems and organs such as the liver and the joints and cause neurological problems.  It can take around two years for the villous lining to completely heal but most people start feeling better well before then. It's also important to realize that celiac disease can cause intolerance to some other foods whose protein structures are similar to gluten. Chief among them are dairy and oats but also eggs, corn and soy. Just keep that in mind.
    • pothosqueen
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

NOTICE: This site places This site places cookies on your device (Cookie settings). on your device. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.