Jump to content

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):

    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

How Many Ppm In A Piece Of Cake?

kellynolan82

Recommended Posts

kellynolan82 Explorer
kellynolan82
Posted

I've always been somewhat keen on the science behind gluten and wondered how much gluten (in terms of parts per million) would be present in a piece of cake (sample recipe below, where flour occupies under half of the cake ingredients):

Ingredients (serves 12)

200g good-quality dark chocolate, chopped

200g butter, softened

1 cup dark brown sugar

1 teaspoon vanilla extract

3 eggs, at room temperature

1 1/2 cups self-raising flour

2 tablespoons cocoa powder

1/2 cup milk

chocolate curls or shavings (optional), to serve (see note)

I'm thinking there'd probably be somewhere between 10Kppm and 40Kppm gluten in this. What would you have to say? I'd just be interested. :unsure:

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


T.H. Community Regular
T.H.
Posted

Okay...quick math done late at night, so I'm probably going to screw this up, but I'll try it anyway. :-)

Just looking at the flour, and taking some info. from the web here....

1 1/2 cups of self-rising flour weighs about 0.19 kg.

Flour is not solid gluten, and the percentage can range from around 7.5%-14% of the flour being actual gluten, depending on the type (like cake flour, whole wheat, etc...). I'm gonna pick 12% - average for regular flour - although I know it'll be a little high because some of the flour is actually baking powder. So, already inaccuracies are creeping in, LOL.

So for 1 1/2 cups of flour, that's about 22800 mg in those .19 kg. Which means it'd be about 119,928 mg/kg, or 119,928 ppm.

So, a little less than this because of the baking powder. And then add a tiny bit for whatever gluten cc might exist in the sugar, cocoa powder and chocolate, and I figure it's about even. Ignoring, of course, the high probability that I cannot do math to save my life at this state of sleepiness. :lol:

Skylark Collaborator
Skylark
Posted

Wikipedia has wheat flour at around 80K ppm gluten. That makes sense becasue wheat flour is 10-12% protein and about 3/4 of the protein is gluten.

I'd guess that cake is about 1/4 flour by weight if not less. The 1.5 c of flour is about 185g, there's 400g of chocolate and butter plus the sugar, eggs, and milk that weigh another couple hundred grams. Some of the liquid will bake off but there's easily 600g of "stuff" along with the flour.

I say 20K ppm in the finished cake. Ugh.

eatmeat4good Enthusiast
eatmeat4good
Posted

Where is Peter...he loves stuff like this... :unsure:

kellynolan82 Explorer
kellynolan82
Posted
  • Author

I say 20K ppm in the finished cake. Ugh.

So many parts per million! Gee, no wonder this epidemic of celiac disease is rising :rolleyes:

T.H. Community Regular
T.H.
Posted

Ha, knew I was going to screw it up, LOL. ppm of wheat flour vs., oh, I don't know...the actual cake that was asked about? :lol:

kareng Grand Master
kareng
Posted

Can't really wrap my brain around ppm.

1 1/2 cups of flour = 24 tablespoons.

12 servings per cake - 2 tablespoons of flour per slice.

Sounds like enough to make me sick! Feeling a bit gassy just thinking about it! :huh:

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


psawyer Proficient
psawyer
Posted

Where is Peter...he loves stuff like this... :unsure:

He's been in a series of business meetings since noon yesterday and isn't done yet. One more in the morning. Brain is too tired to do mathematics just now.

dilettantesteph Collaborator
dilettantesteph
Posted

Peter will tell you this when he comes back. Ppm is a concentration. There can't be ppm's in a piece of cake. It's like a percent, a ratio, a certain amount in a certain amount.

Takala Enthusiast
Takala
Posted

Don't eat the cake. It is about 5% gluten.

kellynolan82 Explorer
kellynolan82
Posted
  • Author

Don't eat the cake. It is about 5% gluten.

Naw... :o

Usually less than that (probably 2-3% to be approximate). ;)

kellynolan82 Explorer
kellynolan82
Posted
  • Author

Can't really wrap my brain around ppm.

1 1/2 cups of flour = 24 tablespoons.

12 servings per cake - 2 tablespoons of flour per slice.

Sounds like enough to make me sick! Feeling a bit gassy just thinking about it! :huh:

How many grams is 2 tablespoons of wheat flour then? I would work it out myself except I'm a little far from the supermarket at the moment... :o

Skylark Collaborator
Skylark
Posted

Let's see. I found 1.5 cups of flour was 185g. 185/24 = 7.7g so you get 15.4g of flour per slice. If the flour is 8% gluten, you get 1.23g of gluten.

If Guandalini from chicago is right that a celiac can tolerate 10 mg of gluten, you could eat 1/120 of the slice safely. I can visualize 1/8 of a slice - it would be a pretty thin sliver of cake. If you divided that into 16 pieces you'd end up with 1/128th of a slice. I think it might be something about the size and thickness of a dime?

What do you all think 1/120th of a slice of cake would look like? I'm really curious now.

kellynolan82 Explorer
kellynolan82
Posted
  • Author

Let's see. I found 1.5 cups of flour was 185g. 185/24 = 7.7g so you get 15.4g of flour per slice. If the flour is 8% gluten, you get 1.23g of gluten.

If Guandalini from chicago is right that a celiac can tolerate 10 mg of gluten, you could eat 1/120 of the slice safely. I can visualize 1/8 of a slice - it would be a pretty thin sliver of cake. If you divided that into 16 pieces you'd end up with 1/128th of a slice. I think it might be something about the size and thickness of a dime?

What do you all think 1/120th of a slice of cake would look like? I'm really curious now.

So am I! :blink:

However, I'm guessing that means the rest of your day is completely gluten free. I wonder why the used the /day measure. I came across some documentation that recently showed that (over a few weeks on a daily basis) 1% of celiacs reacted to the 10 mg of gluten / day mentioned whereas about 20% of celiacs reacted to 50 mg of gluten / day. Basically it sounds as though (as long as it is not frequented) 50mg should be safe for most. 10 mg should be safe even if frequented.

I might just give them the benefit of the doubt for this topic and take it from 50 mg (any help with being able to visualise this by figures is most welcomed at this stage ;) ).

Based on the above this means that for the 50mg/day approach about 1/(128/5) ≈ 1/25.5th

≈ 4% of an individual slice MAXIMUM

or...

Based on the above this means that for the 10mg/day approach about 1/(128/5) = 1/128.8th

≈ 0.8% of an individual slice MAXIMUM

This is, assuming that all else eaten during the day contains ZERO gluten :rolleyes:

kellynolan82 Explorer
kellynolan82
Posted
  • Author

Maybe if one were to chew (not swallow), it'd maybe be okay based on the mg/day amount... :unsure:

GFinDC Veteran
GFinDC
Posted

What you do is take your cake and measure how many grams it is. Then you wash the cake in cold water until nothing is left but a glob of gluten. Then you can weigh the gluten glob and do some kind of math thing with a calculator or find one of those friends with a math head who can tell you some numbers about it. This video should get you started on the washing...

And this one tells how to make gluten free noodles at the end. Yummy! Well, non-glutinous noodles anyway.

kellynolan82 Explorer
kellynolan82
Posted
  • Author

What you do is take your cake and measure how many grams it is. Then you wash the cake in cold water until nothing is left but a glob of gluten. Then you can weigh the gluten glob and do some kind of math thing with a calculator or find one of those friends with a math head who can tell you some numbers about it. This video should get you started on the washing...

And this one tells how to make gluten free noodles t the end. Yummy! Well, non-glutinous noodles anyway.

:lol: the problem here is that the cake isn't just simply a wheat dough ball though. There are milk, egg and other proteins present in the final product. Gluten really is tough though, especially in comparison to eggs and milk. No wonder so many of our bodies don't like it. :o

GFinDC Veteran
GFinDC
Posted

:lol: the problem here is that the cake isn't just simply a wheat dough ball though. There are milk, egg and other proteins present in the final product. Gluten really is tough though, especially in comparison to eggs and milk. No wonder so many of our bodies don't like it. :o

Quite true, and sounds lovely doesn't it? Cake, mostly flour (yucky gluten), butter or lard or other fat, sugar, eggs (not bad), milk and some kind of flavoring. flour, sugar and fat yum yum!

Actually i don't know if the gluten wash would work after the cake is baked. That might lock the starch and gluten up somehow. Not sure on that one.

kellynolan82 Explorer
kellynolan82
Posted
  • Author

Quite true, and sounds lovely doesn't it? Cake, mostly flour (yucky gluten), butter or lard or other fat, sugar, eggs (not bad), milk and some kind of flavoring. flour, sugar and fat yum yum!

Actually i don't know if the gluten wash would work after the cake is baked. That might lock the starch and gluten up somehow. Not sure on that one.

On the other hand...

I'd say if you were one of the VERY few celiacs who can tolerate up to 150mg of gluten a day, seeing as though you would need to eat 7500 grams of a food containing 20 ppm gluten, you could (technically) take about ~ 7 grams from that cake and (perhaps) be able to safely enjoy that small bit of it :wacko:

Wacko! I think that's going to extremes (at least for me anyway) ;)

I'll stick to my strict gluten free guns and stay at the level of ZERO gluten for now. It's probably easier in the long run and of course then I can sleep in peace. -_-

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):


  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      132,134
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    Driver
    Newest Member
    Driver
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.5k
    • Total Posts
      1m
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):


  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • Sarah Grace
      Headaches / Migraines and Hypoglycaemia

      By Sarah Grace · Posted

      Dear Kitty Since March I have been following your recommendations regarding vitamins to assist with various issues that I have been experiencing.  To recap, I am aged 68 and was late diagnosed with Celiac about 12 years ago.  I had been experiencing terrible early morning headaches which I had self diagnosed as hypoglycaemia.  I also mentioned that I had issues with insomnia, vertigo and brain fog.   It's now one year since I started on the Benfotiamine 600 mg/day.  I am still experiencing the hypoglycaemia and it's not really possible to say for sure whether the Benfotiamine is helpful.  In March this year, I added B-Complex Thiamine Hydrochloride and Magnesium L-Threonate on a daily basis, and I am now confident to report that the insomnia and vertigo and brain fog have all improved!!  So, very many thanks for your very helpful advice. I am now less confident that the early morning headaches are caused by hypoglycaemia, as even foods with a zero a GI rating (cheese, nuts, etc) can cause really server headaches, which sometimes require migraine medication in order to get rid off.  If you are able to suggest any other treatment I would definitely give it a try, as these headaches are a terrible burden.  Doctors in the UK have very limited knowledge concerning dietary issues, and I do not know how to get reliable advice from them. Best regards,
    • knitty kitty
      High DGP-A with normal IGA

      By knitty kitty · Posted

      @rei.b,  I understand how frustrating starting a new way of eating can be.  I tried all sorts of gluten-free processed foods and just kept feeling worse.  My health didn't improve until I started the low histamine AIP diet.  It makes a big difference.   Gluten fits into opioid receptors in our bodies.  So, removing gluten can cause withdrawal symptoms and reveals the underlying discomfort.  SIBO can cause digestive symptoms.  SIBO can prevent vitamins from being absorbed by the intestines.  Thiamine insufficiency causes Gastrointestinal Beriberi (bloating, abdominal pain, nausea, diarrhea or constipation).  Thiamine is the B vitamin that runs out first because it can only be stored for two weeks.  We need more thiamine when we're sick or under emotional stress.  Gastric Beriberi is under recognised by doctors.  An Erythrocyte Transketolace Activity test is more accurate than a blood test for thiamine deficiency, but the best way to see if you're low in thiamine is to take it and look for health improvement.  Don't take Thiamine Mononitrate because the body can't utilize it well.  Try Benfotiamine.  Thiamine is water soluble, nontoxic and safe even at high doses.  I thought it was crazy, too, but simple vitamins and minerals are important.  The eight B vitamins work together, so a B Complex, Benfotiamine,  magnesium and Vitamin D really helped get my body to start healing, along with the AIP diet.  Once you heal, you add foods back in, so the AIP diet is worth doing for a few months. I do hope you'll consider the AIP diet and Benfotiamine.
    • captaincrab55
      Finding gluten free ingredients

      By captaincrab55 · Posted

      Imemsm, Most of us have experienced discontinued, not currently available or products that suddenly become seasonal.   My biggest fear about relocating from Maryland to Florida 5 years ago, was being able to find gluten-free foods that fit my restricted diet.  I soon found out that the Win Dixie and Publix supper markets actually has 99% of their gluten-free foods tagged, next to the price.  The gluten-free tags opened up a  lot of foods that aren't actually marked gluten-free by the manufacture.  Now I only need to check for my other dietary restrictions.  Where my son lives in New Hartford, New York there's a Hannaford Supermarket that also has a gluten-free tag next to the price tag.  Hopefully you can locate a Supermarket within a reasonable travel distance that you can learn what foods to check out at a Supermarket close to you.  I have dermatitis herpetiformis too and I'm very sensitive to gluten and the three stores I named were very gluten-free friendly.  Good Luck 
    • rei.b
      High DGP-A with normal IGA

      By rei.b · Posted

      Okay well the info about TTG-A actually makes a lot of sense and I wish the PA had explained that to me. But yes, I would assume I would have intestinal damage from eating a lot of gluten for 32 years while having all these symptoms. As far as avoiding gluten foods - I was definitely not doing that. Bread, pasta, quesadillas (with flour tortillas) and crackers are my 4 favorite foods and I ate at least one of those things multiple times a day e.g. breakfast with eggs and toast, a cheese quesadilla for lunch, and pasta for dinner, and crackers and cheese as a before bed snack. I'm not even kidding.  I'm not really big on sugar, so I don't really do sweets. I don't have any of those conditions.  I am not sure if I have the genes or not. When the geneticist did my genetic testing for EDS this year, I didn't think to ask for him to request the celiac genes so they didn't test for them, unfortunately.  I guess another expectation I had is  that if gluten was the issue, the gluten-free diet would make me feel better, and I'm 3 months in and that hasn't been the case. I am being very careful and reading every label because I didn't want to screw this up and have to do gluten-free for longer than necessary if I end up not having celiac. I'm literally checking everything, even tea and anything else prepacked like caramel dip. Honestly its making me anxious 😅
    • knitty kitty
      High DGP-A with normal IGA

      By knitty kitty · Posted

      So you're saying that you think you should have severe intestinal damage since you've had the symptoms so long?   DGP IgG antibodies are produced in response to a partial gluten molecule.  This is different than what tissue transglutaminase antibodies are  produced in response to.   TTg IgA antibodies are produced in the intestines in response to gluten.  The tTg IgA antibodies attack our own cells because a structural component in our cell membranes resembles a part of gluten.  There's a correlation between the level of intestinal damage with the level of tTg antibodies produced.  You are not producing a high number of tTg IgA antibodies, so your level of tissue damage in your intestines is not very bad.  Be thankful.   There may be reasons why you are not producing a high quantity of tTg IgA antibodies.  Consuming ten grams or more of gluten a day for two weeks to two months before blood tests are done is required to get sufficient antibody production and damage to the intestines.  Some undiagnosed people tend to subconsciously avoid lots of gluten.  Cookies and cakes do not contain as much gluten as artisan breads and thick chewy pizza crust.  Anemia, diabetes and thiamine deficiency can affect IgA antibody production as well.   Do you carry genes for Celiac?  They frequently go along with EDS.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

NOTICE: This site places This site places cookies on your device (Cookie settings). on your device. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.