Jump to content

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):

    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Which Test Is Best?

Georgia-guy

Recommended Posts

Georgia-guy Enthusiast
Georgia-guy
Posted

It's beginning to look like my insurance will not want to cover testing without difinitive proof (a bit of a cath-22 there). I have found a lab that will do blood work out of pocket without doctor orders. My question is this: which one or two tests can I get that will be most likely to come back with an accurate result (preferably a positive since I'm pretty sure it's celiac, and I'm tired of the search for an answer)?

Total Serum IgA

tTG - IgA

tTG - IgG

EMA - IgA

DGP - IgA

DGP - IgG

(I know it's kinda bad I'm asking to a positive test, but celiac answers EVERYTHING and my reverse gluten challenge showed positive signs gluten is the problem, and I know my dietician agrees with me, and i think my doc does too.)

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


nvsmom Community Regular
nvsmom
Posted

If at all possible, it is best to have a few tests run because the sensitivity (how many cases out of 100 celiacs it would catch) is as low as 17% in the worst tests (AGA ones). If insurance will cover at least a few, I would push for it as much as you are able.

 

This report shows the sensitivities of the various tests on page 12: Open Original Shared Link  According to that report, the DGP IgA is the most sensitive with a sensitivity of  82-96% - meaning it could miss 4-18% of all celiacs taking that test.

 

Remember that you should have a total serum IgA control test done too. Up to 5% of celiacs are deficient in IgA (more than the regular population) and those 5% can not be tested using IgA based celiac tests (tTG IgA, DGP IgA, EMA IgA) because they will almost always result in a false negative result.  If you do not have a total serum IgA run, you might want to stick to the IgG based tests (DGP IgG, tTG IgG).

 

And you know you must be consuming about 1-2 slices of bread per day (or equivalent) for 8-12 weeks prior to testing in order to get the most accurate result.

 

Best of luck with whatever you decide.

Georgia-guy Enthusiast
Georgia-guy
Posted
  • Author

Insurance won't cover any right now, so my an is go pay out of pocket at a lab, get results to my doc, then there will be reason for insurance to pay for it (and maybe even reimburse for my out of pocket expense).

And I am aware that I need to have gluten, and I'm also keeping a journal showing what I eat, what issues I have, as when. :-)

nvsmom Community Regular
nvsmom
Posted

Insurance won't cover any right now, so my an is go pay out of pocket at a lab, get results to my doc, then there will be reason for insurance to pay for it (and maybe even reimburse for my out of pocket expense).

And I am aware that I need to have gluten, and I'm also keeping a journal showing what I eat, what issues I have, as when. :-)

Darn insurance.

 

Just so you know, the doctors' favourite test to run is usually the tTG IgA.

Georgia-guy Enthusiast
Georgia-guy
Posted
  • Author

Darn insurance.

Yeah, I love my insurance. They are always first on the list to send a Christmas card to. #complete sarcasm

LauraTX Rising Star
LauraTX
Posted

Honestly, if you are looking for something that is hopefully positive and will give your doctor the ability to further test you, and are paying the full price out of pocket, I say do only the tTG IgA at first.  Then, if it is hugely positive, you can go to your doctor and go further there, and if it is negative, do the rest of the tests to look further into it and make sure your IgA levels are okay, etc.  I only say this to you and you only in this circumstance because you have demonstrated an understanding of what is needed.  Anyone else reading this in the future who is not the user georgia guy should not follow this advice.

Georgia-guy Enthusiast
Georgia-guy
Posted
  • Author

Laura, thank you for that information. Is there anyway to know if my IgA would be off? I would I have to do the IgA total serum to know that?

I plan to go get the test done Wednesday, so long as I don't get called into work (I work a job where I am on-call 6 days a week and can't say "sorry, I can't come in today" unless I'm admitted to the hospital)

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


Georgia-guy Enthusiast
Georgia-guy
Posted
  • Author

So here's the newest plan...I'm at the hospital after passing out. They suspect anemia...I suspect one of my post-gluten naps came on too strong. But either way, I will have to follow up with the doc. When I follow up, I will make 1 last attempt to get the doc to force insurance to approve the celiac panel, if that doesn't work, then I will be going out of pocket.

LauraTX Rising Star
LauraTX
Posted

Oh my gosh you poor thing!  *virtual hugs*

 

If you do just the ttg iga first, and it comes back glaringly positive, then it doesn't matter in that sense what your total iga is. (of course you could be like me and still have a positive ttg iga and also low iga)  If it comes back negative or borderline, you can then pay for the total iga if neccesary.  Basically paying for what you need incrementally as you deem it absolutely neccesary as to not bankrupt you.

-once again this only applies to georgiaguy in this scenario and applies to no one else-

Georgia-guy Enthusiast
Georgia-guy
Posted
  • Author

Well, on the bright side, ER lab wotk came back. Vitamin deficiency, suspected malnutrition (I eat ALL day long), loss of 10 lbs in 2 weeks (without change in exercise or eating habits), and anemia. Looks like I may now have enough, combined with abt a third of the Univ of Chicago Celiac symptom list, to get the insurance to pay up.

Georgia-guy Enthusiast
Georgia-guy
Posted
  • Author

Oh, and the blood work results are nothing new...they had my old doctor (called and woke him up) send copies of all lab work in last 5 years for comparison. Turns out vitamin deficiency, malnutrition, and anemia should have been picked up on long ago. Go figure, that's also the doc who tried to give me medicine I'm severely allergic to.

BlessedMommy Rising Star
BlessedMommy
Posted

I'm glad that you will have more leverage to deal with the insurance company. It's just kind of ludicrous how many hoops you have to jump through nowadays to get tested for celiac. I remember getting a gastroenterologist back in the day to ask about celiac testing and they said, "Oh well we might not test you for celiac. We don't always do what the patient wants. We'll determine what's appropriate screening for you."

 

Sometimes it surprises me that ANYBODY gets a DX, with the way doctors and insurance drag their feet on it.

 

Best of luck to you!

nvsmom Community Regular
nvsmom
Posted

Glad things are finally moving for you!  Hope you are feeling better today.

cyclinglady Grand Master
cyclinglady
Posted

Oh my gosh!  Your insurance *%$#S!  

 

I feel so bad for you!  And when you are sick, you just don't feel like jumping through a million hoops!  I can relate.  Our insurance is good (we are self-employed) but our largest monthly expense is our health insurance!  We pay for three people a whopping $22,000 per year and that's is a reduction from $24,000 thanks to Obamacare (I guess)!  I cringe when I think that we have paid 1/4 of a million dollars over the last 11 years!  We could go through our state and get comparable insurance, but at the same price!  So we are stuck.  Actually glad to have it now, but every test is a big hassle!  Like when I asked for a bone scan and did not get one until I had some fractures.  Really!  

 

I hope that you get approval.  I also hope that you were not offended over my previous comments of paying for the tests out-of-pocket.  I do not know you or your finances.  I just think a celiac disease test may be the best investment anyone could ever make if they are suffering with obvious symptoms!  

 

Please take care!  Get some iron in you (at least what little you can absorb).  

 

I'm keeping my fingers crossed!  

Georgia-guy Enthusiast
Georgia-guy
Posted
  • Author

I also hope that you were not offended over my previous comments of paying for the tests out-of-pocket. I do not know you or your finances. I just think a celiac disease test may be the best investment anyone could ever make if they are suffering with obvious symptoms!

Please take care! Get some iron in you (at least what little you

Cyclinglady, I was not offended by your out of pocket comments, I had already started looking for a way to do that. My finances are alright, I'm just under payment plans with creditors that I can't break, and a few ER copays ($250 a piece) in the past month-ish aren't helping much. It's just frustrating that I have insurance but they won't pay $500 for some lab work that could save them many thousands in the future.

As for the iron, I'm not sure how to safely do that without over-doing it. I'm waiting to hear back from my unofficial nutritionist. (Unofficial cuz it's an old college classmate who I am not paying aside from a dinner out type deal since she's working with me on her own time to save me some $$)

Georgia-guy Enthusiast
Georgia-guy
Posted
  • Author

To those that were involved in this post, I got the testing done out of pocket. Results came in today...I have yet to see the actual report, and couldn't discuss details over the phone, I will have to drive back to the private lab to get the report (don't mind cuz it protects my privacy). But...all 4 tests showed positive! I finally have an answer after tons of "nope it's not this" and "idiopathic whatever"! I know it's not gonna be easy at all, but I think I can handle it. It's not the best answer, but it's not the worst either (I've been tested for lymphoma and other "death sentence" Dx's). So, let this new journey begin. See y'all in the "post-diagnosis" category!

Wi11ow Apprentice
Wi11ow
Posted

Congrats on getting an answer. It's always easier when you know what's wrong. And, um, welcome!!

LauraTX Rising Star
LauraTX
Posted

Good to hear there are finally some definitive answers.  You can now add "Official member of the Silly Yak Club 5-28-14" to your signature... lol

nvsmom Community Regular
nvsmom
Posted

So glad you know.  :) And to have all tests positive is unsual! It doesn't get much clearer than that though.  LOL

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Celiac.com:
    Join eNewsletter
    Donate
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):



    Celiac.com Sponsors (A17-M):



  • Recent Activity

    1. GlorietaKaro
      - GlorietaKaro replied to GlorietaKaro's topic in Super Sensitive People
      3

      Am I nuts?

      Thanks to both of you for your responses! Sadly, even after several years of very strict gluten avoidance, I remember the symptoms well enough that I am too frightened to risk a gluten challenge— heartbeat and breathing problems are scary— Scott, thank you for the specific information— I will call around in the new year to see if I can find anyone. In t...
    2. trents
      - trents replied to GlorietaKaro's topic in Super Sensitive People
      3

      Am I nuts?

      Welcome to the celiac.com community, @GlorietaKaro! As Scott indicated, without formal testing for celiac disease, which would require you to have been consuming generous amounts of gluten daily for weeks, it would be not be possible to distinguish whether you have celiac disease or NCGS (Non Celiac Gluten Sensitivity). Their symptoms overlap. The difference...
    3. lalan45
      - lalan45 replied to xxnonamexx's topic in Post Diagnosis, Recovery & Treatment of Celiac Disease
      29

      My journey is it gluten or fiber?

      That’s really frustrating, I’m sorry you went through that. High fiber can definitely cause sudden stomach issues, especially if your body isn’t used to it yet, but accidental gluten exposure can feel similar. Keeping a simple food/symptom journal and introducing new foods one at a time can really help you spot patterns. You’re already doing the right things ...
    4. Russ H
      - Russ H posted a topic in Celiac Disease Pre-Diagnosis, Testing & Symptoms
      0

      Anti-endomysial Antibody (EMA) Testing

      I thought this might be of interest regarding anti-EMA testing. Some labs use donated umbilical cord instead of monkey oesophagus. Some labs just provide a +ve/-ve test result but others provide a grade by testing progressively diluted blood sample. https://www.aesku.com/index.php/ifu-download/1367-ema-instruction-manual-en-1/file Fluorescence-labelled...
    5. Scott Adams
      - Scott Adams replied to JoJo0611's topic in Post Diagnosis, Recovery & Treatment of Celiac Disease
      1

      Just diagnosed today

      First, please know that receiving two diagnoses at once, especially one you've never heard of, is undoubtedly overwhelming. You are not alone in this. Your understanding is correct: both celiac disease and Mesenteric Panniculitis (MP) are considered to have autoimmune components. While having both is not extremely common, they can co-occur, as chronic inflammation...
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      132,806
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    IleneG
    Newest Member
    IleneG
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.5k
    • Total Posts
      1m
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):

  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • GlorietaKaro
      Am I nuts?

      By GlorietaKaro · Posted

      Thanks to both of you for your responses!  Sadly, even after several years of very strict gluten avoidance, I remember the symptoms well enough that I am too frightened to risk a gluten challenge— heartbeat and breathing problems are scary— Scott, thank you for the specific information— I will call around in the new year to see if I can find anyone. In the meantime, I will carry on has I have been— it’s working! Thanks also for the validation— sometimes I just feel crushed by disbelief. Not enough to make me eat gluten though—
    • trents
      Am I nuts?

      By trents · Posted

      Welcome to the celiac.com community, @GlorietaKaro! As Scott indicated, without formal testing for celiac disease, which would require you to have been consuming generous amounts of gluten daily for weeks, it would be not be possible to distinguish whether you have celiac disease or NCGS (Non Celiac Gluten Sensitivity). Their symptoms overlap. The difference being that celiac disease is an autoimmune disorder that damages the lining of the small bowel. We actually no more about celiac disease than we do about NCGS, the mechanism of the latter being more difficult to classify. There are specific antibody tests for celiac disease diagnosis and there is also the endoscopy/biopsy of the small bowel lining. Currently, there are no tests to diagnose NCGS. Celiac disease must first ruled out. Researchers are working on developing testing methods to diagnose celiac disease that do not require a "gluten challenge" which is just out of the question for so many because it poses serious, even life-threatening, health risks. But we aren't there yet.
    • lalan45
      My journey is it gluten or fiber?

      By lalan45 · Posted

      That’s really frustrating, I’m sorry you went through that. High fiber can definitely cause sudden stomach issues, especially if your body isn’t used to it yet, but accidental gluten exposure can feel similar. Keeping a simple food/symptom journal and introducing new foods one at a time can really help you spot patterns. You’re already doing the right things with cleaning and separating baking—also watch shared toasters, cutting boards, and labels like “may contain.”
    • Russ H
      Anti-endomysial Antibody (EMA) Testing

      By Russ H · Posted

      I thought this might be of interest regarding anti-EMA testing. Some labs use donated umbilical cord instead of monkey oesophagus. Some labs just provide a +ve/-ve test result but others provide a grade by testing progressively diluted blood sample. https://www.aesku.com/index.php/ifu-download/1367-ema-instruction-manual-en-1/file Fluorescence-labelled anti-tTG2 autoantibodies bind to endomysium (the thin layer around muscle fibres) forming a characteristic honeycomb pattern under the microscope - this is highly specific to coeliac disease. The binding site is extracellular tTG2 bound to fibronectin and collagen. Human or monkey derived endomysium is necessary because tTG2 from other mammals does not provide the right binding epitope. https://www.mdpi.com/1422-0067/26/3/1012
    • Scott Adams
      Just diagnosed today

      By Scott Adams · Posted

      First, please know that receiving two diagnoses at once, especially one you've never heard of, is undoubtedly overwhelming. You are not alone in this. Your understanding is correct: both celiac disease and Mesenteric Panniculitis (MP) are considered to have autoimmune components. While having both is not extremely common, they can co-occur, as chronic inflammation from one autoimmune condition can sometimes be linked to or trigger other inflammatory responses in the body. MP, which involves inflammation of the fat tissue in the mesentery (the membrane that holds your intestines in place), is often discovered incidentally on scans, exactly as in your case. The fact that your medical team is already planning follow-up with a DEXA scan (to check bone density, common after a celiac diagnosis) and a repeat CT is a very proactive and prudent approach to monitoring your health. Many find that adhering strictly to the gluten-free diet for celiac disease helps manage overall inflammation, which may positively impact MP over time. It's completely normal to feel uncertain right now. Your next steps are to take this one day at a time, focus on the gluten-free diet as your primary treatment for celiac, and use your upcoming appointments to ask all your questions about MP and what the monitoring plan entails. This dual diagnosis is a lot to process, but it is also the starting point for a managed path forward to better health. This article has some detailed information on how to be 100% gluten-free, so it may be helpful (be sure to also read the comments section.):    
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

NOTICE: This site places This site places cookies on your device (Cookie settings). on your device. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.