Jump to content

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Anyone Have Trouble 'stomaching" Magnesium?

Guest BERNESES

By Guest BERNESES
in Related Issues & Disorders

Recommended Posts

Guest BERNESES
Guest BERNESES
Posted

Both my chiropractor and physiatrist recently recommended that I take a calcium magnesium supplement to help with fibromyalgia. I took it at night at first (3 tablets which was a LOT) and didn't feel good, so I backed off and tried again dividing it up through the day. I took one with lunch yesterday and one with dinner. feel sick again and it gives me something close to diarrhea.

I looked at the "natural laxative" I take (Cleanse More by ReNew Life) and it has about 200 mg of magnesium in it. That alone makes me poop my brains out and I only take it when I'm desperate because it means a day spent in the bathroom and cramping, bloating and nausea.

I'm noticing the same thing with the cal-mag supplement too. My chiro told me to make sure it's not magnesium citrate (that gives me explosive D) and it's not but I don't do very well with magnesium it would seem.

Does anyone else have such a strong reaction to it? Is there anything comparable to cal mag for muscles? It makes my muscles much less sore but I spend the day feeling hideous and the trade off isn't worth it.

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


tarnalberry Community Regular
tarnalberry
Posted

Mag does cause D - you can balance that with calcium (which has the opposite effect). Spreading it throughout the day in multiple doses (even if you have to split the pills) is probably your best bet. And taking it with food.

Guest BERNESES
Guest BERNESES
Posted

Oh my gosh- too funny! I was just thinking YOU would be the perfect person to answer this question, came back to my desk and there was your reply! :D

Actually, I have another question. I used to take cal mag with no problem at all 9but haven't taken it in aabout 6 months) but I "lost" my gall bladder :P two weeks ago so that can cause D too. Maybe my body isn't ready for anything "new"?

tarnalberry Community Regular
tarnalberry
Posted
Oh my gosh- too funny! I was just thinking YOU would be the perfect person to answer this question, came back to my desk and there was your reply! :D

Actually, I have another question. I used to take cal mag with no problem at all 9but haven't taken it in aabout 6 months) but I "lost" my gall bladder :P two weeks ago so that can cause D too. Maybe my body isn't ready for anything "new"?

ooo... that's now jumped right out of my knowledge base. I know gallbladder removal makes things different, but I haven't the faintest clue how! sorry. :( It could just be that taking some time would help.

the cal/mag/D I take hasn't bothered my stomach (rainbow light, food based calcium), though one I took in the past has. but I think spreading it out over the day - many many small doses - might help. if not, try a liquid?

if it's not bothered you in the past, though, and is now, I would suspect the surgery had an impact.

Nancym Enthusiast
Nancym
Posted

Magnesium in high doses is a laxative. :P The way to take it is in small doses several times a day, not on an empty stomach. There are some time released magnesiums on the market too but you can probably only order them online.

lindalee Enthusiast
lindalee
Posted
Both my chiropractor and physiatrist recently recommended that I take a calcium magnesium supplement to help with fibromyalgia. I took it at night at first (3 tablets which was a LOT) and didn't feel good, so I backed off and tried again dividing it up through the day. I took one with lunch yesterday and one with dinner. feel sick again and it gives me something close to diarrhea.

I looked at the "natural laxative" I take (Cleanse More by ReNew Life) and it has about 200 mg of magnesium in it. That alone makes me poop my brains out and I only take it when I'm desperate because it means a day spent in the bathroom and cramping, bloating and nausea.

I'm noticing the same thing with the cal-mag supplement too. My chiro told me to make sure it's not magnesium citrate (that gives me explosive D) and it's not but I don't do very well with magnesium it would seem.

Does anyone else have such a strong reaction to it? Is there anything comparable to cal mag for muscles? It makes my muscles much less sore but I spend the day feeling hideous and the trade off isn't worth it.

I take magnesium for helping the cal. to absorb and also as a protector for the heart. Could you try just that for a while and lay off the laxative? Magnesium works as a laxative. Dr. Becker said if you have too much magnesium you get diarrhea. I don't know if that has anything to do with us "celiac's" though. Ha, ha LindaLee

jerseyangel Proficient
jerseyangel
Posted

Bev--I tend to have a difficult time stomaching calcium/mag suppliments. The one that I can tolerate easily is by Standard Process--it's called Calcium Lactate. It was suggested to me by my Kineisiologist. It is available at my local health food store, and the owner told me that a lot of Chiropracters tell their patients to use that brand.

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


Guest BERNESES
Guest BERNESES
Posted

Thanks everyone for your input- I did a thorough "analysis" of my food journal and it definitely seems like the cal mag is the problem. I only take the CleanseMore with magnesium as a laxative when I am really constipated, normally just the cal mag supplement. I read that if cal mag gives you D, it's because of the unabsorbed portion irritating your bowels.

Tiffany- As far as the gall bladder goes, when you have it removed, your bile no longer gets stored there for release when you eat. Instead, it just goes straight from the liver to the small intestine. Sometimes people get D after gall bladder removal until their liver figures out there is no storage for the bile and releases less. They say that it's the first few months (for some people it goes on longer) but I haven't had D every day, just the days I've taken more than 2 cal mags.

Patti- I'll look into the calcium lactate. I also heard that magnesium glycinate is more easily absorbed 9i think it's mag and malic acid?).

Ugh! I've been on the toilette all day and I'm supposed to go see Little Feat tonight. I'm pooped! :P

twinmommy Newbie
twinmommy
Posted

I started giving my twin boys (both with Celiac Disease) a Cal-Mag supplement and they had so many messy, runny diapers. I stopped the supplement but also stopped several other things at the same time and was wondering what helped. I see now that it was probably the Cal-Mag. Have you tried it in several doses? Does that help instead of one big dose?

By the way, I am brand new and cannot figure out how to post a message. Can you help me?

Dana

Mag does cause D - you can balance that with calcium (which has the opposite effect). Spreading it throughout the day in multiple doses (even if you have to split the pills) is probably your best bet. And taking it with food.
lindalee Enthusiast
lindalee
Posted
Magnesium in high doses is a laxative. :P The way to take it is in small doses several times a day, not on an empty stomach. There are some time released magnesiums on the market too but you can probably only order them online.

I take extra magn. and the calc. mag. helps me sleep. They say you only absorb small amounts of calcium at a time so big doses just go to waste. LindaLee

Guest BERNESES
Guest BERNESES
Posted
By the way, I am brand new and cannot figure out how to post a message. Can you help me?

Dana

Dana- whatever you did wworked- you posted! To start a new topic, go to the forum you want to post in like "coping With" or "Sleep" and a list of all the current topics will come up, in the upper right hand corner, it says "New Topic'. Hit that and a box will come up where you can title your post and then write what you want to post. After you type your message, hit

"post New Topic" at the bottom and your post will show up and then a moderator will read it and "pin" it. Welcome!!!!!!

I have tried it in several doses throughout the day with food and it doesn't seem to help so maybe I will stop it for a bit, see what happens once my gut settles down and then try it again or in a different form. It could be that the excess bile going into my small intestine since I had my gall bladder removed 2 weeks ago is contributing to the D. I think I'll just go low key for awhile and take my multi and fish oil and see if things calm down and try again in a few weeks.

trents Grand Master
trents
Posted

I get the same effect if I take cal/mag at the usual recommended dose. You may want to cut it in half and take a calcium supplement with vitamin D but not magnesium for the other half. Also, are you getting a significant amount of magnesium from some other source that you aren't taking into account such as your multiple vitamin? Some people are just more sensitive to magnesium than others. I have the same problem when I try use zinc losenges for a cold. I just don't tolerate some of those metallic elements well from a GI perspective.

Steve

Guest BERNESES
Guest BERNESES
Posted

Thanks Steve- good to know I am not alone. Yes- my multi-vitamin has 100 mg of magnesium in it so if I take that and 3 cal mags (at 133 mg each) I get 499 mg which just sends me over the edge D wise. :ph34r:

aikiducky Apprentice
aikiducky
Posted

I was wondering too if there was some reason that you couldn't just take a lower dose? Try to find the dose that you can tolerate? Magnesium works well as a laxative for me, too :D but if I keep under a certain dose and spread it through the day it's ok.

Pauliina

jenvan Collaborator
jenvan
Posted
Thanks everyone for your input- I did a thorough "analysis" of my food journal and it definitely seems like the cal mag is the problem. I only take the CleanseMore with magnesium as a laxative when I am really constipated, normally just the cal mag supplement. I read that if cal mag gives you D, it's because of the unabsorbed portion irritating your bowels.

Tiffany- As far as the gall bladder goes, when you have it removed, your bile no longer gets stored there for release when you eat. Instead, it just goes straight from the liver to the small intestine. Sometimes people get D after gall bladder removal until their liver figures out there is no storage for the bile and releases less. They say that it's the first few months (for some people it goes on longer) but I haven't had D every day, just the days I've taken more than 2 cal mags.

Patti- I'll look into the calcium lactate. I also heard that magnesium glycinate is more easily absorbed 9i think it's mag and malic acid?).

Ugh! I've been on the toilette all day and I'm supposed to go see Little Feat tonight. I'm pooped! :P

Yeah, most folks I've known w/gallbladder removal had the D go away after a short period of time... I have a lower dose magnesium/malic acid (80mg) supplement I can take w/o any issues--but we have some higher dose mag pills that cause the cramping, D and burning--ugh. :unsure: Those are 400mg. I usually take two of each. For me, reducing side effects is reducing dosage...

barbara3675 Rookie
barbara3675
Posted

I, too, take magnesium with malic acid as suggested by my health store owner for fibromyalgia and I it works also for my constipation along with eating gluten-free. Each pill has 62.5 mg magnesium and 250 mg malic acid and I take two in the AM and two in the PM. They are kind of expensive and I should go on the internet to see if I could get them cheaper, but it is really handy to just stop there and buy them. I also take Mobic, which is an anti-inflammitory for the fibro and without both of them I am in trouble and with them I do really well except for isolated times when I am in flares. Also be aware that sugar is not good for people with fibro, eating a lot of sugary foods if really bad for people with fibromyalgia...direct correlation. My diagnosis for fibro came at around age 58 and for the fibro at 59. Barbara

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Celiac.com:
    Join eNewsletter
    Donate
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):



    Celiac.com Sponsors (A17-M):



  • Recent Activity

    1. xxnonamexx
      - xxnonamexx replied to xxnonamexx's topic in Post Diagnosis, Recovery & Treatment of Celiac Disease
      50

      My journey is it gluten or fiber?

      I don't know if I am getting sufficient Omega Threes. I read about phosphotidyl choline may cause heart issues. I will have o do further research on heathy Omega 3 supplements or from foods. Is there a blood test that can tell you everything level in your system such as Thiamine, Benfotiamine levels etc? Thanks
    2. Scott Adams
      0

      Gluten-Free Cantonese Steamed Fish with Ginger, Scallions, and Sizzling Oil

    3. catnapt
      - catnapt replied to catnapt's topic in Celiac Disease Pre-Diagnosis, Testing & Symptoms
      8

      results from 13 day gluten challenge - does this mean I can't have celiac?

      If lectins were my problem, I would react to wheat germ (the highest source of wheat lectins) and beans. I don't. I only react to bread and pasta, which are the highest sources of gluten. Therefore, my issue is wheat-specific (Gluten/ATIs), not a general lectin issue. I have eaten a supposedly high lectin diet (I say supposedly because lectin...
    4. knitty kitty
      - knitty kitty replied to catnapt's topic in Celiac Disease Pre-Diagnosis, Testing & Symptoms
      8

      results from 13 day gluten challenge - does this mean I can't have celiac?

      @catnapt, Wheat germ contains high amounts of lectins which are really hard to digest and can be irritating to the digestive tract. They can stimulate IgG antibody production as your blood test shows. Even beans have lectins. You've simply eaten too many lectins and irritated your digestive tract. You may want to allow your digestive tract...
    5. knitty kitty
      - knitty kitty replied to xxnonamexx's topic in Post Diagnosis, Recovery & Treatment of Celiac Disease
      50

      My journey is it gluten or fiber?

      I take Now B-1 (100 mg) Thiamine Hydrochloride, and Amazing Formulas L-Tryptophan (1000 mg). Both are gluten free and free of other allergens. I've taken them for a long time and haven't had a problem with them. I take Vitamin A from BioTech called "A-25". It's gluten and allergen free and made in the USA. It's a powder form of Vitamin A. ...
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      133,368
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    Klairep
    Newest Member
    Klairep
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.6k
    • Total Posts
      1m
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):

  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • xxnonamexx
      My journey is it gluten or fiber?

      By xxnonamexx · Posted

      I don't know if I am getting sufficient Omega Threes. I read about  phosphotidyl choline may cause heart issues. I will have o do further research on heathy Omega 3 supplements or from foods. Is there a blood test that can tell you everything level in your system such as Thiamine, Benfotiamine levels etc? Thanks
    • catnapt
      results from 13 day gluten challenge - does this mean I can't have celiac?

      By catnapt · Posted

      If lectins were my problem, I would react to wheat germ (the highest source of wheat lectins) and beans. I don't. I only react to bread and pasta, which are the highest sources of gluten. Therefore, my issue is wheat-specific (Gluten/ATIs), not a general lectin issue.   I have eaten a supposedly high lectin diet (I say supposedly because lectin content in these foods is greatly reduced by proper cooking and I eat very few of those foods raw, and even then, rarely!!) for years. My health has improved greatly on my whole foods plant forward diet. I have asked all my drs and a registered dietician about my diet, asked if eating such a high amnt of fiber might interfere with the digestion of any other nutrients and the answer has always been NO.     while doing the gluten challenge I did not eat ANY wheat germ (since it doesn't have hardly any gluten, and I was too sick from the bread and pasta to want to eat much anyway) I will NOT put that poison in my body again. That was a horrific experience and if this is what most celiac patients have to deal with, I am very sorry for them I don't care if I have celiac or NCGS I won't intentionally cause myself that much pain and suffering it's not worth it.  
    • knitty kitty
      results from 13 day gluten challenge - does this mean I can't have celiac?

      By knitty kitty · Posted

      @catnapt,  Wheat germ contains high amounts of lectins which are really hard to digest and can be irritating to the digestive tract.  They can stimulate IgG antibody production as your blood test shows.   Even beans have lectins.  You've simply eaten too many lectins and irritated your digestive tract.   You may want to allow your digestive tract to rest for a week, then start on gluten in "normal" food, not in concentrated vital wheat gluten. This explains it well: Lectins, agglutinins, and their roles in autoimmune reactivities https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25599185/
    • knitty kitty
      My journey is it gluten or fiber?

      By knitty kitty · Posted

      I take Now B-1 (100 mg) Thiamine Hydrochloride, and Amazing Formulas L-Tryptophan (1000 mg).   Both are gluten free and free of other allergens.  I've taken them for a long time and haven't had a problem with them. I take Vitamin A from BioTech called "A-25".  It's gluten and allergen free and made in the USA.  It's a powder form of Vitamin A.  I was having trouble digesting fats at one point, but found I tolerated the powder form much better and have stuck with it since.   Tryptophan and Vitamin A help heal the intestines as well as improves skin health.  I get Dermatitis Herpetiformis and eczema flairs when my stomach is upset.  So I'm healing the outside as well as the inside.   I take one 1000 mg Tryptophan before bedtime.   With the Thiamine HCl, take 100 mg to start.  If you don't notice anything, three hours later take another. You can keep increasing your dose in this manner until you do notice improvement.  Remember not to take it in the evening so it won't keep you too energized to sleep. When I first started Thiamine HCl, taking 500 mg to 1000 mg to start was recommended.  If you've been thiamine insufficient for a while, you do notice a big difference.  It's like the start of a NASCAR race: Zoom, Zoom, turn it up!   This scared or made some people uncomfortable, but it's just your body beginning to function properly, like putting new spark plugs in your engine.  I took 1000 mg all at once without food.  It kicked in beautifully, but I got a tummy ache, so take with food.  I added in Thiamine TTFD and Benfotiamine weeks later and felt like I was Formula One racing.  So cool.  You may feel worse for a couple days as your body adjusts to having sufficient thiamine.  Feels sort of like you haven't cranked your engine for a while and it backfires and sputters, but it will settle down and start purring soon enough.  Adjust your dose to what feels right for you, increasing your dose as long as you feel improvement.  You can reach a plateau, so stay there for several days, then try bumping it up again.  If no more improvements happen, you can stay at the plateau amount and experiment with increasing your Thiamine TTFD.  It's like being your own lab rat.  LoL Yes, take one Benfotiamine at breakfast and one at lunch.  Take the B Complex at breakfast. Take the TTFD at breakfast and lunch as well.  I like to take the vitamins at the beginning of meals and the NeuroMag at the end of meals.   You may want to add in some zinc.  I take Thorne Zinc 30 mg at breakfast at the beginning of the meal.   Are you getting sufficient Omega Threes?  Our brains are made up mostly of fat.  Flaxseed oil supplements, sunflower seed oil supplements (or eat the seeds themselves) can improve that.  Cooking with extra virgin olive oil, avocado oil, or coconut oil is also helpful.   @Wheatwacked likes phosphotidyl choline supplements for his Omega Threes.  He's also had dramatic health improvement by supplementing thiamine.  You're doing great!  Thank you for sharing your journey with us.  This path will smooth out.  Keep going!  
    • catnapt
      results from 13 day gluten challenge - does this mean I can't have celiac?

      By catnapt · Posted

      good luck! vital wheat gluten made me violently ill. I will touch the stuff ever again.  
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

NOTICE: This site places This site places cookies on your device (Cookie settings). on your device. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.