Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×
  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.




  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):



    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):


  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Gluten Threshold


Alfred

Recommended Posts

Alfred Newbie

Greetings, Folks.

 

I don't have Celiac disease but I have a question about the amount of gluten it takes to elicit a reaction. And is it an immediate response or does it take a while to come on. I'm looking to be educated on this matter. Let me tell you why I am asking. I am an organic farmer in the making. I'm getting the ground on my farm prepared for planting oats next year. I love oats and I am developing a line of products based on oat flour. And I understand that people with Celiac disease are not adversely effected by consuming oats.

 

I've spent the last 6 months or so developing a recipe for oat hotcakes. I have 7 varieties now. And they are all delicious. I've been buying my oats from a local organic farmer. I want to sell my product as gluten free but I can't. I can't because the farmer that I buy the oats from also processes wheat on the same equipment as the oats. However if I test my oat flour for gluten and it measures less than 20ppm, then I can label my product as gluten free.

 

Now getting to the crux of the matter. How sensitive are people with Celiac to very small amounts of Gluten? Does anyone have any idea quantitatively? Or how about qualitatively speaking? So for example if one grain of wheat was consumed by a person with Celiac disease, how would that person be effected, if at all?

 

In the next few days I will have my mixes tested for gluten. If they turn out to have slightly higher levels of gluten than the FDA specifies for a product to be gluten free, I may have to sell them as a low gluten product. Do the words "low in gluten" have any meaning to a person with Celiac? Is it all or nothing when you have Celiac?

 

Any response would be so greatly appreciated.

 

Thanks!   


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



kareng Grand Master

Please don't sell contaminated oats as "low gluten" or "gluten free".  "low gluten" is just a term some people use to try to trick Celiacs and others sensitive to gluten into thinking their product is safe.  There are farmers that produce certified gluten free oats.

 

As for the amount we can tolerate - there were studies that have determined less than 20 ppm as being safe.  Howeve, many of the good US companies test to 10 or 5 ppm.

bartfull Rising Star

"Low in gluten" = poison to anyone with celiac.

 

Most if not all of us must eat certified gluten-free oats, and even then, some of us get sick. If they guy you get the oats from uses the same equipment on wheat, one batch MAY pass, but another one may not. It sounds like you have a good product, but perhaps you should market your product as organic and let it go at that.

 

And by the way, I appreciate your coming here to ask and educate yourself about celiac. So many companies try to make the gluten-free claim without knowing the least bit about the disease. Dominoes Pizza comes to mind. They came out with a gluten-free pizza a few years ago that was so far from being truly gluten-free that they finally made a disclaimer.

 

I wish you the best of luck.

Alfred Newbie

Thank you Bartfull. I am now getting educated! :-)

 

I do have a great product. These hotcakes are thick and the texture is great. I have 7 varieties so far, and more later. I have whole grain oat, blueberry oat, cranberry oat, chocolate chip oat, peanut butter chip oat, ginger snap oat, and marshmallow oat. I never intended to make a gluten free product. I just love oats. I think what I'll do is sell them as NOT Gluten Free until I develop a source of truly gluten free oats. When I start growing them I'll be all set. Thank you for the response, I really appreciate the feedback.

Alfred Newbie

Thank you KarenG. I appreciate your input!

mamaw Community Regular

Alfred there are companies that do sell gluten free oats .... until you are ready to produce your own gluten free oats....

Alfred Newbie

I realize that Mamaw. I haven't had time to process all of this. My focus is "locally grown in Maine". I may have to deviate from that for a while as you say if I want to be gluten free. The added cost however may be an issue. I've got to look in to all of this. Thank you for your comment.


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



jennifer101 Newbie

are you kidding me??? people w CELIAC disease CAN NOT TAKE a chance!!! cross contamination is the "BIG" fear!! because we obviously have to steer clear from all things containing GLUTEN. this just pisses me off! when will people understand that this is not an allergy like pollen or peanuts but realize this is an auto immune disease!?!?!?!?!?

ravenwoodglass Mentor

are you kidding me??? people w CELIAC disease CAN NOT TAKE a chance!!! cross contamination is the "BIG" fear!! because we obviously have to steer clear from all things containing GLUTEN. this just pisses me off! when will people understand that this is not an allergy like pollen or peanuts but realize this is an auto immune disease!?!?!?!?!?

Very few people who are not celiac understand the cross contamination issue until they do some research. Alfred is doing the responsible thing and coming to us for information. I am thankful that he is doing so while his product is in development. You should be too.

SMRI Collaborator

Another thing to consider is that many people with Celiac can not tolerate oats.  I was also told no oats for the first year after diagnosis as well.  I recently ate at a restaurant that had gluten-free pancakes (hotcakes) and they used potato flour.  They were very good!  Maybe look into doing that?

mamaw Community Regular

I agree  Alfred  is  going  about  this  in the  right  way but  as  he  knows  & we all know  there's  a lot  to  learn....... & SMRI 's  post  before this  one  is also  correct.... I've  been  eating gluten-free oats  since  they  first  appeared in our  world  which  has been many years  now  but  I still can only eat 1/2 cup  once/twice a  week  at  best... usually  it  is  once/twice a  MONTH   ....... &  then  there our  gluten-free  people  who  can  not tolerate  oats  ever.....

nvsmom Community Regular

I'm actually afraid to try oats again.  I don't always react violently to being glutened, my symptoms tend to grow over repeated exposures beyond the bloat and headache, so I just don't try it.  My symptoms sneak up on me so it is hard to figure out why I am slowly feeling worse and worse.  Anyway, even eating gluten-free oats is a risk I would rather not take.

 

I agree that marketing it as organic would probably be the way to go.

bartfull Rising Star

Now SMRI just had a good idea! If you could make a line made from potato flour there would be not problem with contamination, and as we all know, Maine grows (sorry Idaho) the best potatoes in the world. Locally grown AND gluten-free. What could be better?

Alfred Newbie

Hello Bartfull.

 

I was going to wait until the end of the day to respond to all of the recent posts so I can focus on work. But your comment was too hard to resist! :-)

 

Potatoes are definitely in the works. I had the idea a while ago but decided to pursue the oats first. And your right about Maine and potatoes, especially in Aroostook County where I live. I love the heirloom varieties (old varieties) of potatoes. They come in different colors and shapes and sizes, textures, flavors, etc, etc. You know it's going to be hard to not distract myself now, with thoughts of how to dry potatoes in preparation for grinding in to flour, and growing them, etc. Thanks to you and SMRI. :-)

 

Back to work I go! 

bartfull Rising Star

:) If you come up with a gluten-free pancake made with potato flour, let me know. I'd be proud and happy to be the first to test it!!

SMRI Collaborator

Open Original Shared Link

 

This is where I had the potato flour gluten-free pancakes.  Maybe they can be of assistance!!  They were VERY good!!  My daughter liked them better than her regular pancakes even.

Alfred Newbie

I checked out the restaurant SMRI. VERY cool that a restaurant would offer gluten-free food! I wonder if they were Pamela's brand of pancakes or they're own recipe? You know I tried Bob's Red Mill GL pancakes and I thought they were terrible.

 

I think I've come up with a temporary solution to my hotcake dilemma. I'm going to offer a Low-Gluten product for folks who simply don't want wheat (but their not allergic or do not have an immune disease), and that would love to try an all-oat flour hotcake. The other piece to my temporary solution is that I think I can also offer a GL free plain whole grain oat hotcake mix. I would use certified GL free oats for that mix. The oats wouldn't come from Maine and they would be more expensive. That extra expense might be offset by the price of the mix. I haven't thought through this yet, so I may be premature in saying any of this.

 

Making an all-potato flour mix is a no brainer. I can't wait to start experimenting with potato flour. I gotta get through the oat issues first and get my website up, and make some sales before I can add a potato flour mix to my product line. It's going to happen though.

 

I want to thank everyone who responded to my post. It's been an eye opener for me. I had no knowledge about Celiac disease or gluten-free except for the very basic, that some people "suffered" from consuming gluten containing products. It's no fun being sick and having to scrutinize every little morsel that you put into your mouth, for fear of getting REALLY ill. I'm glad there are food products out there that you can enjoy and not have to worry about. Once I have a truly GL-Free product available I will let you know.

 

Al       

SMRI Collaborator

From what I understood, it was their own mixture.  I think the Pamela's note on there is an ad.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      130,411
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748

    duddridge
    Newest Member
    duddridge
    Joined

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):


  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.3k
    • Total Posts
      1m

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):





  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):



  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • Stephanie Wakeman
      Wow, thank you for share Elisal!  We do need to stay focused on the fact we are so much healthier without wheat and gluten as hard as it is! I've learned to love rice and almond flour based sweets and enjoy the corn and plantain chips as my go to salty snacks! 
    • Pablohoyasaxa
      I feel your pain. Grain and gluten intolerant. Hang in there. This forum is very helpful
    • ElisaL
      IDK how common it is but it does happen. I'm celiac, allergic, and intolerant to the fiber in grains. (Fodmaps) So not only do I get sick from cross contamination, also gluten free wheat statch/fiber, and beauty products with wheat will get me. While I don't stop breathing the full body hives and short breath are not fun. Then once I make through that me and the bathroom become reacquaint. Sigh if I didn't feel so much better with the restrictions on my diet I'd feel sorry for myself. Least it makes for some good jokes about how the gremlin that lives in my gut really hates wheat. 
    • Wends
      Hi Dora77. “Questions I Need Help With” “1. Is it realistically safe to eat food my mom cooks…” YES - you wouldn’t be here if it wasn’t for your mother. Trust she still knows how to take the best care of you in her own way. Mishaps and cross contamination may happen - will happen on occasion, in fact - that’s life. But for the bulk of it as long as you’re aware of cc and try to avoid it for the most part, don’t sweat the small stuff! See the gluten free diet as a process. Own the process, Do Not let the process own you! “2. Do I need to worry about touching doorknobs, fridge handles, light switches, etc. that family members touched after eating gluten? What about public places like bus handles or school desks? Or like if i went to the gym, I would be touching stuff all the time, so there will be small amounts of gluten and those would get transferred on my phone if I touch my phone while in the gym. But I want to knos if it would be enough to do damage.” NO - this is OCD brain at its best! Hijacking your thoughts and justifying it because of the very real fear of gluten contamination. That’s OCD all over. Like a devil in the driving seat. Fears that are based on some kind of reality are hard to argue with. Boss it back! Recognise this for what it is. OCD using fear of gluten as its excuse to keep you entrapped. Own the OCD in this scenario, don’t let it own you. Normal cleanliness rules apply. Washing your hands before you handle food you’re putting in your mouth is fine. Washing after the gym is normal. Once daily cleansing wipe of your phone etc. Even if you did go rubbing your hands all over surfaces and licking them there might be a trace exposure to gluten possible. But I’m guessing you don’t usually do that sort of thing. Even if you inadvertently were to ingest trace gluten - it won’t be enough to do damage, no. It takes weeks to months of at least a few hundred milligrams of gliadin daily for the innate immune system followed by the adaptive immune system in coeliac disease to kick in and start producing antibodies and cause villous atrophy. “3. Is an endoscopy (without biopsy) enough to tell if my intestines are healed? I’d pay privately if it could help and if i dont get a refferal. Or do i need a biopsy?” Only biopsy, as the gold standard of diagnosis, can tell for certain if villi have recovered. Having said that video capsule etc. can give an indication of any inflammation. “4. Could my job (powder coating, sandblasting, etc.) expose me to gluten or damage my intestines through air/dust?” Assuming your employer provides all necessary PPE - appropriate mask and overalls etc. All you can do is take the precautions that are advised according to risk assessments and regulations of the relevant industry governing bodies? (I don’t know what this would be in the USA. Sorry. But there’s safety and governing regs in the UK for this sort of thing. Assuming it would be very similar over the pond in fairness). “5. Do I need certified gluten-free toothpaste, hand soap, shampoo, or moisturizer? (For example: Vaseline and Colgate don’t contain gluten ingredients but say they can’t guarantee it’s gluten-free.)” This comes down to personal threshold of gluten tolerance. People that are highly sensitive may need certified products. Especially those with dermatitis herpetiformis - the skin manifestation of gluten sensitivity. Listen to your body on this one. “6. Is spices like pepper with “may contain traces of gluten” safe if no gluten ingredients are listed? Or does everything need to be labeled gluten-free?” This one is easy - when following a strict gluten free diet, avoid products that say May contain traces of gluten. But it does not have to be labelled gluten free. There are many foods naturally gluten free. Having said that, there is nuance and personal tolerance threshold. If you’re super sensitive “may contain gluten” labelling is a godsend. But this kind of labelling is more aimed at informing customers with type 1 food hypersensitivity/ allergy reactions. The company is basically legally covering themselves, because there may be a risk of cross contamination. Not to be confused that it means there is cross contamination. In addition to products being labelled gluten free. Many products that are labelled can still contain gluten by the way - in fact any processed products labelled gluten free can still contain the allowable level of gluten (up to 20 parts per million according to Codex). A study was done not too long ago that showed gluten free processed products such as cereals, breads, flours etc. can and some are in fact contaminated and have above the legal allowable amount of gluten in them. While most gluten free products are fine for most celiac patients and tolerated, highly sensitive patients fail to heal fully if relying on processed gluten free products. The trace gluten exposure adds up for someone eating a typical western diet of gluten free cereal for breakfast, gluten free sandwich for lunch, gluten free pasta or pizza for dinner for example day after day, week after week. This is why, at least in the beginning after diagnosis, the gluten free diet should be one of whole real food - food that does not require a label. Meats, oily fish, eggs, beans, natural gluten free complex carbohydrates and vegetables according to custom and taste. Limit fruit as fructose worsens leaky gut and has been hypothetically linked to increased OCD and ADHD - Professor Richard Johnson published study on this recently. “7. Is continuing to only eat my own food the better choice, or could I eventually go back to eating what my mom cooks if she’s careful?” NO and YES. What you listed as your current, limited diet is nutrient poor. Correct it as soon as possible for your own sake and future health! Ditto what others have replied regarding vitamin and minerals that are lacking in malabsorption syndromes like celiacs and need replenishing. Gluten free products are not fortified. You were likely healthier, dare I say it, on a gluten containing diet for this reason. Your brain , and gut for healing and maintenance, needs lots of nourishment from omega 3s, B complex vitamins, folate, B12, iron, selenium etc. Meats, fish, natural fats that come with, do not fear - the brain is made of fat. Limit sugar, seed oils, and high glycemic cereals and fruit like bananas unfortunately as they can cause blood sugar highs and lows that can worsen anxiety in some people. Refined carbohydrates should be limited for the same reason. Fructose and simple sugars in excess feed the unhealthy gut bugs that wreak havoc with anxiety disorders like OCD. White potatoes can be problematic for some, also. It can take six weeks of elimination to see improvements. Note, consult your physician regards insulin adjustment if you reduce carbohydrates in the diet. Dr Bernstein diabetes protocol has worked for thousands. Ketogenic and low carbohydrate diets for mental and neurological conditions have shown improvements. Limited studies have and are being conducted under metabolic psychology and nutritional psychology. In a good proportion of anxiety disorders, mental, and neurological conditions including dementias, the brain is lacking nutrition and usable energy, not a drug. Similar in many autoimmune conditions, including celiacs, the prevailing hypothesis is that gut inflammation and resultant permeability allowing exposure to antigens begets triggering the genetically susceptible immune system response. Modern lifestyle exposure, one of the biggest being the food we choose to eat plays a huge role. Avoid ultra processed products, high in seed oils, refined grains, and sugar. Not just gluten can cause a leaky gut. Fructose, alcohol, egg white lysozyme, emulsifiers, added gums, the list goes on. “8. is cutlery from dishwasher safe if there are stains? Stuff like knives is used for cutting gluten bread or fork for noodles etc. I often see stains which i dont know if it’s gluten or something else but our dish washer doesnt seem to make it completely clean.” If in doubt have your own cutlery set, plate and dishes etc. for your sole use that you handwash yourself. Carry a camping fork/spoon set when out and about if needed. “9. I wash my hands multiple times while preparing food. Do i need to do the same when touching my phone. Like if i touch the fridge handle, I wash my hands then touch the phone. I dont eat while using my phone but i leave it on my bed and pillow and my face could come in contact with where it was.” That’s a classic OCD fear. Nothing to do with gluten as such. OCD brain is using gluten as the excuse here. I personally have the habit of using a cleansing wipe or dust cloth on my phone, nightly, that eases this sort of worry. For example a micro fibre dust cloth will do the trick, keep one on your nightstand? They are antibacterial as particles cling to the cloth. “10. Do i need to clean my phone or laptop if theyve been used by people who eat gluten? Even if no crumbs fall onto my keybaord, i mean because of invisible gluten on their fingers.”  NO. But again these OCD thoughts are hard to argue with. If in doubt, just a quick wipe with a cloth daily should suffice. Normal cleanliness practice. But if you don’t, or forget, don’t sweat the small stuff. “11. Does medication/supplements have to be strictly glutenfree? One company said they couldn‘t guarantee if their probiotics don’t contain traces of gluten.” Better if it is gluten free, yes. “12. I had bought supplements in the past, some of them say glutenfree and some of them dont(like the brand „NOW“ from iherb). I bought them and used them when i wasnt washing my hands so often, are they still safe? As I touched and opened them after touching door knobs, water taps etc. It was like a year ago when i bought those and even though i was eating gluten-free, I never worried about what i touch etc.” Still safe if do not explicitly contain gluten grains / derivatives AND if within the use by and use within dates. “I know this post is long. I’m just extremely overwhelmed. I’m trying to protect myself from long-term health damage, but the OCD is destroying my quality of life, and I honestly don’t know what’s a reasonable level of caution anymore.” Really hope these replies to your questions help. Just remember, in the midst of overwhelming thoughts and darkness under OCD clouded vision, the light and sunshine is always shining above. Take a moment or two when you are able in each day - even if it’s last thing at night - to meditate. Focus on something that you enjoy and appreciate. Or sit in a quiet space and try to relax and tune in to your higher self. Ask for guidance and soothing from your guardian angel. Over time it works but don’t worry if your brain is anxious. Eventually it will quieten down some. Try to focus on a real food, nutrient dense and naturally gluten free diet, this will help your anxiety and future health in the long run. Please eat real food - not cornflakes and sandwiches. Eat a steak, eggs or fish for example. Gluten exposures may happen, but don’t sweat it, dust yourself off so to speak, and carry on with a natural gluten free diet as best you can. Own your OCD don’t let it own you! Similarly, when it comes to a gluten free diet for celiac disease, own the process, don’t let it own you! You’re 18. That’s great. I’ve been managing OCD since childhood (in my 40s now. Many years of research, trial and error so to speak. Diet makes a difference. To quote Doc Brown to teenagers Marty and Jennifer, ‘ …your future hasn’t been written yet. No one’s has. It’s whatever you make it. So make it a good one.’
    • maryannlove
      Unfortunately not going to be able to let you know how Amneal is working because I still have almost 3 month supply of Mylan.  Had annual appointment with endocrinologist last week (though get scripts for blood work more often) and since was on my last refill, she sent new script to pharmacist.  Staying on my Mylan until it's gone.  (I tend to build up a supply because after trying a couple of endocrinologists for my Hashimotos, one finally got my thyroid regulated by my taking only six days a week instead of adjusting the strength which had me constantly up and down.  Will be forever grateful to her.  Apparently high percentage of folks with Celiac also have Hashimotos so all this relevant/helpful on Celiac.com.    
×
×
  • Create New...