Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):

    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Neg Ema / Positive Ttg And Biopsy / Negative Hla

maramelia

Recommended Posts

maramelia Newbie
maramelia
Posted

Hey all!

I have a little boy, now 6yrs, and he has this history: 6weeks of diarhea at 9m of life (dx of rotavirus diarrhea). after that normal life, just with problems in feeding (he didnt like food at all... since 1-2 years0old, I had to insist always, always, for him to eat, every day. rarely he asked for food, or said he was hungry. sometimes complained of stomach ache, and always had a more distended belly. with the age of 5 years, began to lose speed / fall in growth curve for height and growth. With 5y7m, he broke his arm in a silly palying with friends in school, at this time I was scared. And we began to investigate. Idiopatic short stature? > GH deficiency ? inconclusive exs. Hypothyroidism appeared > then comes MY QUESTION:

6yrs > weakly positive TTG + negative EMA + positive biopsy (Marsh type I - just few diminished vili and 35 lynphocytes (normal < 30).

And the weird thing: HLA DQ2 and DQ8 were NEGATIVE!!!

IS IT POSSIBLE?

Please help me...

PS. 2 weeks after GFD --- my child and my husband are on it... Both improved on their gastrointestinal symptoms...

Today, we went to a japanese restaurant, my husband ate (by mistake) a shimeji with a shoyo with gluten...!!! People!!! His diarrhea is back!!!!

I cant believe this is not celiac disease... Just because the HLA are negative... How to explain all this?

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


ravenwoodglass Mentor
ravenwoodglass
Posted

It is quite possible to have celiac and not have one of the two most commonly associated genes. If your son and husband are doing well on the diet just keep it up.

Skylark Collaborator
Skylark
Posted

Yes, it's possible to have only part of the celaic panel positive and lack the so-called celiac genes. DQ2 and DQ8 only convey risk, they do not guarantee presence or absence of celiac disease. Notice that Ravenwoodglass who answered above is double DQ9 and had very severe celiac symptoms.

I hope your son improves on the gluten free diet! :)

maramelia Newbie
maramelia
Posted
  • Author

skylark and ravenwoodglass,

thanks for your answers... im really worried, because all cientific information that i read and study about those HLA genes says "if HLA tests are negative, celiac disease is almost excluded..."...

and i wrote to an expertise physician / chief of a celiac center in US, and he wrote: "probable your son is not celiac".

but at the same way, i think: if HLA genes are present in 98% of celiac disease patients, there are 2% of then without it... so, i do believe, with all this improvement we are seeing in our lovely 6yo son, that my son must have this, or at least some intolerance, something i dont know how to describe...

we are going to wait some more weeks, and we are monitoring his weight and height monthly, to see if there will be some response in the extra-gastrointestinal symptoms (hypothiroidism / growth chart - percentil curves).

Thanks, my friends.

I loved this forum.

Rgs Maramelia

ravenwoodglass Mentor
ravenwoodglass
Posted

skylark and ravenwoodglass,

thanks for your answers... im really worried, because all cientific information that i read and study about those HLA genes says "if HLA tests are negative, celiac disease is almost excluded..."...

and i wrote to an expertise physician / chief of a celiac center in US, and he wrote: "probable your son is not celiac".

but at the same way, i think: if HLA genes are present in 98% of celiac disease patients, there are 2% of then without it... so, i do believe, with all this improvement we are seeing in our lovely 6yo son, that my son must have this, or at least some intolerance, something i dont know how to describe...

we are going to wait some more weeks, and we are monitoring his weight and height monthly, to see if there will be some response in the extra-gastrointestinal symptoms (hypothiroidism / growth chart - percentil curves).

Thanks, my friends.

I loved this forum.

Rgs Maramelia

One other thing to keep in mind as far as the genes go is that not all diagnosed celiacs are gene tested. I think that the number of folks diagnosed without the commonly associated genes would be a higher percentage if they did.

I do wish more doctors knew that the gene test is not the be all and end all of diagnosis.

Your plan to keep him gluten free and monitor his progress is a good one. Since he had a positive biopsy do keep him strictly gluten free.

Skylark Collaborator
Skylark
Posted

One other thing to keep in mind as far as the genes go is that not all diagnosed celiacs are gene tested. I think that the number of folks diagnosed without the commonly associated genes would be a higher percentage if they did.

I do wish more doctors knew that the gene test is not the be all and end all of diagnosis.

No, the studies have been done. Prometheus did a very large genetic study of 10,000 people with GI trouble. 0.16% of the people who were celiac by blood test didn't have DQ2 or DQ8. This means celiacs without the usual genes are 1.6 per thousand.

Roda Rising Star
Roda
Posted

I'm diagnosed celiac from blood work and biopsy. I've never had the genetic tests done. My youngest son is diagnosed by blood work, his response to the gluten free diet/gluten reintroduction and my diagnosis. I wouldn't let the genetic tests keep you from putting your son gluten free and hubby. Three positives is pretty darn diagnostic of celiac despite the negative genes.

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


maramelia Newbie
maramelia
Posted
  • Author

Roda, Sky and Raven,

Thanks for your information. This kind of contact is important to give us more confidence to lead with this disease.

I also agree with Roda, in the case of my little son, we have many features, and just one HLA test that is negative.

Its better to wait and see what is going to happen in the future. Our only fear is to loose time doing another thing that will improve his growth, just like, for example, GH, if his case is some type of GH deficiency or resistance, and not celiac disease...

But at least one thing Im sure: without gluten, both my son and my husband are doing very well.

Best regards, Mara

ravenwoodglass Mentor
ravenwoodglass
Posted

Roda, Sky and Raven,

Thanks for your information. This kind of contact is important to give us more confidence to lead with this disease.

I also agree with Roda, in the case of my little son, we have many features, and just one HLA test that is negative.

Its better to wait and see what is going to happen in the future. Our only fear is to loose time doing another thing that will improve his growth, just like, for example, GH, if his case is some type of GH deficiency or resistance, and not celiac disease...

But at least one thing Im sure: without gluten, both my son and my husband are doing very well.

Best regards, Mara

An endocrinologist can tell you if he has a GH deficiency without him having to go back on gluten. If his growth related problems are due to celiac he should catch up.

maramelia Newbie
maramelia
Posted
  • Author

raven, the history of my son started with the failure to thrive - percentil 2,5 in gowth chart >> then a pediatric endocrinologist, and the blood tests to see GH deficiency were "unconclusive". then this endocrinologist wanted, even with unconclusive tests, to start growth hormone, but at this time the TGG AB appeared, and then the hypothiroidism, and then the GI biopsy (mild positive - MARSH I abnormalities), and then the negative HLA...

so my son has an unconclusive GH stinuli test, and this history of celiac disease a little bit "confused" (neg EMA / mild positive TGG / mild positive biopsy / negative HLA / good GI symptoms response to GFD.

What we're waiting: some response >>> to catch up the normal growth.

Mara

An endocrinologist can tell you if he has a GH deficiency without him having to go back on gluten. If his growth related problems are due to celiac he should catch up.

mushroom Proficient
mushroom
Posted

If I read you correctly, you are only two weeks into GFD. It will take a little while before you will notice a growth spurt, but not too long at age 8, I would think. Hang in there!

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):


  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      130,981
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    Kimmy88
    Newest Member
    Kimmy88
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.4k
    • Total Posts
      1m
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):


  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • trents
      Untreated celiac

      By trents · Posted

      Can you be specific about what supplements you are taking? The form of a supplement can be critical in how well it is absorbed. Many over the counter vitamin and mineral supplements are optimized for shelf-life rather than absorbability. For instance, take magnesium. On the store shelves you will often see Magnesium oxide or Magnesium citrate. Magnesium glycinate is a much better choice. Same with zinc. Zinc picolinate is a much better choice than zinc oxide. Same with B12, Thiamin, etc. This can be critical when your absorption efficiency is already compromised by celiac disease. You should research best vitamin and mineral formulations for absorbability.  Routinely, we recommend on this forum the following combination of supplements to counteract nutritional deficiencies from long-term untreated celiac disease: B12 sublingual, B-complex, D3 (5-10k IU daily), magnesium glycinate, zinc picolinate. If you are taking an iron supplement, drink something acidic with it like orange or tomato juice or a vitamin C tablet to increase absorption.  As the villous lining of your small bowel heals from the gluten-free diet, your absorption efficiency will improve. In the meantime, the only way to combat poor absorption efficiency is to flood the small small bowel with more concentration of vitamins and minerals.
    • Sarawiththeceliac
      Untreated celiac

      By Sarawiththeceliac · Posted

      I did a tTG-IgA test to check if they were high I usually do it a lot when I was a kid but the last time I did it was when I was 12 then now at 17 and they were 32 the normal is less than 7 i guess .also I want to know,I do have gluten free supplements but they are not absorbed well due to the inflammation, what do I do should I wait six month after I eat gluten free food or take now even tho I am not sure if they able to be absorbed and I don't see improvements 
    • knitty kitty
      Diagnosed gluten allergy but not Celiac

      By knitty kitty · Posted

      Actually, it's an opioid hit.  Gluten attaches to opioid receptors we have throughout our bodies including our digestive systems.  That opioid hit from gluten attaching to opioid receptors is probably why some people don't have gastrointestinal symptoms.  Some people feel worse after going gluten free because they are no longer consuming exogenous opioids from gluten. We also have opioid receptors in our brains which can account for brain fog.  Remember that antibodies against gluten attack not only the gluten on the receptors, but also our own tissues because structural elements in our cell membranes resemble gluten.  In our digestive systems, our villi, the anemone like projections that absorb nutrients, are damaged.  Same type of thing in the tissue of the brain.  People with gluten ataxia tend to produce tTg 6 IgA antibodies.  Diagnostic blood tests for Celiac test for tTg 2 antibodies from the intestines.  People with Parkinson's and Alzheimer's also produce tTg 6 antibodies although they may not have Celiac Disease.   Gluten is not just an addiction, it's a health hazard to us.
    • trents
      Progesterone pills - are they gluten free??

      By trents · Posted

      Do you have a soy or peanut allergy? This shouldn't be a concern purely from a celiac or gluten sensitivity perspective.
    • trents
      Untreated celiac

      By trents · Posted

      Welcome to the forum, @Sarawiththeceliac! Can you give us the reference range for your celiac test? Different labs use different reference ranges for negative vs. positive so without that a test score of 32 is not that helpful. And its that a recent test or was it done when you were 5 years old? It is imperative that you begin to observe a strict gluten-free diet. If you will do this, you can expect substantial improvement in your health. I can't promise you that you will experience 100% repair of all body damage but you can expect significant improvement overall. You will also need invest in some high potency gluten-free vitamin and mineral supplements. Celiac disease damages the lining of the small bowel. That is the area of the intestinal track where all of the vitamins and minerals contained in what we eat gets absorbed. The damage to this villous lining greatly reduces the efficiency of the absorption. In the meantime, here is a primer for getting off to a good start on the gluten free diet:   
×
×
  • Create New...