Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×
  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.




  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):
    GliadinX



    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):
    GliadinX


  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Enterolabs?


TJSpin

Recommended Posts

TJSpin Rookie

I got my daughter tested for gluten sensitivity through Enterolabs and she came back positive (73 units, <10=normal). I'm reading a lot about the stool test debates. Is it just that some think it is a test for celiac when it's actually for GS? OR, is it the test altogether? Do some think a positive gluten sensitivity test could actually be negative?

Tori


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Little Northern Bakehouse
Food for Life



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):
Daura Damm


kareng Grand Master

Read around on here. Many people who have a scientific background object to them because they will not publish thier findings. So there is no scientific research or evidence that the tests work. I have never heard of anyone who has sent them tests and not had a positive lab result. Maybe someone else has?

Why didn't you get a Celiac blood test from the doctor's office? If you have insurance, they would probably pay for that. All these various " do- it- yourself" places are usually not paid by insurance.

burdee Enthusiast

Read around on here. Many people who have a scientific background object to them because they will not publish thier findings. So there is no scientific research or evidence that the tests work. I have never heard of anyone who has sent them tests and not had a positive lab result. Maybe someone else has?

Why didn't you get a Celiac blood test from the doctor's office? If you have insurance, they would probably pay for that. All these various " do- it- yourself" places are usually not paid by insurance.

In order to get scientific work published, you need peer reviews. If other doctors won't review your work, you don't get published. Why would other docs refuse to review important work? The same logic that says a negative blood test means no celiac disease, that even with a positive blood test, a biopsy is required, that even if only 3 (of the recommended 6) biopsy samples are taken and found negative, the patient doesn't have celiac, etc, etc. I'm confounded a population which struggled with doctors to get celiac tests, suffered through (sometimes years of) misdiagnoses, false negative celiac results, and often self-diagnose just to do what works for them (avoiding gluten). After all those struggles with mainstream docs, they won't consider important work and testing, because the same doctors who misdiagnosed them and discounted their test results won't consider Dr. Fine's work at Enterolab.

Dr. Fine is a rebel, just like the doctors who discovered H. Pylori (not excess stomach acid) caused stomach ulcers. For years other docs discounted their work. Progress in the medical community must often overcome long standing beliefs, which are not easily relinquished.

Lisa Mentor

Here is an excellent article, in my opinion:

Open Original Shared Link

Confusing the picture further are private labs that offer tests of stool or saliva that they say can definitively diagnose gluten sensitivity. Experts say that such tests haven't been validated and shouldn't be relied on for a diagnosis. "If anyone claims they have a test that is specifically for gluten sensitivity, there is no such thing, though I'm not ruling it out in the future," says Dr. Fasano.

burdee Enthusiast

Here is an excellent article, in my opinion:

Exactly. There are many opinions out there about what constitutes a valid celiac diagnostic test. Because I didn't want to return to eating gluten for a blood test that depends on enough gut damage to allow gluten antibodies to leak into the gut, I used Enterolab tests to verify that I had gluten intolerance, casein intolerance, high Ttg and genes which predispose me to celiac disease. That info, along with my history of symptoms, convinced both my HMO PC and my naturopath that I have celiac disease. Elab tests may not qualify as the 'gold standard'.patients However patients, who have celiac disease symptoms for years, while they are misdiagnosed, discounted and dismissed, may prefer information which supports their decision to do what they already know works for them (avoiding gluten), rather than continue to eat gluten to support tests flawed by many false negative results (both blood and biopsy tests for celiac).

Skylark Collaborator

The problem with Enterolab is that their own data show that fecal anti-gliadin is a poor predictor of feeling better on the diet. :rolleyes: There is also a peer-reviewed study showing fecal AGA appearing and disappearing in the stools of healthy people who are able to eat wheat comfortably. In addition, when Enterolab tested healthy people they got a very high 30% false positive rate on fecal AGA.

If your daughter has fecal TTG that's more meaningful and she may be celiac.

Burdee, you seem to have some misunderstandings about peer review. It is a quality check, where another scientist reads the manuscript and makes sure there are no major issues with the study. If a study can't get into a peer reviewed journal it's generally because the work either shows nothing new (not the case with Enterolab) or is so flawed as to be meaningless.

TJSpin Rookie

Thanks everyone. I had her tested for gluten sensitivity through Enterolabs because of the ease of the stool test. She's 6 and if I could avoid a blood draw, I would. I am talking to my doc about the blood test but don't we all know how unreliable that is, at least for celiac diagnosis. Is the blood test more reliable for gluten sensitivity testing? Also, being 6 I just wonder how destroyed her intestines could really be? She shows no gut issues but does have tooth enamel issues and geographic tongue. She's the shortest in every class she's in but so are her dad and I. I don't think a removal test would work for her...although we are doing what we can/know to be 100% free of gluten. So, basically, we could be going through all of this worrying for nothing (not that we would eat gluten anyway)?


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Food for Life
Lakefront Brewery



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):
Holidaily Brewing Co.


Skylark Collaborator

Did she have TTG at Enterolab or only anti-gliadin? If she only has anti-gliadin I'm sorry to say it, but she needs the blood draw. The blood test is not as sensitive as one would hope, but it will catch 3 out of 4 cases of celiac so it's well worth doing. Unlike Enterolab, false positives are pretty rare on the blood tests.

If she has no GI issues at all and her short stature is genetic, I am not sure she has that many symptoms of celiac. The poor tooth enamel can be caused by malabsorption, but it can also be caused by diet (a lot of food kids eat these days is very nutrient-poor and loaded with sugar) or overuse of antibiotics. I think of geographic tongue as a sign of allergies more than celiac, though I could be mistaken. When you get her celiac test, you might want to see if the doctor will test her for deficiencies including calcium, vitamin D, B12, and folic acid. If she has deficiencies you have better evidence for malabsorption.

I'm sorry but the only accurate way to test for gluten sensitivity is a strict trial of the gluten-free diet. As that WSJ article Lisa posted points out, there is no accurate diagnostic test available right now. What you have to do is rule out celiac by blood and possibly biopsy and then put her on the diet to see how she does.

TJSpin Rookie

If she has no GI issues at all and her short stature is genetic, I am not sure she has that many symptoms of celiac. The poor tooth enamel can be caused by malabsorption, but it can also be caused by diet (a lot of food kids eat these days is very nutrient-poor and loaded with sugar) or overuse of antibiotics. I think of geographic tongue as a sign of allergies more than celiac, though I could be mistaken. When you get her celiac test, you might want to see if the doctor will test her for deficiencies including calcium, vitamin D, B12, and folic acid. If she has deficiencies you have better evidence for malabsorption.

I listen to Dr. Tom O'Bryan and he states that only 1 in 8 have the gastrointestional symptoms- 1 of 8 have the silent signs. This is theOpen Original Shared Linkfrom the New England Journal of Medicine that got me interested in testing. There seems to be a possible link. Also, I have read that it can be caused by a Vit. B12 deficiency. So, my thought process was that if she had intestional issues, she may not absorb it well enough. Also, I wrote to Cyrex Labs and they thought it was worth testing. Those things were what made me get her tested. I guess I'll have to go with the blood test, then! Thanks for you information, everyone!!!

Skylark Collaborator

Hopefully you'll get your answers. :) Be sure to prod your Dr. for the vitamin testing so she only has to go through one blood draw.

TJSpin Rookie

Hopefully you'll get your answers. :) Be sure to prod your Dr. for the vitamin testing so she only has to go through one blood draw.

Thanks, will do!

Lori2 Contributor

If your daughter has fecal TTG that's more meaningful and she may be celiac.

I had a high TTG reading from Enterolab (86, negative is less than 20) but I do not have either of the celiac genes. So is this anything to be concerned about?

Skylark Collaborator

I had a high TTG reading from Enterolab (86, negative is less than 20) but I do not have either of the celiac genes. So is this anything to be concerned about?

If I had that reading I would be concerned. The evidence for fecal TTG being abnormal in the literature is much more convincing than that for AGA and you are well above the negative reading. Problem is, fecal TTG is not specific for celiac. It can appear in inflammatory bowel diseases like Crohn's and ulcerative colitis.

https://www.celiac.com/articles/870/1/Anti-Tissue-Transglutaminase-tTG-Antibodies-Also-Found-in-Inflammatory-Bowel-Disease/Page1.html

Celiac is absolutely possible without the celiac genes, but Crohn's Disease or UC is statistically more likely. :( I remember a post from someone who was really angry with Enterolab. She had fecal TTG and went gluten-free but she was still ill. Eventually she was diagnosed correctly with Crohn's. Enterolab hadn't mentioned the possibility to her and she suffered unnecessarily for an extra year.

If you're still having stomach or bowel trouble on a strict gluten-free diet, you need a thorough workup by a good GI doc.

Lori2 Contributor

If you're still having stomach or bowel trouble on a strict gluten-free diet, you need a thorough workup by a good GI doc.

My GI's advice--"Eat what you want and take Imodium".

Skylark Collaborator

My GI's advice--"Eat what you want and take Imodium".

OMG you poor thing. That's awful. You need another GI. :(

Lori2 Contributor

That test was a year and a half ago. I've been gluten free for the past year. I just sent a second fecal sample to Enterolab to get a current reading and see if there has been any improvement. Diarrhea very much improved gluten free.

burdee Enthusiast

Did she have TTG at Enterolab or only anti-gliadin? If she only has anti-gliadin I'm sorry to say it, but she needs the blood draw. The blood test is not as sensitive as one would hope, but it will catch 3 out of 4 cases of celiac so it's well worth doing. Unlike Enterolab, false positives are pretty rare on the blood tests.

If she has no GI issues at all and her short stature is genetic, I am not sure she has that many symptoms of celiac. The poor tooth enamel can be caused by malabsorption, but it can also be caused by diet (a lot of food kids eat these days is very nutrient-poor and loaded with sugar) or overuse of antibiotics. I think of geographic tongue as a sign of allergies more than celiac, though I could be mistaken. When you get her celiac test, you might want to see if the doctor will test her for deficiencies including calcium, vitamin D, B12, and folic acid. If she has deficiencies you have better evidence for malabsorption.

I'm sorry but the only accurate way to test for gluten sensitivity is a strict trial of the gluten-free diet. As that WSJ article Lisa posted points out, there is no accurate diagnostic test available right now. What you have to do is rule out celiac by blood and possibly biopsy and then put her on the diet to see how she does.

I totally agree with trying the gluten free diet. However, some people need more incentive than just feeling better. I actually was on a gluten free diet for 3 months before I took Elab tests. I knew I felt better, but I needed something to convince my doctors. I also did not want to return to excruciating gut pain and bloating by eating gluten to prepare for a blood test.

I didn't have diarrhea (because I also had undiagnosed Hashimoto's thyroiditis which causes constipation) but I was short underweight and had low energy along with many other common celiac symptoms. However, without that diarrhea symptom, my doc and even one naturopath told me I just had 'ibs', because they followed the rigid profile of diarrhea, underweight, short and fatigued, as celiac symptoms. BTW my mainstream doc also ignored my Hashimoto's symptoms (low blood pressure, cold all the time, horrible fingernails, etc.) because I was not overweight (a common sign of hypothyroidism).

My doctors' rigidity made them ignore my symptoms for 2 diseases for many years (since childhood). Maybe that makes me more open to alternative testing methods used by Enterolab, despite lack of support from the traditional medical community (which ignored my celiac and hypothyroid symptoms for 35 years). I may be mistaken, but I didn't want to use testing methods promoted by the traditioal medical community, which misdiagnosed and/or discounted my symptoms all those years.

  • 2 weeks later...
Lori2 Contributor

If I had that reading I would be concerned. The evidence for fecal TTG being abnormal in the literature is much more convincing than that for AGA and you are well above the negative reading. Problem is, fecal TTG is not specific for celiac. It can appear in inflammatory bowel diseases like Crohn's and ulcerative colitis.

https://www.celiac.com/articles/870/1/Anti-Tissue-Transglutaminase-tTG-Antibodies-Also-Found-in-Inflammatory-Bowel-Disease/Page1.html

Celiac is absolutely possible without the celiac genes, but Crohn's Disease or UC is statistically more likely. :( I remember a post from someone who was really angry with Enterolab. She had fecal TTG and went gluten-free but she was still ill. Eventually she was diagnosed correctly with Crohn's. Enterolab hadn't mentioned the possibility to her and she suffered unnecessarily for an extra year.

If you're still having stomach or bowel trouble on a strict gluten-free diet, you need a thorough workup by a good GI doc.

This was your reply to my posting about my fecal tTG testing in July, 2010. At that time it was 86 units (negative below 10 units). I just redid the test and the tTG has dropped to 12 units. I have been gluten-free for a year so I think this means I'm making progress. Might this possibly mean that, even though my blood tests were negative, I might actually be celiac?

Skylark Collaborator

This was your reply to my posting about my fecal tTG testing in July, 2010. At that time it was 86 units (negative below 10 units). I just redid the test and the tTG has dropped to 12 units. I have been gluten-free for a year so I think this means I'm making progress. Might this possibly mean that, even though my blood tests were negative, I might actually be celiac?

Boy, that's encouraging! If you're feeling a lot better off gluten and a lot of celiac symptoms resolved I'd sure be thinking in that direction if I were you. B)

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):
    Food for Life



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      130,307
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748

    JenLo
    Newest Member
    JenLo
    Joined

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):
    GliadinX


  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.3k
    • Total Posts
      1m

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):
    GliadinX




  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):
    Authentic Foods



  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • TheFuzz
      I had similar pains after going gluten-free.  Turns out it was more related to undiagnosed rheumatoid arthritis and fibromyalgia.  Because celiac is an immune dysfunction disease, it's possible you have another underlying one.  I wish mine had been identified much sooner, so you may want to look at symptoms of diseases like RA and lupus to see if you have other symptoms that might point you in the right direction to ask the right questions.
    • lmemsm
      When they give you a blood test, there's a range they consider low to high from the results.  It's not based on how much vitamin you're taking.  My blood tests were low and then I took 5000 IU and they went too high on the blood test.  I also get exposed to D from the sun and I live in a very sunny area and I get D in some foods I eat.  I was very annoyed with the doctors because they weren't paying attention to the blood test results in order to help me figure out the optimum dose for me.  They just told me to take it when it was low on the blood test and didn't pay any attention after that.  Too much of a good thing is not a good a thing.  I hope the medical field knows enough to really know what the safe range is.  However, I would not go by just intake or sun exposure since how much each person can absorb is different.  That's why I wanted actual testing to determine my levels. Also, interesting points, about the choline.  I just saw some information about it yesterday and was thinking I'd better check if I'm getting the RDA.  This is the second mention I've seen on this in two days, so maybe the universe is trying to tell me something. If I get cramps in my feet, salt usually helps with it.  It usually means my electrolyte levels are off somehow.  I bought some electrolyte water from Sprouts.  I also try to add salt (Himalayan or sea) to my meals.  I always hear cut out salt from medical professionals.  I don't think they realize that when you make things from scratch and eat unprocessed foods, you've probably cut out a lot of the salt in an average American diet.  It can be easy to be too low on salt if you make things yourself. I've read selenium is important to balance iodine intake and one shouldn't have too much of one and not enough of the other.
    • Wheatwacked
      How high is too high?  I take 10,000 IU vitamin D3 every day.  My blood is stable at 80 ng/ml (200 nmol/L).  Even at 10,000 a day it took 8 years to raise it to 80.  Higher levels of 25(OH)D in blood can moderate the autoimmune attack.  Vitamin D Is Not as Toxic as Was Once Thought Lower vitamin D levels have also been associated with increased OCD symptom severity.  This is a most dangerous popular belief. As mentioned you are suffering from vitamin and mineral deficiencies.  Part of the recovery, that is never explained by doctors, is replenishing your deficits.  Celiac Disease is a disease of malabsorption.  The Western diet is a diet of deficiency.  That is why many processed foods are fortified.  Gluten free foods are exempt.   "I’ve been completely asymptomatic since diagnosis."  There are 200 symptoms that can be caused by Celiac Disease and the malabsorbtion it can cause.     • "Floating, undigested stools for over a year now. Dont think its related to celiac as it was like this since im 17 and not 13-16( i got diagnosed at 13). " Many are misdiagnosed as gall bladder disease.  Choline is needed to create the bile salts needed to digest fat.  90% of our population is deficient.  Eggs and beef are the best source.  The RDA (minimum daily allowance is 500 mg to 3500 mg daily.  One egg has 27% DV.  Broccoli, chopped, boiled, drained, ½ cup only has 7%.  Low choline can cause Non Alcoholic Fatty Liver Disease.   Choline and Risk of Neural Tube Defects in a Folate-fortified Population; Could we be overlooking a potential choline crisis in the United Kingdom?;   Choline was formerly called vitamin B4.  I prefer phoshphatidyl choline for supplementation as it is the form we get in food.   • Chronic back pain started gradually, worsens with movement, lots of cracking/popping sounds.  Vitamin D deficiency may be linked to chronic back pain, But I took levothyroxine for slightly low FT4 levels.  I supplement Iodine by taking Liquid Iodine.  50 mcg per drop.  The RDA is 150 mcg to 1000 mcg in the US.  In Japan it is 150 mcg to 3000 mcg.  I take 600 mcg a day. Since 1970 the intake of iodine has decreased in the US by 50%.  Hypothyroidism has increased 50%.  Insufficient iodine leads to the thyroid gland working harder to produce these hormones, and if it cannot keep up, hypothyroidism can develop, according to the Mayo Clinic.   Iodine Insufficiency in America: The Neglected Pandemic.   I see improvement in muscle tone, healing, brain fog since taking the Liquid Iodine.  I could not eat enough seaweed. B1 stops the cramps in my feet B6 speeds up gastric empying and works on my freezing toes at night.  250 mg several times a day sometimes.  Also seems to be helping bowel regularity. 5 mg Lithium Orotate helped me with overthinking.   10,000 IU vitamin D to control autoimmune, mental health. 500 mg Thiamine - neurologic symptoms 500 mg Nicotinic Acid - increase capillary blood flow 500 mg Pantothenic Acid - creates energy from glucose Krebs Cycle 1000 mcg B12 - creates hemoglobin for oxygen transport 500 mg Taurine - essential amino acid, a powerful antioxident that we make indogenously so it is officially labeled "Conditional Essential" as Choline used to be, but not enough when sickness increases inflammation. reduces Reactivite Oxygen Species (ROS are are free radicals.). 840 mg Phosphatidly Choline x 3 - essential for fat digestion, gall bladder, liver, brain fog, cell membranes, prevent congenital spinal defects (along with B6, B12, folate, Taurine. Iodine - muscle tone, testosterone, hyper and hypo thyroid, slow healing.  600 mcg of Liquid Iodine.  Sometimes twice a day, usually added to a drink.
    • Scott Adams
      I completely understand the frustration of finding reliable gluten-free ingredients—it's exhausting when trusted products disappear or companies don't respond to safety inquiries. For teff flour in bulk, check out Azure Standard or Bulk Foods; both often carry gluten-free grains in larger quantities and clearly label dedicated facilities. For soy flour, Anthony's Goods tests for gluten and offers bulk options, though always verify their current certifications. For beans, peas, and lentils, Palouse Brand is a great choice—they're GFCO-certified and transparent about their farming practices. As for lentil elbow macaroni, Explore Cuisine offers similar pastas, though cross-contact policies vary. When companies don't respond, I lean on third-party certifications (GFCO, NSF) or stick with brands like Jovial or Edward & Sons that prioritize allergen safety. It's a constant hunt, but hopefully these leads help! Have you tried local co-ops or ethnic markets for teff? Sometimes they stock bulk African or Indian brands with clear labeling.
    • Scott Adams
      Beans in desserts are a fantastic way to add moisture, structure, and protein while keeping recipes gluten-free. Black bean brownies are a classic, but other beans like adzuki and pinto can also work well—adzuki beans are naturally sweet and often used in Asian desserts, making them great for cookies or cakes. Lentils, especially red lentils, blend smoothly into batters and can replace flour in recipes like blondies or muffins. Since you’re allergic to chickpeas, you might try navy beans or cannellini beans for a milder flavor in vanilla-based desserts. For less crumbliness, blending cooked beans into a paste helps bind the dough, and adding a bit of xanthan gum (if tolerated) can improve texture. If you’re experimenting, start with recipes that replace half the flour with bean purée before going fully flourless. Have you tried using aquafaba (bean liquid) as an egg substitute? It works wonders in gluten-free baking too!
×
×
  • Create New...