Jump to content
  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):
  • Join Our eNewsletter:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Terrible Neurological Symptoms


HectorConvector

Recommended Posts

Jackie Garrett Collaborator
10 hours ago, Scott Adams said:

As far as I know @HectorConvector hasn't been diagnosed with lactic acidosis, and before altering your diet to treat something you haven't been diagnosed with, it would be best to first get tested for it. According to this article "Lactic acidosis is diagnosed through a fasting blood test."

https://www.healthline.com/health/lactic-acidosis#diagnosis

@Jackie Garrett have you been tested for lactic acidosis and diagnosed with it? I have no doubt that the diet seems to have helped you, but there is a difference between being self-diagnosed and officially diagnosed with something. Also, it seems that due to your personal lactic acidosis condition, you now seem to see that as a common in others here on a celiac disease forum, which isn't necessarily the case. Lactic acidosis is a rare, and potentially fatal condition, if left untreated.

Lactose intolerance affects many, many people I never connected it to my symptoms, it was only when I increased my milk intake that I noticed my symptoms and pain/ inflammation got really bad it was only then that I thought what have I been doing lately that’s different and it was increasing the milk, so I removed Dairy and others things that had Lactic/ Citric acid in and everything got better, no Dr. found this out, I was never offered a Anion Test, I only ever had a standard blood test in previous years, I hadn’t heard of an Anion gap blood test until recently. But by removing the acids I got well, and because Hector has some symptoms similar to mine and the Drs. don’t seem to have an answer for him at the moment, I just thought maybe he could start removing the things contain Lactose/ Lactic acid just to see if it helps him if nothing else is working, it helped me, I know I would still be having so many symptoms if I hadn’t done this, like I said before this may or may not be Hectors case, it’s just something to consider if he’s not getting better.


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



  • Replies 344
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • HectorConvector

    118

  • Jackie Garrett

    67

  • knitty kitty

    42

  • Wheatwacked

    35

Top Posters In This Topic

  • HectorConvector

    HectorConvector 118 posts

  • Jackie Garrett

    Jackie Garrett 67 posts

  • knitty kitty

    knitty kitty 42 posts

  • Wheatwacked

    Wheatwacked 35 posts

Posted Images

trents Grand Master
17 minutes ago, Jackie Garrett said:

Lactose intolerance affects many, many people I never connected it to my symptoms, it was only when I increased my milk intake that I noticed my symptoms and pain/ inflammation got really bad it was only then that I thought what have I been doing lately that’s different and it was increasing the milk, so I removed Dairy and others things that had Lactic/ Citric acid in and everything got better, no Dr. found this out, I was never offered a Anion Test, I only ever had a standard blood test in previous years, I hadn’t heard of an Anion gap blood test until recently. But by removing the acids I got well, and because Hector has some symptoms similar to mine and the Drs. don’t seem to have an answer for him at the moment, I just thought maybe he could start removing the things contain Lactose/ Lactic acid just to see if it helps him if nothing else is working, it helped me, I know I would still be having so many symptoms if I hadn’t done this, like I said before this may or may not be Hectors case, it’s just something to consider if he’s not getting better.

Jackie, how do you know it's not the protein in dairy that bothers you instead of the sugar in milk (lactose)? Have you tried lactose free milk?

Jackie Garrett Collaborator
19 minutes ago, trents said:

Jackie, how do you know it's not the protein in dairy that bothers you instead of the sugar in milk (lactose)? Have you tried lactose free milk?

Yes Trents possibly both ?? I know Lactic acid affects me with nerve pain, I am very dubious to try Lactose free milk as they add something to it, and it is very sweet, I am ok with my Almond milk now,  I am waiting for an appointment with an immunologist  to tell them what happened to me and how I improved my health, as I think It would be good for research purposes and also for Drs. to maybe question Lactose intolerance to more of their patients, and yes Trent’s possibly Protein intolerance ?? by what I posted a few days ago, it did get me thinking, I am waiting for an  appointment,  I will let you know the outcome. In the meantime I am looking more into Protein intolerance which is something I haven’t heard of until recently, very interesting !!!

Jackie Garrett Collaborator
3 hours ago, trents said:

Jackie, how do you know it's not the protein in dairy that bothers you instead of the sugar in milk (lactose)? Have you tried lactose free milk?

Lactose free milk doesn’t appeal to me, I think they add something to it, I’d rather avoid it. Yes Trent’s it could be the proteins too. The article I came across which I posted a few days ago, got me thinking about certain Proteins and was wondering if in some of us our bodies can’t process them too well, either because have we too much in our system through eating/ drinking too many things that have it in, or did we start off with a too much when we were born or are some us just plain intolerant, or do we need a good detox for a while, or are us sensitive people missing an enzyme, Are we designed to eat saturated fats from Animals, maybe tiny amounts, who knows ?  ?? I  would love to find out the answer.

trents Grand Master
(edited)

I think all they do is break down the lactose in the milk buy adding lactase. The enzyme lactase, which breaks down lactose, is produced by the epithelial cells that line our gut. But some people don't make enough of it to break down lactose well. Lactose cannot be absorbed by the gut so it must be broken down into simpler sugars that can be. When it isn't broken down it causes GI distress. Lactose free milk tastes sweeter because the lactose is broken down into simpler sugars, sugars that taste sweeter in the mouth and are easily digested.  So, there is nothing harmful in lactose free milk. You can buy a product called Lactaid that breaks down the lactose when you put some drops in your milk. 

Edited by trents
Jackie Garrett Collaborator
52 minutes ago, trents said:

I think all they add is lactase, the enzyme produced naturally by lactobacillus, a naturally occurring bacteria in the gut that breaks down the lactose (the sugar in the milk). Lactose cannot be absorbed by the gut so it must be broken down into simpler sugars that can be. The milk tastes sweeter because the lactose is broken down into simpler sugars, sugars that taste sweeter in the mouth and are easily digested. People who are lactose intolerant don't have enough lactobacillus in their gut to produce sufficient lactase. At least that's my understanding. So, there is nothing harmful in lactose free milk. You can buy a product called Lactaid that breaks down the lactose when you put some in your milk. 

Thanks Trent’s for that explanation. I have been very sceptical to try anything like that, I suppose with what effect milk has had on my health, I know people take these tablets after they have consumed  Dairy, but I am very wary of these things, I just avoid it, which is a shame as nothing tastes as good as Dairy, Cheese is a big thing to give up, I do miss it, I will try it again and see how I go, if I get pain or any of my other symptoms then I will know I can’t have it. Are you ok with Dairy or is it just Gluten ?

Wheatwacked Veteran
8 hours ago, Jackie Garrett said:

I increased my milk intake that I noticed my symptoms and pain/ inflammation got really bad it was only then that I thought what have I been doing lately that’s different and it was increasing the milk,

When you increased milk intake you also increased your intake of omega 6 fatty acids. Omega 6 increases inflammation and clotting. That's its job. Have you tried 100% Grass fed dairy or meat? The supplements used to increase milk in dairy and to fatten beef raises omega 6 content. Fortunately that is not the case with plant based foods. The issue is not that milk and red meat are intrinsically bad, it is how we raise them. We are after all omnivores.

Adding the antioxidant vitamins C and E as well as homocysteine-lowering B6, B12, folate and choline should help keep blood thin. 

 Antioxidant Vitamins Block Homocysteine's Acute Toxic Effects

Quote

our meta-analysis demonstrated that high consumption of  n-3 PUFA decreases plasma Hcy concentration   https://www.hindawi.com/journals/tswj/2013/931626/

The best way to increase lactobacillus is to eat naturally fermented foods (not vinegar pickled) like unpasteurized pickles, sauerkraut and yogurt and plenty of fiber.


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



Jackie Garrett Collaborator
4 minutes ago, Wheatwacked said:

When you increased milk intake you also increased your intake of omega 6 fatty acids. Omega 6 increases inflammation and clotting. That's its job. Have you tried 100% Grass fed dairy or meat? The supplements used to increase milk in dairy and to fatten beef raises omega 6 content. Fortunately that is not the case with plant based foods. The issue is not that milk and red meat are intrinsically bad, it is how we raise them. We are after all omnivores.

Adding the antioxidant vitamins C and E as well as homocysteine-lowering B6, B12, folate and choline should help keep blood thin. 

 Antioxidant Vitamins Block Homocysteine's Acute Toxic Effects

The best way to increase lactobacillus is to eat naturally fermented foods (not vinegar pickled) like unpasteurized pickles, sauerkraut and yogurt and plenty of fiber.

Thanks Wheatwacked for info, I do eat Red meat, I have cut it down though I love all kinds of meat, but I do think we have to be careful how often and how much we eat as i believe it can increase our histamine levels inside of us,( my opinion) The only vitamin I take is a liquid vitamin D I try and get my vitamins from food I feel ok so I don’t think I’m lacking in anything at the moment, I try and avoid preservatives where I can,  I make sure I eat fruit, lots of veg, potatoes, meat, Salmon, Mackeral no Caffeine, drink water mainly herbal teas and vary my diet as much as I can, because I feel well I don’t want to change things. Things that do have higher histamine in, in my opinion, I really do think we have to limit. It has become so easy today to buy food that is full of things that the body is not designed  to have, we all need to look at what we are consuming and that very much includes drinks, high histamine drinks !!! I will take a look at what you have sent through. Thankyou.

Geoff01 Apprentice
On 3/30/2022 at 9:26 AM, HectorConvector said:

I had an MRI scan last year which didn't show any signs of MS. I'm currently seeing a neurologist who is lining up another MRI scan including the spine as well as head.

I’ve been struggling with peripheral neuropathy for 30 years but no doctor could work out the cause. Not too bad but has got a lot worse in the last ten years. Now I have significant numbness below the knees, esp in my feet and some burning sensations when in bed.  I’m 59 and very active but didn’t realise that I had gluten intolerance until I was about 50.  I started getting a severe gut reaction to gluten. My sister was diagnosed celiac at age 16, 1981. I got a DNA test 9 yrs ago and the results came back HLA DQ2.2. 9 yrs ago I tried a gluten free diet for 6 months then did a “gluten test” with approximately 3 slices of bread. I was terribly Ill for 10 days (stomach pain, diarrhoea, constipation, headaches, chills, brain fog, essentially bedridden) and I’ve been gluten-free ever since. I’ve noticed that if I get glutened by accident and normally cross contamination I lose my sense of balance and essentially get gluten ataxia as well as stomach pain etc.  I saw a neurologist some years ago and explained this to him. He ordered a brain MRI which showed I have a lot of UBOs ( essentially holes) at each end of the sinus in my cerebral cortex similar to an extreme migraine patient or an 80 yr old. Also damage to the perjinkie cells in my cerebellum which control balance.

Understandingly, I am now much more careful not to get glutened. I can’t fix the damage but perhaps I can slow or halt it. As Dr Hajivassileu has written, gluten intolerance is largely a neurological problem, of which a small percentage are classified as Celiac. 

Geoff01 Apprentice
On 11/21/2021 at 9:26 AM, HectorConvector said:

Hello.

34 year old man. In 2010, I was tested for celiac disease due to having a sister who had it. I never suspected I'd have it as I had more or less no symptoms then. The antibodies were present in the blood test and the gastroscopy revealed the typical damage. 

I immediately went on a gluten free diet, which I've maintained in the 11 years since.

Back then, I had mild shooting and tingling in my feet and sometimes hands. Over most of the next 8 years or so this was manageable and at a low level. It always seemed to get worse after eating, however. The more I eat (of anything, all gluten free), the worse it would get. 

I am also chronically underweight, and so when I try to gain weight, my nerve symptoms get worse.

However, in the last 2 years my neurological symptoms have totally gone out of control, for no obvious reason. I have multiple violent attacks of nerve pain in my feet mostly, every day. It gets violent after meals of any kind, and terribly violent in the evenings. I get stabbing, crushing, burning pains in both feet and sometimes hands. I also started developing painful stabbing headaches behind my eye area and in the frontal part of head. All this gets worse with food intake. 

I've been seeing doctors about this and been on multiple medications to control the pain. Carbamazepine, Gabapentin and Pregabalin, the anti convulsants, had been useless. Duloxetine has been the best so far, and I'm going back on it next week. 

I had a skin biopsy to look at small fibres but the result was normal. There is no diabetes, as all that was tested and I test myself with a blood sugar meter several times a year, everything is normo-glycaemic. 

I don't know why this has got so out of control in the last two years despite being gluten free. My immune system is reacting to everything I eat giving me terrible nerve pains that are getting worse by the very month. I don't know where this will end. Things that trigger the pain include food obviously, heat (I have to sleep with my feet outside of the bed or they burn like hell), dehydration, concentration and excitement of any kind. It's hard to work on anything as the pain will get intense. 

Somehow I get no digestive symptoms at all but I get awful nerve pain every day. Is the the celiac disease do you think, or something else. If it is, why is it so bad after 11+ years on a gluten-free diet? Everything I read about suggests it would get better. Yet it was barely there at diagnosis and now it's extremely violent and far worse since going gluten-free.

Does anyone else have this problem?

 

Geoff01 Apprentice
On 11/21/2021 at 9:26 AM, HectorConvector said:

Hello.

34 year old man. In 2010, I was tested for celiac disease due to having a sister who had it. I never suspected I'd have it as I had more or less no symptoms then. The antibodies were present in the blood test and the gastroscopy revealed the typical damage. 

I immediately went on a gluten free diet, which I've maintained in the 11 years since.

Back then, I had mild shooting and tingling in my feet and sometimes hands. Over most of the next 8 years or so this was manageable and at a low level. It always seemed to get worse after eating, however. The more I eat (of anything, all gluten free), the worse it would get. 

I am also chronically underweight, and so when I try to gain weight, my nerve symptoms get worse.

However, in the last 2 years my neurological symptoms have totally gone out of control, for no obvious reason. I have multiple violent attacks of nerve pain in my feet mostly, every day. It gets violent after meals of any kind, and terribly violent in the evenings. I get stabbing, crushing, burning pains in both feet and sometimes hands. I also started developing painful stabbing headaches behind my eye area and in the frontal part of head. All this gets worse with food intake. 

I've been seeing doctors about this and been on multiple medications to control the pain. Carbamazepine, Gabapentin and Pregabalin, the anti convulsants, had been useless. Duloxetine has been the best so far, and I'm going back on it next week. 

I had a skin biopsy to look at small fibres but the result was normal. There is no diabetes, as all that was tested and I test myself with a blood sugar meter several times a year, everything is normo-glycaemic. 

I don't know why this has got so out of control in the last two years despite being gluten free. My immune system is reacting to everything I eat giving me terrible nerve pains that are getting worse by the very month. I don't know where this will end. Things that trigger the pain include food obviously, heat (I have to sleep with my feet outside of the bed or they burn like hell), dehydration, concentration and excitement of any kind. It's hard to work on anything as the pain will get intense. 

Somehow I get no digestive symptoms at all but I get awful nerve pain every day. Is the the celiac disease do you think, or something else. If it is, why is it so bad after 11+ years on a gluten-free diet? Everything I read about suggests it would get better. Yet it was barely there at diagnosis and now it's extremely violent and far worse since going gluten-free.

Does anyone else have this problem?

Hi Hector, please see my other reply to you. Most writers note that gluten only occurs in wheat rye and barley.  This is not true or only half of the story.
 

Corn has zein, oats have ovenin and rice has something similar.  These are all proteins that do the same job as gluten, discourage animals from over grazing cereal seeds. Most Humans have evolved to manage these poisons. WE HAVE NOT! We are the last Hunter gatherers if you like. Additionally, beans and peas (all legumes) have lectins, proteins that are structurally similar to gluten. I believe that lactose from milk is similar or can aggravate already damaged and irritable\open intestines.  I react to all of them and have largely cut them from my diet. It’s not easy but it’s the only way. 

If you are eating processed, store bought “gluten free” food the you will find that it’s full of oats, corn, rice and legumes.  The gluten free manufacturers are not keeping up with the science and many celiacs only react to gluten and glutenin. This may be your problem. It may also be the problem for refractory celiacs, of which you may be one.

Good luck. It’s not easy but it’s the only way.  I can refer you to scientific papers if that will help.

On 11/21/2021 at 9:26 AM, HectorConvector said:

Hello.

34 year old man. In 2010, I was tested for celiac disease due to having a sister who had it. I never suspected I'd have it as I had more or less no symptoms then. The antibodies were present in the blood test and the gastroscopy revealed the typical damage. 

I immediately went on a gluten free diet, which I've maintained in the 11 years since.

Back then, I had mild shooting and tingling in my feet and sometimes hands. Over most of the next 8 years or so this was manageable and at a low level. It always seemed to get worse after eating, however. The more I eat (of anything, all gluten free), the worse it would get. 

I am also chronically underweight, and so when I try to gain weight, my nerve symptoms get worse.

However, in the last 2 years my neurological symptoms have totally gone out of control, for no obvious reason. I have multiple violent attacks of nerve pain in my feet mostly, every day. It gets violent after meals of any kind, and terribly violent in the evenings. I get stabbing, crushing, burning pains in both feet and sometimes hands. I also started developing painful stabbing headaches behind my eye area and in the frontal part of head. All this gets worse with food intake. 

I've been seeing doctors about this and been on multiple medications to control the pain. Carbamazepine, Gabapentin and Pregabalin, the anti convulsants, had been useless. Duloxetine has been the best so far, and I'm going back on it next week. 

I had a skin biopsy to look at small fibres but the result was normal. There is no diabetes, as all that was tested and I test myself with a blood sugar meter several times a year, everything is normo-glycaemic. 

I don't know why this has got so out of control in the last two years despite being gluten free. My immune system is reacting to everything I eat giving me terrible nerve pains that are getting worse by the very month. I don't know where this will end. Things that trigger the pain include food obviously, heat (I have to sleep with my feet outside of the bed or they burn like hell), dehydration, concentration and excitement of any kind. It's hard to work on anything as the pain will get intense. 

Somehow I get no digestive symptoms at all but I get awful nerve pain every day. Is the the celiac disease do you think, or something else. If it is, why is it so bad after 11+ years on a gluten-free diet? Everything I read about suggests it would get better. Yet it was barely there at diagnosis and now it's extremely violent and far worse since going gluten-free.

Does anyone else have this problem?

Hi Hector, please see my other reply to you. Most writers note that gluten only occurs in wheat rye and barley.  This is not true or only half of the story.
 

Corn has zein, oats have ovenin and rice has something similar.  These are all proteins that do the same job as gluten, discourage animals from over grazing cereal seeds. Most Humans have evolved to manage these poisons. WE HAVE NOT! We are the last Hunter gatherers if you like. Additionally, beans and peas (all legumes) have lectins, proteins that are structurally similar to gluten. I believe that lactose from milk is similar or can aggravate already damaged and irritable\open intestines.  I react to all of them and have largely cut them from my diet. It’s not easy but it’s the only way. 

If you are eating processed, store bought “gluten free” food the you will find that it’s full of oats, corn, rice and legumes.  The gluten free manufacturers are not keeping up with the science and many celiacs only react to gluten and glutenin. This may be your problem. It may also be the problem for refractory celiacs, of which you may be one.

Good luck. It’s not easy but it’s the only way.  I can refer you to scientific papers if that will help.

HectorConvector Enthusiast
1 hour ago, Jackie Garrett said:

Thanks Wheatwacked for info, I do eat Red meat, I have cut it down though I love all kinds of meat, but I do think we have to be careful how often and how much we eat as i believe it can increase our histamine levels inside of us,( my opinion) The only vitamin I take is a liquid vitamin D I try and get my vitamins from food I feel ok so I don’t think I’m lacking in anything at the moment, I try and avoid preservatives where I can,  I make sure I eat fruit, lots of veg, potatoes, meat, Salmon, Mackeral no Caffeine, drink water mainly herbal teas and vary my diet as much as I can, because I feel well I don’t want to change things. Things that do have higher histamine in, in my opinion, I really do think we have to limit. It has become so easy today to buy food that is full of things that the body is not designed  to have, we all need

 

34 minutes ago, Geoff01 said:


 

Corn has zein, oats have ovenin and rice has something similar.  These are all proteins that do the same job as gluten, discourage animals from over grazing cereal seeds. Most Humans have evolved to manage these poisons. WE HAVE NOT! We are the last Hunter gatherers if you like. Additionally, beans and peas (all legumes) have lectins, proteins that are structurally similar to gluten. I believe that lactose from milk is similar or can aggravate already damaged and irritable\open intestines.  I react to all of them and have largely cut them from my diet. It’s not easy but it’s the only way. 

If you are eating processed, store bought “gluten free” food the you will find that it’s full of oats, corn, rice and legumes.  The gluten free manufacturers are not keeping up with the science and many celiacs only react to gluten and glutenin. This may be your problem. It may also be the problem for refractory celiacs, of which you may be one.

Good luck. It’s not easy but it’s the only way.  I can refer you to scientific papers if that will help.

Well that is interesting. Yeah I generally eat my own prepared food now so I know what's going in it. Mostly fish, meat, vegetables and some fruit. I'm taking cheese out of the diet today to see if that was causing problems but I have to replace it with something calorific though, so am using peanut butter, but that presumably would have lectins in it, which isn't good possibly.  I don't eat rice or oats really as I don't eat much carbs. Wouldn't mind seeing the scientific papers.

Wheatwacked Veteran
Scott Adams Grand Master
12 hours ago, Jackie Garrett said:

Lactose intolerance affects many, many people I never connected it to my symptoms, it was only when I increased my milk intake that I noticed my symptoms and pain/ inflammation got really bad it was only then that I thought what have I been doing lately that’s different and it was increasing the milk, so I removed Dairy and others things that had Lactic/ Citric acid in and everything got better, no Dr. found this out, I was never offered a Anion Test, I only ever had a standard blood test in previous years, I hadn’t heard of an Anion gap blood test until recently. But by removing the acids I got well, and because Hector has some symptoms similar to mine and the Drs. don’t seem to have an answer for him at the moment, I just thought maybe he could start removing the things contain Lactose/ Lactic acid just to see if it helps him if nothing else is working, it helped me, I know I would still be having so many symptoms if I hadn’t done this, like I said before this may or may not be Hectors case, it’s just something to consider if he’s not getting better.

I just want to mention that lactic acidosis and lactose intolerance are two very different things, and you often switch back and forth when describing them, and when you give advice to others. You've not been diagnosed with either, so it's really hard to know for sure exactly why cutting out dairy is help you, but like @trents mentioned, I strongly suspect you have lactose intolerance, rather than lactic acidosis. 

In any case, as was mentioned, adding the missing enzyme you may lack via Lactaid might give you an answer. I do think you should try figure out exactly what your issues are before offering specific advice, and especially before suggesting that others might have conditions like lactic acidosis.

knitty kitty Grand Master
3 hours ago, Geoff01 said:

I’ve been struggling with peripheral neuropathy for 30 years but no doctor could work out the cause. Not too bad but has got a lot worse in the last ten years. Now I have significant numbness below the knees, esp in my feet and some burning sensations when in bed.  I’m 59 and very active but didn’t realise that I had gluten intolerance until I was about 50.  I started getting a severe gut reaction to gluten. My sister was diagnosed celiac at age 16, 1981. I got a DNA test 9 yrs ago and the results came back HLA DQ2.2. 9 yrs ago I tried a gluten free diet for 6 months then did a “gluten test” with approximately 3 slices of bread. I was terribly Ill for 10 days (stomach pain, diarrhoea, constipation, headaches, chills, brain fog, essentially bedridden) and I’ve been gluten-free ever since. I’ve noticed that if I get glutened by accident and normally cross contamination I lose my sense of balance and essentially get gluten ataxia as well as stomach pain etc.  I saw a neurologist some years ago and explained this to him. He ordered a brain MRI which showed I have a lot of UBOs ( essentially holes) at each end of the sinus in my cerebral cortex similar to an extreme migraine patient or an 80 yr old. Also damage to the perjinkie cells in my cerebellum which control balance.

Understandingly, I am now much more careful not to get glutened. I can’t fix the damage but perhaps I can slow or halt it. As Dr Hajivassileu has written, gluten intolerance is largely a neurological problem, of which a small percentage are classified as Celiac. 

I'm curious about your UBO's on your MRI.  Dr. H.'s article talks about ataxia and MRI changes, but doesn't mention thiamine deficiency.  Thiamine deficiency can cause bright spots on MRIs.  Just curious if your bright spots might be caused by thiamine deficiency as well.  

 

Vestibular signs of thiamine deficiency during the early phase of suspected Wernicke encephalopathy

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6082353/

 

Thiamine Deficiency Increases Intrinsic Excitability of Mouse Cerebellar Purkinje Cells

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33098550/

 

MR Imaging Findings in Alcoholic and Nonalcoholic Acute Wernicke's Encephalopathy: A Review

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4094710/

 

Diagnosis and management of progressive ataxia in adults

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6585307/

 

 

HectorConvector Enthusiast

FWIW my upcoming MRI scan in June will be my second, on my first there was no sign of any abnormalities (unlike in Geoff's case). Of course there could still be (or have been) thiamine deficiency, so I'm keeping the supplement going to see if any improvements occur.

Jackie Garrett Collaborator
3 hours ago, Scott Adams said:

I just want to mention that lactic acidosis and lactose intolerance are two very different things, and you often switch back and forth when describing them, and when you give advice to others. You've not been diagnosed with either, so it's really hard to know for sure exactly why cutting out dairy is help you, but like @trents mentioned, I strongly suspect you have lactose intolerance, rather than lactic acidosis. 

In any case, as was mentioned, adding the missing enzyme you may lack via Lactaid might give you an answer. I do think you should try figure out exactly what your issues are before offering specific advice, and especially before suggesting that others might have conditions like lactic acidosis.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10230483/ 

Scott, I know what happened to me. I am now well.

knitty kitty Grand Master
1 hour ago, Jackie Garrett said:

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10230483/ 

Scott, I know what happened to me. I am now well.

That article says of the infant "Her mother attempted to reintroduce cow milk on the 59th and 64th day, but this was immediately followed by allergic manifestations which supported the diagnosis of cow milk allergy."

Cow Milk allergy is an allergic reaction to the protein casein in milk.  

NOT because the milk had lactic acid, but because of the allergic immune response to the Casein.

Geoff01 Apprentice
10 hours ago, HectorConvector said:

 

Well that is interesting. Yeah I generally eat my own prepared food now so I know what's going in it. Mostly fish, meat, vegetables and some fruit. I'm taking cheese out of the diet today to see if that was causing problems but I have to replace it with something calorific though, so am using peanut butter, but that presumably would have lectins in it, which isn't good possibly.  I don't eat rice or oats really as I don't eat much carbs. Wouldn't mind seeing the scientific papers.

I love cheese and don’t have a problem with it. I believe that the fermentation process for strong cheeses destroys the protein that is the problem. I don’t drink much milk. 

trents Grand Master
27 minutes ago, Geoff01 said:

I love cheese and don’t have a problem with it. I believe that the fermentation process for strong cheeses destroys the protein that is the problem. I don’t drink much milk. 

I think the aging process can do that, at least to some extent. How much is converted may vary from aged cheese to age cheese. By the way, this happens with Buttermilk to some extent.

Jackie Garrett Collaborator
5 hours ago, knitty kitty said:

That article says of the infant "Her mother attempted to reintroduce cow milk on the 59th and 64th day, but this was immediately followed by allergic manifestations which supported the diagnosis of cow milk allergy."

Cow Milk allergy is an allergic reaction to the protein casein in milk.  

NOT because the milk had lactic acid, but because of the allergic immune response to the Casein.

I know I can not have milk and because I didn’t realise this for many many years, having different symptoms, and found out myself that milk was the underlying cause, definitely Lactose affected me, I know it made my body become acidic I would react with anything acidic, no test standard blood test ever picked this up, knowing what I know now I would have requested an Anion gap test that may have picked things up, when I realised milk was my problem I removed it and in time symptoms started to go, some fairly quickly, I was very bad on my meds,( I didn’t know at that time I was on them that Lactose/milk was a problem) they contained lactose so when I found out about my intolerance to milk that all made sense, I believe the Lactose had made my body acidic, and yes Casein can too, I know how bad I was on the meds it seemed to heighten my symptoms and they contained lactose so in my case I know how Lactose alone affected me and caused a lot of inflammation , a histamine reaction, which I believe causes more acid release in the body leading to higher acid levels leading to possible Acidosis that can cause various different symptoms in our bodies and one of them being pain, the histamine reaction from the build of too many acids, from the Lactose and yes, protein reaction too in some cases, I really believe both cause a histamine reaction in some of our bodies, I removed milk and become well, I keep higher acid intake low. Because I got myself well and in all the years no one else had found the answers, the only way I got well is how I’ve worked it out myself,  so I replied to Hector and others as  I thought it helped me it may help some one else who is struggling, and if they also are not getting the answers to their health problems to pass on what had worked for me,  and yes I believe lactose can cause higher acid levels in the body as much as Casein, because of what Lactose alone had done to me it heightened my symptoms. And as Hector was getting symptoms similar to me I thought I would mention it to see if it helps him it’s worth a try whether he chooses to or not is his Choice, it may be the answer or it may not. 

Jackie Garrett Collaborator
10 hours ago, knitty kitty said:

That article says of the infant "Her mother attempted to reintroduce cow milk on the 59th and 64th day, but this was immediately followed by allergic manifestations which supported the diagnosis of cow milk allergy."

Cow Milk allergy is an allergic reaction to the protein casein in milk.  

NOT because the milk had lactic acid, but because of the allergic immune response to the Casein.

I believe the lactose intolerance has the same effect on the body as casein intolerance from milk and then histamine reactions occur which causes an acidic environment and then  in SOME cases progressing onto Acidosis or the body just being in an  higher acidic state like I believe like mine was, maybe only a slight change in acid levels is just enough to tip our healths over ??? Because I went on for years never connecting my symptoms to milk I believe my body became acidic, a long time of build up, I then had my Heart attack, so was that a another clue ?? what happened to me and how I recovered made all logical sense to me. Maybe more research is needed on how  raised acid levels,  and at what point these levels starts to affect our healths needs more research, and look into what foods and drinks causes histamine   release, Liberators, I know this is becoming more talked about now which is very good news, and will solve a lot of peoples problems, I wish this was talked about years ago, maybe it wasn’t recognised,  What  I question is if milk is doing that to our bodies should we really ingest it regularly, I know what I think !! 

 

HectorConvector Enthusiast
9 hours ago, Geoff01 said:

I love cheese and don’t have a problem with it. I believe that the fermentation process for strong cheeses destroys the protein that is the problem. I don’t drink much milk. 

 I've never noticed problems with it myself but am taking it out to begin with owning to what Jackie said about the lactic/lactose relationship, in case it's a hidden cause of the problems. So, I'm trying one thing at a time to begin with before making any completely drastic changes to my diet. 

Still taking 400mg of thiamine a day.

Jackie Garrett Collaborator
5 minutes ago, HectorConvector said:

 I've never noticed problems with it myself but am taking it out to begin with owning to what Jackie said about the lactic/lactose relationship, in case it's a hidden cause of the problems. So, I'm trying one thing at a time to begin with before making any completely drastic changes to my diet. 

Still taking 400mg of thiamine a day.

🤞🤞

Scott Adams Grand Master
6 hours ago, Jackie Garrett said:

I believe the lactose intolerance has the same effect on the body as casein intolerance from milk and then histamine reactions occur which causes an acidic environment and then  in SOME cases progressing onto Acidosis or the body just being in an  higher acidic state like I believe like mine was, maybe only a slight change in acid levels is just enough to tip our healths over ??? Because I went on for years never connecting my symptoms to milk I believe my body became acidic, a long time of build up, I then had my Heart attack, so was that a another clue ?? what happened to me and how I recovered made all logical sense to me. Maybe more research is needed on how  raised acid levels,  and at what point these levels starts to affect our healths needs more research, and look into what foods and drinks causes histamine   release, Liberators, I know this is becoming more talked about now which is very good news, and will solve a lot of peoples problems, I wish this was talked about years ago, maybe it wasn’t recognised,  What  I question is if milk is doing that to our bodies should we really ingest it regularly, I know what I think !! 

 

You were never tested for any of what you are claiming here, but are throwing around lots of ideas like "my body became acidic" and that milk caused this condition, as though it is generally accepted by doctors and science, but I can assure you that the alkaline diet is currently looked at as psuedoscience by the scientific community:

https://www.webmd.com/diet/a-z/alkaline-diets

Quote

The alkaline diet claims to help your body maintain its blood pH level. In fact, nothing you eat is going to substantially change the pH of your blood. Your body works to keep that level constant.

I suspect that in your case you have casein intolerance and/or allergy, which caused your issues, and many of our site's participants, including myself and the board moderators, definitely recognize this, and often recommend excluding cow's milk/casein to those who have ongoing symptoms after going gluten-free. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      133,988
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      10,442

    julu
    Newest Member
    julu
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):
  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.6k
    • Total Posts
      1m
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):
  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • knitty kitty
      @Stegosaurus, Switching from a Keto diet to a diet high in carbohydrates increases the metabolic demand for thiamine to turn the fats, carbohydrates and proteins into energy.   Insufficient thiamine in the digestive tract can lead to SIBO and systemic yeast infection (autobrewery syndrome, Candida overgrowth).  Thiamine has both antibacterial and antifungal properties.   Trehalose is two molecules of sugar.  Thiamine is needed to metabolize carbohydrates like these.    Thiamine acts as a signal for the increased production of trehalase, the enzyme that breaks down trehalose.  I wonder what the thiamine levels of the test subjects in this study were prior to the experiment.   https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18777247/   Fungi (like Saccharomyces boulardii) often pair with bacteria that can make its own thiamine.  In a state of plentiful thiamine, thiamine signals for trehalase production, thus improving tolerance.     Role of fungal trehalose and bacterial thiamine in the improved survival and growth of the ectomycorrhizal fungus Laccaria bicolor S238N and the helper bacterium Pseudomonas fluorescens BBc6R8 https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23766226/#:~:text=We investigated the identity of,the fungal growth in vitro. The role of trehalose in the global spread of epidemic Clostridium difficile https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6546318/   I wonder if taking more Thiamine in the form Benfotiamine would increase your trehalase production and improve your intolerance to trehalose.   Keep us posted on your progress!
    • knitty kitty
      @glucel, Yes, most doctors prefer to prescribe pharmaceuticals than delve into vitamins because they aren't educated about the health impact vitamins and minerals can make in medical school. Thiamine, especially Benfotiamine, has been shown to be protective to the kidneys.  Benfotiamine improves kidney function!  Especially in people on dialysis.   Thiamine and Benfotiamine are safe and nontoxic even in high doses!  PLEASE Read! Prevention of Incipient Diabetic Nephropathy by High-Dose Thiamine and Benfotiamine  https://diabetesjournals.org/diabetes/article-abstract/52/8/2110/13835/ Benfotiamine Protects against Peritoneal and Kidney Damage in Peritoneal Dialysis https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3083313/ Prevention of incipient diabetic nephropathy by high-dose thiamine and benfotiamine https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12882930/ If more than half your plate is carbohydrates, you need more Thiamine!  High carbohydrate diets induce thiamine because as the carbohydrate load us increased, an increased amount of thiamine is needed to process them.  I have been taking high dose thiamine as thiamine hcl and Benfotiamine for over ten years.  I have not had any bad experiences with it.   I no longer have any symptoms that reflect type two diabetes.   Doctors can't profit from prescribing vitamins because they can't be patented.  They profit from pharmaceuticals and medical procedures necessitated by health conditions that could be remedied, or at least improved, with essential vitamins and minerals!   Don't fear thiamine!  Do discuss the benefits with your doctor.  Ask if you can take 300 mg Benfotiamine in his office under medical supervision if you're nervous.  Most people have improved health within a short period of time.  You've already seen improvement with low dose thiamine hcl.  Jump in with both feet!  
    • Known1
      I found credible scientific evidence from The World Heath Organization, pertaining to nutrients in drinking-water. There are several sections within the paper regarding nutrient depleted water (aka RO water)  Below is a small sample from the PDF which is linked further below. The possible adverse consequences of low mineral content water consumption are discussed in the following categories: • Direct effects on the intestinal mucous membrane, metabolism and mineral homeostasis or other body functions. • Little or no intake of calcium and magnesium from low-mineral water. • Low intake of other essential elements and microelements. • Loss of calcium, magnesium and other essential elements in prepared food. • Possible increased dietary intake of toxic metals. I highly recommend downloading the PDF and reviewing it for yourself. https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9241593989
    • glucel
      Great info, thanks. Luckily I am taking thiamin hcl 100mg at lunch and the 25 mg in morning b complex is made up of hcl and cocarboxlase.  I have read many of your writings about thiamin and understand/believe that the body gets rid of the excess. One thing that a gluten-free diet has done for me is no microscopic blood in urine after a lifetime of it, at least so far, but in other aspects my kidneys not so good. My kidneys have never been completely healthy and as an old guy have only gotten worse. My brother is on dialysis so I am more than concerned about excessive thiamin affect on the kidneys. It would be great to check with a dr about this but most of the time they have no interest in anything but drugs. So yes I would love to load up on b1 but it was actually a big decision for me to add 100 mg at noon time a few months ago. Normally my so called bigger meal, or at least where meat is consumed is at mid day. I eat way too much bread and cereals at night and usually stay away from meat as I try to limit cholesterol, although I do sneak a hard boiled egg in there. Maybe a half a hamburger or something like that could help curb the appetite.
    • cristiana
      Hi @Maureen armey Just one point re: PPIs.  Here in the UK the people I know with Barretts have had to take them long term, or H2 blockers instead, despite the fact they have side effects.   I feel that it is very important that you follow your consultant's advice re: this type of medication but if you do need to take them longterm, see if they can offer any advice on how to mitigate these potential side effects.   I hope you find the information contained via following the link below helpful. Do come back to us if you have any further questions. https://heartburncanceruk.org/blog/should-you-take-ppis-long-term-insights-from-a-gp-and-barretts-patient/ Cristiana
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

NOTICE: This site places This site places cookies on your device (Cookie settings). on your device. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.