Jump to content
  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.




  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):



    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):


  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Shocking Story


Gcbec

Recommended Posts

schuyler Apprentice

Wow. My skin is crawling because I'm so outraged. I feel so bad for you and your family. I agree with the people who said that the media needs to be involved; the public will be as outraged as we all are. What has happened to you and your children is horrible and uncalled for. I am so sorry that you had had to go through this. I just hope that it all ends soon, and that your children will be returned to you (where they really belong). I'll be saying lots of prayers.


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



  • Replies 216
  • Created
  • Last Reply
rumbles Newbie

Cindy,

I don't know if it will reach him directly or not, but I just sent an email to Dr. Peter H.R. Green, M.D. at Columbia University advising him of your posts, and requesting his assistance.

In the meantime, please discuss with your attorneys about your attorneys engaging the media and your lpolitical representatives. Also please contact your local Celiac support chapter and the national chapter for their assistance. This is outrageous.

Keep us posted, - you have definitely touched everyone that reads this, and we are here for you however we can be.

GFBetsy Rookie

Anyone out there a gluten-free NY lawyer? It would certainly help to have someone who really understands this illness testifying on her behalf . . .

Lymetoo Contributor
On the one hand, I can understand why "guilty until proven innocent" with taking children away in time of REAL abuse!

NO kidding!! The same thing has happened to parents of children with chronic Lyme disease. Several times that I know of. It's really sick on the part of these "drs"!!

I will pray you get your children back....and I'm betting you WILL!

Hang in there!!

Nic Collaborator

This year my son had a bone marrow test, becasue that is what they thought was wrong in the begining, becasue of weight loss, fever fatigue and our peditrician sent him. It was negative, then they did cat scan, which was negative, but lots of stool in intestines. then they did endoscopy, which there was alot of imflamation, then they did blood work. THIS IS ALL..

Aren't these test, maybe with the exception of the bone marrow test, the same tests that most of us "put our kids through" trying to come up with a diagnosis? For my poor son you can add a barium enima to the list. It was tough on him but he is ok now.

Nicole

penguin Community Regular
Anyone out there a gluten-free NY lawyer? It would certainly help to have someone who really understands this illness testifying on her behalf . . .

Where in NY are you? The CUNY School of Law in Queens is highly rated for their clinical program, and have a good sized aide practice. This school is very progressive and are easily outraged, I would contact them if you're in/near the city. I think they even have a health law clinic. I would also call every patient advocacy organization that will listen. This is insane!!!

aprilh Apprentice

I cannot believe this! Did they have any other reason for taking your children away? Any prior history? It is just unbelievable but yet believable that this could happen. I would be sick without my babies! That is neglect by the justice system.

Can you get the the positive blood test and show them, maybe get some documented research together along with it and take it to court or to the attorney as proof? Sounds like the dr. who did the blood work, that came back positive, but said it was negative needs to be SUED!!!! That is outrageously WRONG!!!

Ooh, I am praying for you. Please get all your documents in order. Try to get some Medical studies, you can probably find some on the internet. Dangerous Grains, the book, recommends this.

If I run across anything that I think will help, I will post.


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



Rikki Tikki Explorer

Is this the only reason the children were taken? What does the paperwork say exactly? What were the reasons for the detainment?

The other important question would be is their health improving out of your care? Not trying to be rude, just asking for factual information so maybe can give you advice.

Luvs to Scrap Apprentice

I am so shocked and outraged that something this ridiculous can be allowed! As a mother who just spent the afternoon at the lab "abusing my daughter by having lots of blood drawn for celiac testing per drs orders" I don't understand how they would think you would have tests done for the fun of it. My DH has celiac and so does my DS and Kirsten is showing the same symptoms so that is why we are having her tested. You were doing the same thing as us because of your diagnosis and are getting accused of child abuse and having your kids taken away. Why don't they spend their time taking care of kids who are really abused not ones whose parents love them enough to try to get them the diagnosis and help they need. I will definitely keep this situation in my prayers. I agree this situation needs media attention. Kendra

Judyin Philly Enthusiast
Is this the only reason the children were taken? What does the paperwork say exactly? What were the reasons for the detainment?

************************************8

This is an important question... make sure you find this paper work and have it out in case Alice Blast calls you...I got your PM and thank you.

sending another email to you

Judy in Philly

this is a quote from Dr. Peter Green---

sent you the link ---This should sure be something in your 'corner' of the fight.

*******************

"Because the disease is hereditary, family members of people who have been diagnosed should be tested for the disease, says Dr. Green. "About 10 percent of an affected person's first-degree relatives (parents, siblings,

children) will also have the disease," he says. "The longer a person goes undiagnosed and untreated, the greater the chance of developing malnutrition and other complications." Untreated people can incur a higher risk of additional autoimmune disorders, neurological problems, osteoporosis and even cancer".

chrissy Collaborator

like tavi, i am wondering what the actual charges were? i don't think that lying is grounds for removing children from a home.

Canadian Karen Community Regular

Anyone remember the reporter's name David __________ at the Wall Street Journal who has gone to bat for us before? I think Peter (Sawyer) has his e-mail addy........

Karen

Gcbec Newbie

Again, I must say I am overwhelmed with everyones responses. For weeks my husband and I have been trying to figure out what to do. I am going to try to answer as many questions as I can.

Dr Greene was sent a message by his administrator at Columbia, she said there is a long waiting list and because my son was not a patient and becasue of the situation they were unsure if they would be able to help. She sympathized with me and took our information and was sending it to Dr Peter Greene to see what he could do. I also left a message with for my dr, but have gotten no return calls yet. I take that back I just got email response from Dr Greens office, she said it appears the tests were negative? I am not sure what she is talking about but I DO know I am looking at blood tests that show IGG positive, does that mean anything to anyone? It says Celiac Antibodies and IGG says 24.2 and flagged as High. Anyone help?

I must say my heart has dropped with this email because it sounded as if they really cant help because they havnt seen my son. Please anyone what can I do? I would love to go to media but I have no proof to back up the theory, and the acusing dr will use the defense of me lying. My only hope was to get him in and diagnosed and get support in getting my children home.

As far as other reasons for taking our children,, NO there were no other reasons at all. NONE they claim I lied about his symtpoms and medical history. Which when you read all medical records you can clearly see is not true. This Dr has got to be stopped before any more innocent families are destroyed. Yeah I know most of your children have probably had more tests done then my son. And we even had a dr take my son out of school for the year in September becasue they felt he was too sick. He has been on Home Tutoring.

Cindy

Judyin Philly Enthusiast

Cindy--

1. As far as other reasons for taking our children,, NO there were no other reasons at all. NONE they claim I lied about his symtpoms and medical history. Which when you read all medical records you can clearly see is not true.

TERRIFIC..THIS SHOULD BE GREAT EVIDENCE IN YOUR FAVOR AS WELL AS THIS---.

2. And we even had a dr take my son out of school for the year in September becasue they felt he was too sick. He has been on Home Tutoring.

Cindy

The forward didn't seem to go through the dang PM..so will try to put it here.

I would sure think that Dr. Greens opinion would have more clout...than your dr's...Just pulled this off a link i tried to forward to you in pm

********************************

"Because the disease is hereditary, family members of people who have been diagnosed should be tested for the disease, says Dr. Green. "About 10 percent of an affected person's first-degree relatives (parents, siblings,

children) will also have the disease," he says. "The longer a person goes undiagnosed and untreated, the greater the chance of developing malnutrition and other complications." Untreated people can incur a higher risk of additional autoimmune disorders, neurological problems, osteoporosis and even cancer".

good luck Cindy. I still think you need some Celiac expert to help your lawyer pursure this esp if your going to the media..I'm sure this Alice Blast will know the 'ropes.

judy

EDIT--I WAS HAVING TROUBLE SENDING LINKS TO CINDY

HERE ARE THE WEB SITES WHERE I GOT THE QUOTE FOR DR. GREEN.

Shortcut to: Open Original Shared Link

AND THE DR. GREEN QUOTE WAS FROM A LINK FOR THIS WEB SITE.

Open Original Shared Link & Open Original Shared Link

If Dr Green wrote the article I would think he wouldn't mind being quoted but Cindy's personal Dr's names should be left out..I agree.

Gcbec Newbie
like tavi, i am wondering what the actual charges were? i don't think that lying is grounds for removing children from a home.

No there were no "charges" but allegations. They claim I have Munchausen Syndrome By Proxy which is that I lied about my sons symptoms to get attention from Dr's. Basically I took him to to many dr's for attention and as a result of my "lies" my son recieved unnessisary and potential harmful medical tests.

Now as everyone here knows, Celiac is so hard to diagnose it took me several years before I got diagnosed. That didnt mean I didnt suffer and have symptoms before I was diagnosed.

Guest nini

I would talk with your GI dr. about this situation. Ask the office to have her/him? call you as soon as possible and maybe your Dr. would have some ideas.

Rikki Tikki Explorer

Again, what are the reasons as stated on the paperwork in Court for the detainment of your children? You should of already had at least one court date? What was the decision? Why has it been 51 days since you have seen your children? You haven't had any visitation, if not why? They are placed with family? What exactly were the allegations that were made? And most of all what is the health of your son now since he has been out of the home?

Gcbec Newbie
Is this the only reason the children were taken? What does the paperwork say exactly? What were the reasons for the detainment?

The other important question would be is their health improving out of your care? Not trying to be rude, just asking for factual information so maybe can give you advice.

Hi Tavi,

My son was also on Adderall, and when he was taken they stopped this medication. As far as his headaches and fevers they have stopped. As far as his poops and belly aches they have not. The problem is we have no contact and cant be for sure of how things really are. My parents were there and wittnessed his severe poopy episode after he had pasta dinner.

I know how strange this sounds to everyone believe me, our family freinds neighbors and teachers could not beleive it either. Everyone has wittnessed my son sick especially this past year, yes we feel the adderall also had a big effect on him. But I swear on my children, what they are "charging" me and my husband with is that I lied about my sons symptoms and he went under too many medical tests as a result. We have even hired Expert Witness Physchologist to review all his medical records to show my innocence. That is when we noticed the posative antibody test when we were reviewing notes. I have been saying all along this is what it is, Celiac disease. Like I said the other part is adderall effect on him as well.

I hope this clears up any questions if not I dont mind answering anything else. I know how unbeleivable it sounds and that is why we are still in shock.

Thanks CIndy

Lymetoo Contributor

Just to be safe, I would suggest NOT giving drs' full names here, coupled with what they said. Perhaps it's OK to quote Dr Greene....but any correspondence with any drs should be kept private for your and THEIR protection.

Gcbec Newbie
Again, what are the reasons as stated on the paperwork in Court for the detainment of your children? You should of already had at least one court date? What was the decision? Why has it been 51 days since you have seen your children? You haven't had any visitation, if not why? They are placed with family? What exactly were the allegations that were made? And most of all what is the health of your son now since he has been out of the home?

Yes we had 2 court appearances, the first one we recieved petition. The second time we were denied any contact with my children they even placed an order of protection against my husband and I. They claim if we see the children we might phychologically make them sick. We are dealing with a Dr and a judge that are trying to get another notch in there belt. We are not even allowed to send my daughter a birthday card next week. If anyone wants to read about this the best place to read about Munchausen Syndrome is to go to www.msbp.com

Judyin Philly Enthusiast

EDIT--I WAS HAVING TROUBLE SENDING LINKS TO CINDY

HERE ARE THE WEB SITES WHERE I GOT THE QUOTE FOR DR. GREEN.

Shortcut to: Open Original Shared Link

AND THE DR. GREEN QUOTE WAS FROM A LINK FOR THIS WEB SITE.

Open Original Shared Link & Open Original Shared Link

If Dr Green wrote the article I would think he wouldn't mind being quoted but Cindy's personal Dr's names should be left out..I agree.

Judy

Gcbec Newbie
EDIT--I WAS HAVING TROUBLE SENDING LINKS TO CINDY

HERE ARE THE WEB SITES WHERE I GOT THE QUOTE FOR DR. GREEN.

Shortcut to: Open Original Shared Link

AND THE DR. GREEN QUOTE WAS FROM A LINK FOR THIS WEB SITE.

Open Original Shared Link & Open Original Shared Link

If Dr Green wrote the article I would think he wouldn't mind being quoted but Cindy's personal Dr's names should be left out..I agree.

Judy

I agree the only Dr name I used was Dr Green no personal dr names were mentioned not even the accusing dr name was mentioned as far as I see.

2kids4me Contributor

My heart goes out to you, I have seen stories on 20/20 about children with medical conditions that were taken from families - authorities were convinced that the family was making the kids ill, only to find out months later that the child HAD a rare condition (or sometimes not so rare).

These are some sites I found - google: munchausen misdiagnosis and lots of sites come up.

Open Original Shared Link

Open Original Shared Link

Get the media involved, call 20/20 and ask them if they have an archived show about misdiagnosis of munchausen by proxy. Heck, call Oprah!

Is it possible to ask the lawyers or CPS to have celiac ruled out while the child is under their care? or they will be liable for not giving appropriate medical care.

I am so upset for you, it must be painful every day. I hope you have lawyer who can fight tooth and nail for you

Also , when they did the endoscopy, did they take biopsies or was it just a subjective visual exam? - even so inflammation is not normal in the small intestine without a cause! My daughter's endoscopy looked fairly normal (quote from GI) visually and her antibody levels were not that high - yet the GI doc phoned me 3 days later to say the biopsy confirmed celiac sprue. So "looking' alone doesnt cut it.

Lordy, if anyone had looked at the bloodwork and biopsies and psychological tests and scans and xrays done on my daughter with her multiple problems - I could just have easily been in the same boat if the wrong doctor had seen me!

eKatherine Apprentice

You need a celiac specialist doctor for an expert witness, not just a psychologist. Just because a doctor can't see your children doesn't mean he can't talk authoritatively about proper treatment of celiac and the difficulties in getting a diagnosis. Have you done Enterolab on yourself and your husband? Knowing what genes you carry will show what risks the children are likely to have inherited. In fact, a family tree showing who has what genes would make a nice piece of evidence. It might convince your family to give you a little more cooperation, too. I'm thinking a "poopiness" episode might have provided a sample for an Enterolab test...

You can always find doctors who are willing to serve as expert witnesses if you are willing to pay standard rates, and if you can find someone who is looking to advance the cause, you might get a break on that.

Gcbec Newbie
You need a celiac specialist doctor for an expert witness, not just a psychologist. Just because a doctor can't see your children doesn't mean he can't talk authoritatively about proper treatment of celiac and the difficulties in getting a diagnosis. Have you done Enterolab on yourself and your husband? Knowing what genes you carry will show what risks the children are likely to have inherited. In fact, a family tree showing who has what genes would make a nice piece of evidence. It might convince your family to give you a little more cooperation, too. I'm thinking a "poopiness" episode might have provided a sample for an Enterolab test...

You can always find doctors who are willing to serve as expert witnesses if you are willing to pay standard rates, and if you can find someone who is looking to advance the cause, you might get a break on that.

That is a very good idea. My hopes were to get him in to be checked at Columbia but that doesnt seem very possible. So what would be the next best thing I suppose would be to get involved with expert wittness or expert dr in the feild that can review all his medical charts and if anything give the probability of my son having Celiac. I know it wouldnt be the quickest way to get them back and this way we will have to wait till the end of September for our trial. I will look into this thankyou.

As far as getting on TV it is not as easy as it sounds. Remember I am being accussed of lying about my sons symptoms, so if I go to media what sounds normal to people with Celiac is not always normal to people without celiac. I am going to contact National Celiac Association and see if they can help today. Maybe with there helpand everyone here can approach this the rigt way. I wil l keep everyone posted.

Thanks again for everyone, you have all provided me with strength and courage to get through another long day without my babies. I truely appreciate it.

Cindy

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Celiac.com:
    Donate

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):





    Celiac.com Sponsors (A17-M):




  • Recent Activity

    1. - Scott Adams replied to RDLiberty's topic in Gluten-Free Foods, Products, Shopping & Medications
      1

      Toothpaste question.

    2. - Scott Adams replied to Theresa2407's topic in Gluten-Free Foods, Products, Shopping & Medications
      1

      Probiotics

    3. - Scott Adams replied to Colleen H's topic in Post Diagnosis, Recovery & Treatment of Celiac Disease
      1

      Celiac attack confusion and anxiety

    4. - Scott Adams replied to nanny marley's topic in Related Issues & Disorders
      2

      Manitol and mri

    5. - Scott Adams replied to bombier's topic in Gluten-Free Foods, Products, Shopping & Medications
      1

      KATZ CINNAMON DONUTS


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      131,789
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748

    klholt
    Newest Member
    klholt
    Joined

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):


  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.4k
    • Total Posts
      1m

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):





  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):



  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • Scott Adams
      There is no scientific evidence to suggest that hydrated silica or its relative, silicon dioxide, triggers a celiac-specific immune response or causes intestinal damage in individuals with the condition. The concern you likely encountered online is a common misconception. Here’s the key distinction: the protein in gluten (gliadin) is what causes the autoimmune reaction in celiac disease. Hydrated silica and silicon dioxide are minerals, chemically inert compounds of silicon and oxygen, and are completely unrelated to gluten proteins. They are widely used as abrasives in toothpaste and anti-caking agents in food powders because they are stable and non-reactive. While any individual can have a unique sensitivity to any substance, there is no mechanism by which these silica compounds would mimic gluten or exacerbate celiac disease. Your diligence in using a certified gluten-free toothpaste is the correct and most important step, as it eliminates the risk of cross-contamination with wheat-derived ingredients like starch. Based on current scientific understanding, the hydrated silica in your toothpaste is not an issue for your celiac management.
    • Scott Adams
      There is no single "best" probiotic brand universally recommended for celiac disease. The goal of a probiotic in this context is to help support the gut microbiome, which can be disrupted by the damage caused by gluten exposure. The most important factor is not the brand name, but ensuring the product is certified gluten-free, as some probiotics use wheat-derived starches or are produced in facilities that handle gluten, posing a cross-contamination risk. Furthermore, the specific strains of bacteria can matter; some research suggests strains like Lactobacillus and Bifidobacterium may be beneficial, but individual responses vary greatly. Because the supplement industry is not tightly regulated, choosing a reputable brand that undergoes third-party testing for purity and potency is key. 
    • Scott Adams
      What you are describing, while terrifying and severe, is an experience that others in the celiac community have reported during a powerful reaction. The systemic inflammation triggered by gluten exposure in someone with celiac disease can absolutely extend far beyond the digestive tract, creating a cascade of symptoms that feel like your entire body is in revolt. The severe pain, neuropathy, muscle and jaw tension, and intense anxiety and confusion are all potential manifestations of this body-wide inflammatory and autoimmune response. It's a well-documented phenomenon that a celiac attack can provoke a significant neurological and psychological component, including "brain fog," disorientation, and panic-level anxiety. While your first step should always be to meticulously re-check all foods, medications, and even cross-contamination sources, it's also possible that a previously safe product has changed its formula or that you encountered a hidden source. 
    • Scott Adams
      The substance you're likely thinking of is "mannitol," which is a sugar alcohol, and it is indeed used as a sweetener in some "sugar-free" products. However, for an MRI, the drink is almost certainly "Mannite," which is a brand name for a laxative preparation used to cleanse the bowel before the scan. Its primary purpose is not to sweeten but to create a clear image by distending the bowel and stimulating a bowel movement. While the names sound similar, the function and formulation are very different from a small-quantity sweetener. That said, your concern is valid and should be addressed with your healthcare team. The most important step you can take is to call the MRI department or your referring doctor directly. Explain your specific reaction to sweeteners in detail—mentioning the throat and ear sensations is crucial as it could indicate a more significant sensitivity. They can confirm the exact drink they use, check its full ingredient list for you, and determine if an alternative prep is available or if pre-medication is recommended to ensure your safety and comfort during the procedure.
    • Scott Adams
      I'm so sorry to hear you're feeling so unwell, and I hope you recover quickly. While your personal experience of getting sick is absolutely valid, there are a few key inaccuracies in the information you've shared that are important to clarify for anyone else reading. The central misunderstanding is about oats and gliadin. Oats do not contain gliadin; gliadin is a specific protein found exclusively in wheat. The protein in oats is called avenin, which is similar in structure but is a completely different compound. For the vast majority of people with celiac disease or gluten sensitivity, pure, uncontaminated oats are safe. The reason "gluten-free" oats are necessary is because regular oats are frequently cross-contaminated with wheat, barley, or rye during growing and processing. Certified gluten-free oats are tested to ensure they are free from this cross-contamination. It's possible you may have a separate and less common sensitivity to avenin in oats themselves, or the illness could have been caused by another ingredient or even an unrelated virus. Given your expertise and severe reaction, it would be a good idea to discuss this with a doctor to pinpoint the exact cause. This article, and the comments below it, may be helpful:    
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

NOTICE: This site places This site places cookies on your device (Cookie settings). on your device. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.