Jump to content

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Treadmill Vs Elliptical Machines

VydorScope

By VydorScope
in Sports and Fitness

Recommended Posts

VydorScope Proficient
VydorScope
Posted

OKay so I hurt my knee yesterday pushing to hard on the treadmill. I am trying to move into a new work out pattern where I do heavy cardio M/W/F, do weights on Tu/Th, and load up on candy on Sat/Sun (LOL! Joking...)

Well now that i have a gym membership where I work, I have access to all kinds of equipment that was never an option before. Including these fancy looking Elliptical machines. So being that for the last 6 months or so I been running on a treadmill about 12-15 miles a week. and presently I hit about 6.5 to 6.8 mph for 40 mins with a 5 min cool down at about 3.5mph.

SooooOOOoOOOo if I were to try the elliptacl machine today (and give me knees a break) what does that translate to? How do they differ/better/worse? Etc? Never even seen one before...

Thanks!

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


jerseyangel Proficient
jerseyangel
Posted

Hi V,

I use a treadmill (have one here) and do Pilates, so I've not used an elliptical machine.

Carla uses one, and I'm sure when she sees this, she'll give you some pointers. She's been away, but I think she's due home this weekend. :)

Sweetfudge Community Regular
Sweetfudge
Posted

i've heard that ellipticals are much better on the knees, but i don't know how they compare to calories burned/etc...

dlp252 Apprentice
dlp252
Posted

We have treadmills at work, which I use at lunch to get in a little light cardio, and I have an elliptical at home.

IMHO the elliptical pushes my heart rate up faster than the treadmill does. I don't run on the treadmill, I walk at around 3.5 to 4.0 mph usually, with anywhere from a 3 to a 6 incline (10 max incline). I do a slower pace on the elliptical and it really pushes my heart rate up much more quickly and my legs seem to tire quickly. I could walk forever on the treadmill. :lol:

Hum, knee-wise...my knees haven't hurt in a long time, so I have no discomfort on either machine.

tarnalberry Community Regular
tarnalberry
Posted

I believe the ellipticals tend to be a bit more of a workout than a treadmill, and they are a bit easier on the knees - normally. One thing I don't like about ellipticals is the motion constraints - you're feet have to move in a set motion because they're on little platforms, and if you're not built to the machine's standards... It's not terribly comfortable, on the ones I've tried anyway. So I prefer treadmills, but I know lots of people who prefer ellipticals.

If you've hurt your knee, though, still be careful. There is still weight bearing on bent knees with an elliptical, though there is much less impact. Depending on what exactly is wrong with them, it could still be problematic. (For my knee problems and a number of others, it would be. For many other kinds of knee problems, it wouldn't be.) See how it feels for you.

VydorScope Proficient
VydorScope
Posted
  • Author
I believe the ellipticals tend to be a bit more of a workout than a treadmill, and they are a bit easier on the knees - normally. One thing I don't like about ellipticals is the motion constraints - you're feet have to move in a set motion because they're on little platforms, and if you're not built to the machine's standards... It's not terribly comfortable, on the ones I've tried anyway. So I prefer treadmills, but I know lots of people who prefer ellipticals.

If you've hurt your knee, though, still be careful. There is still weight bearing on bent knees with an elliptical, though there is much less impact. Depending on what exactly is wrong with them, it could still be problematic. (For my knee problems and a number of others, it would be. For many other kinds of knee problems, it wouldn't be.) See how it feels for you.

I believe its the same "injury" that I faced in my track/x-country days. There is tow muscle (or groups..) that control the movement of your leg, and one is a "tiny" one that controls the very last little movement from just about fully straight, to fully straight. Prbly has some fancy name like Libolataearliasfhuiasey-minor. :D Well what happened at that time was I was riding a lot, and when on a bike you do not use that muscle much at all, so it does not get as strong as the rest of the leg. So when you run it cant keep up and gets sore much sooner. The "cure" was to target it with specific exercise. Which I will do when I start my weight training on Tuesday .

It feels exactly like it did then, so thats my guess right now.

LoveBeingATwin Enthusiast
LoveBeingATwin
Posted

I prefer to use the treadmill or to ride my bike. I personally don' t like the eliptical machine because I feel like I have to stay in one certain motion. I can't really relax on it. It is a good work out, it just doesn't feel like a natural motion to me. I just recovered from knee surgery this fall and I think my bike, mountain bike that I bought a stand for use in the house, has been the best for me. Best of luck on what you decide and I hope your knee feels better!

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


lonewolf Collaborator
lonewolf
Posted

I work out on an elliptical machine 5 times a week and love it. It's smooth and easier on the knees than a treadmill. I take my heart rate regularly, to make sure I'm not pushing myself too much. I probably spend 1/3 of the time NOT using the moving handle thingys (not sure what they're called). I love to see the calories going up fast. At my weight/age/level I burn about 10 calories per minute - as opposed to 5 cals per minute on the bike. I personally don't like to do anything inside the gym that I can easily do outside - like walking or running on the treadmill.

The other machine that I LOVE is the hand bike thing. It's like riding a bike with your arms and is great for your shoulders. It keeps your heart rate up without using your legs, so you can give an injury rest while still getting in your cardio.

VydorScope Proficient
VydorScope
Posted
  • Author

Welp. I dunno what any of these number mean? But I did 30 mins (max the timer goes up to) at "Level 7" which was "6.6 bike miles" but felt I did not really push as hard as I should have so I did 15 mins at "level 11" which was "3.7 bike miles". I kept my "speed" around 65 RPM's which was a comfortable place I did not have to concentrate to maintain.

My arms gave out far sooner then my legs, so I think I will try switching to it for a while. Once I got in a "grove" it was easier to relax while doing it, so that really helps prevent injury.

I forgot to take note of the calories. :( So I will just assume it was 1,000! :D

Mango04 Enthusiast
Mango04
Posted

It's important on an elliptical machine to keep your feet flat, if possible. A lot of people stay on their toes and lean forward too much, which isn't quite the same workout. If you're on an elliptical that doesn't have the arm movement things, make sure you keep your weight centered rather than leaning entirely forward into the handrails. That's how I understand it anyway. I don't know how the numbers translate. I just work out until I'm really tired, and then I stop, regardless of level or time. Maybe that's not the best way to do it :lol:

elye Community Regular
elye
Posted

I've never put much faith in the calorie readouts on the cardio machines...if I did, I would be getting nearly twice the workout on the elliptical machine that I do on the treadmill (17 cal/minute versus 10.5 on the treadmill). I know I am working harder when I am running at six miles an hour than when I'm skiing on the elliptical at level six with the incline all the way up. I know because my heart rate is higher. Vincent, do you wear a heart rate monitor? If not, you may want to invest in one. The only true and accurate measure of cardiac work load is how fast your heart is pounding. I'm up near my maximum for most of a good run, but only at about 60% on the elliptical.

VydorScope Proficient
VydorScope
Posted
  • Author
I've never put much faith in the calorie readouts on the cardio machines...if I did, I would be getting nearly twice the workout on the elliptical machine that I do on the treadmill (17 cal/minute versus 10.5 on the treadmill). I know I am working harder when I am running at six miles an hour than when I'm skiing on the elliptical at level six with the incline all the way up. I know because my heart rate is higher. Vincent, do you wear a heart rate monitor? If not, you may want to invest in one. The only true and accurate measure of cardiac work load is how fast your heart is pounding. I'm up near my maximum for most of a good run, but only at about 60% on the elliptical.

No I would love to, but not seen any cheap ones! :(

VydorScope Proficient
VydorScope
Posted
  • Author

Oh, I did check it with the machines monitor thingy where you grab two handles and hold on for like 30 seconds and it displays and EKG thingy and then I said and a few more times and it then read out 132 most of the time, but at one point it read 154.

Is that good?

dally099 Contributor
dally099
Posted
Oh, I did check it with the machines monitor thingy where you grab two handles and hold on for like 30 seconds and it displays and EKG thingy and then I said and a few more times and it then read out 132 most of the time, but at one point it read 154.

Is that good?

i have an elliptical runner, i get on it 5X a week for about 30min, 20 min of incline and 10 of just pure running, i have sore knees if im not careful and have had no problems on this, i know that its a good workout becuase i got out on a track at the local university and was able to run 45 minutes and ran stairs as well and felt good, i also run outside in the spring/summer/fall and have been training on my running machine since xmas minus the time outs for being sick and having my weight drop and my first run outside i managed 6km's before i had to come home. so i think their great for training myself, not a big fan of the treadmill it feels like im pounding my feet into the ground.

GOOD LUCK!

dlp252 Apprentice
dlp252
Posted
OKay so I hurt my knee yesterday pushing to hard on the treadmill.

And, I just want to say how "funny" it is that you got RUNNING shoes and wham, injury. :lol:

jerseyangel Proficient
jerseyangel
Posted
And, I just want to say how "funny" it is that you got RUNNING shoes and wham, injury. :lol:

Hey yea--Donna's right!

Maybe you should go back to exercising in your boots :D

elye Community Regular
elye
Posted
Oh, I did check it with the machines monitor thingy where you grab two handles and hold on for like 30 seconds and it displays and EKG thingy and then I said and a few more times and it then read out 132 most of the time, but at one point it read 154.

Is that good?

The general guideline is:

Your maximum heart rate is (approximately) 220 minus your age. This is the number of beats per minute that your heart beats at its absolute fastest. But that is an average...if you are in great shape, your maximum is higher. Now, a good zone to be in for the duration of a cardio workout, a zone that is optimal for cardiovascular health, is 75-80% of your maximum. My maximum right now is about 190. So, if my heart rate sits at around 150-155 for most of my workout, I'm happy. A heart rate monitor really helps me here, and I got my $100.00 Polar model last year for $75.00. Not bad...

VydorScope Proficient
VydorScope
Posted
  • Author
The general guideline is:

Your maximum heart rate is (approximately) 220 minus your age. This is the number of beats per minute that your heart beats at its absolute fastest. But that is an average...if you are in great shape, your maximum is higher. Now, a good zone to be in for the duration of a cardio workout, a zone that is optimal for cardiovascular health, is 75-80% of your maximum. My maximum right now is about 190. So, if my heart rate sits at around 150-155 for most of my workout, I'm happy. A heart rate monitor really helps me here, and I got my $100.00 Polar model last year for $75.00. Not bad...

Hmm 220-32 = 188 * .75 = 141 so I need to push just a little harder then.

elye Community Regular
elye
Posted

Yep. It's an important guideline...what might be interesting for you is to see (if and when you get back on the treadmill) is what your coasting, feel-like-I'm-working-hard heart rate is on the treadmill versus the elliptical. Man, I've gotta have the resistance on VERY high and the incline all the way up on the elliptical for my heart to be pounding in my target zone. I suppose this is why I suspect that some people aren't getting the blistering workout on the elliptical that they think they are (cardiovascularly speaking, anyway)...

VydorScope Proficient
VydorScope
Posted
  • Author

Well I do not know how accurate the heart rate monitors are on these elliptical machines, but assuming they are... I did 30 mins at level 11 and that kept my hr over 170. Unlike the last time I used them,this time I REALLY felt like I worked out! LOL. Actually almost caused a hypo-crash. (I always keep fruit juice in my locker... good thing!).

I see other ppl reading while they work out, so I am going to try that. I know form experience that if I can distract my mind I can get a harder work out. Just not sure how to mount the book yet. :huh:

CarlaB Enthusiast
CarlaB
Posted

I have no problem getting my heart rate up on the elliptical. To get it to 150, I do have to have it set on a high resistance.

I can't read or I slow down. I guess it works well for some.

nikki-uk Enthusiast
nikki-uk
Posted
I can't read or I slow down.

Oh yeah, me too!!! :lol:

I always see people having in depth conversations while working out and I think 'how do they do that?'

I'm all 'Don't talk to me - I can't BREATH!!!' :o

Cuervo Rookie
Cuervo
Posted

I preferr the elliptical machines to the treadmills. I find can burn twice as much calories on the ellipitcal compared to the treadmills in the same amount of time. Also the treadmills are sooooo bad for your joints, it may feel like you get a better workout on the treadmill but it is the pressure and strain on your joints that make it feel like you have worked harder. I never ever run on treadmills. When I do use them I will walk.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Celiac.com:
    Join eNewsletter
    Donate
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):



    Celiac.com Sponsors (A17-M):



  • Recent Activity

    1. knitty kitty
      - knitty kitty replied to catnapt's topic in Celiac Disease Pre-Diagnosis, Testing & Symptoms
      3

      results from 13 day gluten challenge - does this mean I can't have celiac?

      @catnapt, Wheat germ has very little gluten in it. Gluten is the carbohydrate storage protein, what the flour is made from, the fluffy part. Just like with beans, there's the baby plant that will germinate ("germ"-inate) if sprouted, and the bean part is the carbohydrate storage protein. Wheat germ is the baby plant inside a kernel of wheat...
    2. knitty kitty
      - knitty kitty replied to Scott Adams's topic in Post Diagnosis, Recovery & Treatment of Celiac Disease
      49

      Supplements for those Diagnosed with Celiac Disease

      Hello, @asaT, I'm curious to know whether you are taking other B vitamins like Thiamine B1 and Niacin B3. Malabsorption in Celiac disease affects all the water soluble B vitamins and Vitamin C. Thiamine and Niacin are required to produce energy for all the homocysteine lowering reactions provided by Folate, Cobalamine and Pyridoxine. Weight...
    3. Florence Lillian
      - Florence Lillian replied to Jane02's topic in Gluten-Free Foods, Products, Shopping & Medications
      11

      Desperately need a vitamin D supplement. I've reacted to most brands I've tried.

      Hi Jane: You may want to try the D3 I now take. I have reactions to fillers and many additives. Sports Research, it is based in the USA and I have had no bad reactions with this brand. The D3 does have coconut oil but it is non GMO, it is Gluten free, Soy free, Soybean free and Safflower oil free. I have a cupboard full of supplements that did not agree...
    4. catnapt
      - catnapt replied to catnapt's topic in Celiac Disease Pre-Diagnosis, Testing & Symptoms
      3

      results from 13 day gluten challenge - does this mean I can't have celiac?

      highly unlikely NOTHING and I mean NOTHING else has ever caused me these kinds of symptoms I have no problem with dates, they are a large part of my diet In fact, I eat a very high fiber, very high vegetable and bean diet and have for many years now. It's considered a whole foods plant based or plant forward diet (I do now eat some lean...
    5. cristiana
      - cristiana replied to hjayne19's topic in Post Diagnosis, Recovery & Treatment of Celiac Disease
      21

      Insomnia help

      Thank you for your post, @nanny marley It is interesting what you say about 'It's OK not to sleep'. Worrying about sleeping only makes it much harder to sleep. One of my relatives is an insomniac and I am sure that is part of the problem. Whereas I once had a neighbour who, if she couldn't sleep, would simply get up again, make a cup of tea, read,...
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      133,354
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    Gracieruizzz
    Newest Member
    Gracieruizzz
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.6k
    • Total Posts
      1m
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):

  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • knitty kitty
      results from 13 day gluten challenge - does this mean I can't have celiac?

      By knitty kitty · Posted

      @catnapt, Wheat germ has very little gluten in it.  Gluten is  the carbohydrate storage protein, what the flour is made from, the fluffy part.  Just like with beans, there's the baby plant that will germinate  ("germ"-inate) if sprouted, and the bean part is the carbohydrate storage protein.   Wheat germ is the baby plant inside a kernel of wheat, and bran is the protective covering of the kernel.   Little to no gluten there.   Large amounts of lectins are in wheat germ and can cause digestive upsets, but not enough Gluten to provoke antibody production in the small intestines. Luckily you still have time to do a proper gluten challenge (10 grams of gluten per day for a minimum of two weeks) before your next appointment when you can be retested.  
    • knitty kitty
      Supplements for those Diagnosed with Celiac Disease

      By knitty kitty · Posted

      Hello, @asaT, I'm curious to know whether you are taking other B vitamins like Thiamine B1 and Niacin B3.  Malabsorption in Celiac disease affects all the water soluble B vitamins and Vitamin C.  Thiamine and Niacin are required to produce energy for all the homocysteine lowering reactions provided by Folate, Cobalamine and Pyridoxine.   Weight gain with a voracious appetite is something I experienced while malnourished.  It's symptomatic of Thiamine B1 deficiency.   Conversely, some people with thiamine deficiency lose their appetite altogether, and suffer from anorexia.  At different periods on my lifelong journey, I suffered this, too.   When the body doesn't have sufficient thiamine to turn food, especially carbohydrates, into energy (for growth and repair), the body rations what little thiamine it has available, and turns the carbs into fat, and stores it mostly in the abdomen.  Consuming a high carbohydrate diet requires additional thiamine to process the carbs into energy.  Simple carbohydrates (sugar, white rice, etc.) don't contain thiamine, so the body easily depletes its stores of Thiamine processing the carbs into fat.  The digestive system communicates with the brain to keep eating in order to consume more thiamine and other nutrients it's not absorbing.   One can have a subclinical thiamine insufficiency for years.  A twenty percent increase in dietary thiamine causes an eighty percent increase in brain function, so the symptoms can wax and wane mysteriously.  Symptoms of Thiamine insufficiency include stunted growth, chronic fatigue, and Gastrointestinal Beriberi (diarrhea, abdominal pain), heart attack, Alzheimer's, stroke, and cancer.   Thiamine improves bone turnover.  Thiamine insufficiency can also affect the thyroid.  The thyroid is important in bone metabolism.  The thyroid also influences hormones, like estrogen and progesterone, and menopause.  Vitamin D, at optimal levels, can act as a hormone and can influence the thyroid, as well as being important to bone health, and regulating the immune system.  Vitamin A is important to bone health, too, and is necessary for intestinal health, as well.   I don't do dairy because I react to Casein, the protein in dairy that resembles gluten and causes a reaction the same as if I'd been exposed to gluten, including high tTg IgA.  I found adding mineral water containing calcium and other minerals helpful in increasing my calcium intake.   Malabsorption of Celiac affects all the vitamins and minerals.  I do hope you'll talk to your doctor and dietician about supplementing all eight B vitamins and the four fat soluble vitamins because they all work together interconnectedly.  
    • Florence Lillian
      Desperately need a vitamin D supplement. I've reacted to most brands I've tried.

      By Florence Lillian · Posted

      Hi Jane: You may want to try the D3 I now take. I have reactions to fillers and many additives. Sports Research, it is based in the USA and I have had no bad reactions with this brand. The D3 does have coconut oil but it is non GMO, it is Gluten free, Soy free, Soybean free and Safflower oil free.  I have a cupboard full of supplements that did not agree with me -  I just keep trying and have finally settled on Sports Research. I take NAKA Women's Multi full spectrum, and have not felt sick after taking 2 capsules per day -  it is a Canadian company. I buy both from Amazon. I wish you well in your searching, I know how discouraging it all is. Florence.  
    • catnapt
      results from 13 day gluten challenge - does this mean I can't have celiac?

      By catnapt · Posted

      highly unlikely  NOTHING and I mean NOTHING else has ever caused me these kinds of symptoms I have no problem with dates, they are a large part of my diet In fact, I eat a very high fiber, very high vegetable and bean diet and have for many years now. It's considered a whole foods plant based or plant forward diet (I do now eat some lean ground turkey but not much) I was off dairy for years but recently had to add back plain yogurt to meet calcium needs that I am not allowed to get from supplements (I have not had any problem with the yogurt)   I eat almost no processed foods. I don't eat out. almost everything I eat, I cook myself I am going to keep a food diary but to be honest, I already know that it's wheat products and also barley that are the problem, which is why I gradually stopped eating and buying them. When I was eating them, like back in early 2024, when I was in the middle of moving and ate out (always had bread or toast or rolls or a sub or pizza) I felt terrible but at that time was so busy and exhausted that I never stopped to think it was the food. Once I was in my new place, I continued to have bread from time to time and had such horrible joint pain that I was preparing for 2 total knee replacements as well as one hip! The surgery could not go forward as I was (and still am) actively losing calcium from my bones. That problem has yet to be properly diagnosed and treated   anyway over time I realized that I felt better when I stopped eating bread. Back at least 3 yrs ago I noticed that regular pasta made me sick so I switched to brown rice pasta and even though it costs a lot more, I really like it.   so gradually I just stopped buying and eating foods with gluten. I stopped getting raisin bran when I was constipated because it made me bloated and it didn't help the constipation any more (used to be a sure bet that it would in the past)   I made cookies and brownies using beans and rolled oats and dates and tahini and I LOVE them and have zero issues eating those I eat 1 or more cans of beans per day easily can eat a pound of broccoli - no problem! Brussels sprouts the same thing.   so yeh it's bread and related foods that are clearly the problem  there is zero doubt in my mind    
    • cristiana
      Insomnia help

      By cristiana · Posted

      Thank you for your post, @nanny marley It is interesting what you say about 'It's OK not to sleep'. Worrying about sleeping only makes it much harder to sleep.  One of my relatives is an insomniac and I am sure that is part of the problem.  Whereas I once had a neighbour who, if she couldn't sleep, would simply get up again, make a cup of tea, read, do a sudoku or some other small task, and then go back to bed when she felt sleepy again.  I can't think it did her any harm - she lived  well into her nineties. Last week I decided to try a Floradix Magnesium supplement which seems to be helping me to sleep better.  It is a liquid magnesium supplement, so easy to take.  It is gluten free (unlike the Floradix iron supplement).  Might be worth a try.        
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

NOTICE: This site places This site places cookies on your device (Cookie settings). on your device. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.