Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×
  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.




  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):



    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):


  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Questions Out Of Curiosity


rebe09

Recommended Posts

rebe09 Contributor

I have been asked quite a few times by people who are curious about my gluten-free diet change, why people are becoming more and more intolerant to gluten if gluten is a natural thing for us. People have grown wheat on farms for as long as we can remember. I am always stumped when I come upon this question. How would you explain this to someone?


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



YoloGx Rookie

I would tell people who ask that up until 15,000 years ago almost no one ate gluten or much in the way of grains in general. There was suddenly less big game which created a need for some kind of food supply alternatives. Gluten thus is a fairly recent addition to the human diet--it came with the agrarian revolution which in turn helped create more possible stability and thus the possibility of settled villages, towns and finally cities for people. No one fully digests gluten however, despite it being used all these thousands of years. Some people just didn't adapt as well as others to the new food regime. As far as the rest--its just ignorance that stopped many people from knowing they had gluten intolerance or celiac. In the past most just suffered. Celiac was more fully acknowledged in Europe after WWII. People who had been chronically ill had stopped being ill during the grain shortages, and then became ill again when the grains were re-introduced--particularly grains from the wheat family. Gluten intolerance is more concentrated amongst North Europeans since 33% of them have the gene potential for celiac although it also occurs 10% in the rest of Europe and recently has been found to occur in other ethnic groups as well.

Aroostook Newbie

I believe that the increase in Celiac is due to the fact that manufacturers are using more products with high gluten such as high gluten flour for bread. I was facinated when researching Celiac in Italy, that they fully understand the disease. Our son just returned from a week in Italy. I wanted some real Italian gluten-free pasta, so looked up the words in Italian that I could not have. It turned out it was not necessary! Italy tests all citizen early and periodically for Celiac. They have gluten-free menus everywhere and foods readily available. My son said everyone is aware of the disease. He was facinated that the lunch room where he was working even had gluten-free vending machines! Why are we so far behind? Oh, and I did get my pasta. His Italian host recommended one his mom uses. It is E-Coop and 80%corn 20%rice! Fantastic!!!! Could not tell it from regular wheat pasta. But of course I can't find that brand here in the US! But I'm still looking!! :D

YoloGx Rookie

I've heard the same thing about Italy--but not in such detail. That sounds so wonderful!

I forgot to mention before that the Italians apparently have the 33% gene potential for celiac too. I think its due to the northern peoples being brought down by Caesar to help make his troops more invincible since they were so much taller and known for their superior warrior qualities.

ranger Enthusiast
I believe that the increase in Celiac is due to the fact that manufacturers are using more products with high gluten such as high gluten flour for bread. I was facinated when researching Celiac in Italy, that they fully understand the disease. Our son just returned from a week in Italy. I wanted some real Italian gluten-free pasta, so looked up the words in Italian that I could not have. It turned out it was not necessary! Italy tests all citizen early and periodically for Celiac. They have gluten-free menus everywhere and foods readily available. My son said everyone is aware of the disease. He was facinated that the lunch room where he was working even had gluten-free vending machines! Why are we so far behind? Oh, and I did get my pasta. His Italian host recommended one his mom uses. It is E-Coop and 80%corn 20%rice! Fantastic!!!! Could not tell it from regular wheat pasta. But of course I can't find that brand here in the US! But I'm still looking!! :D

I wish it were that way here. It would make life so much easier.

I have also read that not only is wheat a fairly new food source, but that "modern" wheat is genetically engineered for various reason ( mostly profit) and that is part of the increased intolerances. Anyone know more about this?

Gemini Experienced
I believe that the increase in Celiac is due to the fact that manufacturers are using more products with high gluten such as high gluten flour for bread. I was facinated when researching Celiac in Italy, that they fully understand the disease. Our son just returned from a week in Italy. I wanted some real Italian gluten-free pasta, so looked up the words in Italian that I could not have. It turned out it was not necessary! Italy tests all citizen early and periodically for Celiac. They have gluten-free menus everywhere and foods readily available. My son said everyone is aware of the disease. He was facinated that the lunch room where he was working even had gluten-free vending machines! Why are we so far behind? Oh, and I did get my pasta. His Italian host recommended one his mom uses. It is E-Coop and 80%corn 20%rice! Fantastic!!!! Could not tell it from regular wheat pasta. But of course I can't find that brand here in the US! But I'm still looking!! :D

Open Original Shared Link

Check out this place for exceptional Italian gluten-free pasta. I buy my supply from this company and they have great customer service. I usually buy the Bi-Aglut but one of the guys who run this company recommended the Le Veneziane also. I realize it's very expensive pasta BUT after eating these, you'll throw the Tinkyada in the trash. Italy does a fantastic job on gluten-free foods!

VioletBlue Contributor

The ancient ancestors of wheat were considerably lower in gluten. But gluten's interaction with yeast is part of what makes bread rise and become larger and lighter in texture. So the higher the gluten content in the wheat, the bigger the loaf of bread and the fluffier. This was seen as a good thing in a world where food was in short supply. Wheat was specifically grown for higher gluten content by our ancestors for centuries. Wheat was relatively cheap compared to meats fruits and vegetables. It still is cheaper. It costs less to grow wheat and make bread than it does to grow wheat and feed it to cows and make steaks.

Modern Genetically Modified Organisms or GMO's are a whole nother story. Gene's are being spliced left and right and not just in wheat. I don't know that the specifc goal is a higher gluten content, but rather a more resistant plant with more profitable qualities. Who knows what most GMO wheat out there really is anymore. But the same goes for corn and rice and many other vegetables and fruits on the market.

I wish it were that way here. It would make life so much easier.

I have also read that not only is wheat a fairly new food source, but that "modern" wheat is genetically engineered for various reason ( mostly profit) and that is part of the increased intolerances. Anyone know more about this?


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



SGWhiskers Collaborator
I have been asked quite a few times by people who are curious about my gluten-free diet change, why people are becoming more and more intolerant to gluten if gluten is a natural thing for us. People have grown wheat on farms for as long as we can remember. I am always stumped when I come upon this question. How would you explain this to someone?

I also share that a lot of the increase in the number of gluten free people is better understanding of the disease. better blood work, better education, better understanding of the need for compliance with the diet, better food choices.

Ahorsesoul Enthusiast

IMO: As soon as the medical field can genetically alter my digestion system then my body will be able to process all the genetically altered food.

YoloGx Rookie
IMO: As soon as the medical field can genetically alter my digestion system then my body will be able to process all the genetically altered food.

lol!!

VioletBlue Contributor

If they're gonna splice genes into me I want German Shepherd genes :D

IMO: As soon as the medical field can genetically alter my digestion system then my body will be able to process all the genetically altered food.
YoloGx Rookie

Woof woof!

Meanwhile, thought this article from the Mayo Clinic on increased celiac incidence might be relevant:

Open Original Shared Link

But honestly I think supposed increased incidence of celiac has more to do with people now being more aware of this condition -- although its also true that the standard American diet and level of stress could bring more incidents of celiac out in the general population...

Bea

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      130,236
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748

    Elaine Brostrom
    Newest Member
    Elaine Brostrom
    Joined

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):


  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.3k
    • Total Posts
      1m

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):





  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):



  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • Zuma888
      I just got my test results after a less than 2-week gluten challenge consuming about 5 g of gluten per day on average.  Anti tTG-IgA: <0.2 AU/ml (<8 is negative) IgA: 180 mg/dl (Reference range is 70-400) I previously had been on a gluten-free diet for around 3 years or so, with occasional cheating and not being strict about cross-contamination. I am however still suffering from the effects of the gluten challenge (food sensitivities, slight brain fog, weird stool, fatigue, swollen thyroid, bodyaches). Is this likely to be NCGS rather than celiac disease given the test results and my history? Note: I have one copy of HLA-DQ8.
    • trents
      How long have you been strictly gluten free? Certainly, it would be good to look into vitamin and mineral deficiencies and supplementation. The B vitamins, magnesium and D3 are all very important to neurological health. Unfortunately, it can be difficult to reverse gluten-induced neurological damage damage if it has gone on for a long time. 
    • nataliallano
      Thanks Trents I'm strict with my gluten-free diet now. I just don't feel any better. I'm going to get tested for vitamins and minerals to see if I need some supplements. For sure I got some damage that doctors call Menier's and the only way they treat it is with medicine that does damage my body more than it helps.   
    • Zuma888
      Thank you Scott for your helpful response! Based on this, would you say someone who is on a gluten-free diet - but not strict about cross-contamination and occasional cheating - and tests negative for tTg-IgA while having normal total IgA is not likely to have celiac, even if they have been 'gluten-free' for years?
    • Scott Adams
      That’s a really insightful observation about antibody testing and the gluten challenge! You’re absolutely right that antibody levels can remain elevated for months or even years after going gluten-free, especially if there’s ongoing cross-contamination or occasional slip-ups. The immune system doesn’t reset overnight—it can take time for antibodies like tTG-IgA to normalize, which is why many doctors recommend waiting at least 6–12 months of strict gluten-free eating before retesting. For someone who’s been gluten-free for less than two years or hasn’t been meticulous about avoiding cross-contact, there’s absolutely a chance they’d still test positive, since even small amounts of gluten can keep antibodies elevated. This is partly why the gluten challenge (where you eat gluten before testing) exists—it’s designed to provoke a measurable immune response in people who’ve been gluten-free long enough for antibodies to drop. But you raise a great point: the challenge isn’t perfect, and false negatives can happen if the timing or amount of gluten isn’t sufficient to trigger a strong antibody response. This is why diagnosis often combines antibody tests with other tools like genetic testing or endoscopy. Your question highlights just how nuanced celiac testing can be! For people with celiac disease hidden gluten in their diets is the main cause of elevated Tissue Transglutaminase IgA Antibodies (tTG-IgA), but there are other conditions, including cow's milk/casein intolerance, that can also cause this, and here is an article about the other possible causes:      
×
×
  • Create New...