Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):

    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Which Test Is Most Accurate?

LoisArbuckle

Recommended Posts

LoisArbuckle Rookie
LoisArbuckle
Posted

I have all the symptoms of Celiac disease. Even some childhood problems I'm just now realizing after reading the book "Celiac Disease: A hidden epidemic". I've been gluten free for 3 weeks and most of my major issues have disappeared. This week we went out to my favorite Thai place called Surin. They said their food was wheat free. I got really sick. Now I'm a little confused so I'm looking into testing. I'm having a hard time telling my family I can't eat gluten. I just know they think I'm a hypochondriac. Anyway...

Do you guys know what is the best way for me to get an accurate test? I do not have insurance so, keep that in mind.

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


sbj Rookie
sbj
Posted

I advise you to not mess around with your health. If you are/were having symptoms then you really owe it to yourself to see a medical professional. A single doctor's visit is going to cost you less than these other tests you are thinking about. I think you are jumping the gun, trying to confirm your own diagnosis. (In other words, you have already diagnosed yourself with celiac, now you're not sure so you are going to test for celiac.) That's too quick and it's a bridge too far. You don't know if it was celiac to begin with. Digestion problems can be very serious. What if it is something else entirely - say an ulcer or tumorous growth? Aren't you jumping the gun immediately testing for celiac?

Why not tell us what your symptoms are first as a starting point? If you are considering spending $100, $200, $400 for testing why not spend that amount on a doctor's visit first? Tell us where you live and someone might even be able to recommend a good MD well-versed in celiac who you can trust.

aikiducky Apprentice
aikiducky
Posted

About the accuracy of the tests - if you want an official diagnosis that a doctor will accept, what you need is a blood test (nowadays usually endomysial antibody (EmA), tissue transglutaminase (TTg) and total IGA) combined with a biopsy of your small intestine (so an endoscopy, NOT a colonoscopy).

I think the parent site of this board, celiac.com, has some articles about testing.

None of the tests are 100% accurate, but the blood tests above are quite specific meaning that if they are positive it's very unlikely to be anything else but celiac. Ditto for a positive biopsy.

Stool testing can tell you whether or not you are sensitive to gluten, but not WHY you are sensitive to it. Another way to find that out is by taking gluten out of your diet, the reintroducing it. If step one relieves your symptoms and step two brings them back, you are probably sensitive to gluten. But that doesn't tell you anything about the reason why.

I'm not officially diagnosed myself, I'm four years gluten free and healthy and happy without a diagnosis. But I encourage everyone who still hasn't been gluten free for too long to seek an official diagnosis. After you have been gluten free for a while your intestines heal, and your bloodwork returns to normal, and then it's almost impossible to tell whether or not you have celiac or not. A person with celiac needs to be strictly gluten free for the rest of their life (depending on your age, maybe even for a good 50 years!), including all kinds of life situations where you might need an official diagnosis. If at all possible, try to get one before going gluten free.

Pauliina

LoisArbuckle Rookie
LoisArbuckle
Posted
  • Author

oppss

LoisArbuckle Rookie
LoisArbuckle
Posted
  • Author
I advise you to not mess around with your health. If you are/were having symptoms then you really owe it to yourself to see a medical professional. A single doctor's visit is going to cost you less than these other tests you are thinking about. I think you are jumping the gun, trying to confirm your own diagnosis. (In other words, you have already diagnosed yourself with celiac, now you're not sure so you are going to test for celiac.) That's too quick and it's a bridge too far. You don't know if it was celiac to begin with. Digestion problems can be very serious. What if it is something else entirely - say an ulcer or tumorous growth? Aren't you jumping the gun immediately testing for celiac?

Why not tell us what your symptoms are first as a starting point? If you are considering spending $100, $200, $400 for testing why not spend that amount on a doctor's visit first? Tell us where you live and someone might even be able to recommend a good MD well-versed in celiac who you can trust.

Thank you all very much for taking time to answer my questions. In a previous post I asked If it was possible to find out on my own if I had celiac. I also posted all of my health issues. I'm not "jumping the gun".. I have many many reasons to think it is celiac. My 2 cousins and aunt have just been diagnosed with celiac disease. We all have had the same problems for years. That's when I found out what the disease was, I'd never heard of it before.

My health issues are: acid reflux, vomiting almost daily(after eating anything with gluten or msg), constipation, depression, bad leg pains (like growing pains, had them since I was a child).

I've been clinically diagnosed with acid reflux, GERD, depression, dyspepsia, and IBS. None of the diets or meds for these worked.

I've had 2 upperGI/endoscopy done. I called the doctor yesterday and asked if he did a biopsy from my small intestine. He said he didn't take any biopsy and didn't even go into my small intestine and that nothing was wrong with me.. I'm just depressed. Then he laughed and gave me 7 different antidepressants within a years time.

I'm desperate and tired of being sick.. and have no money. Please help.

happygirl Collaborator
happygirl
Posted

LA - see my PM.

LoisArbuckle Rookie
LoisArbuckle
Posted
  • Author

ALSO-

I've been almost gluten free for 3 weeks. Almost all of the stomach problems subsided. Still having bad leg pains. When I accidently ate gluten I vomited.

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


LoisArbuckle Rookie
LoisArbuckle
Posted
  • Author
LA - see my PM.

Happygirl, what is PM?

LoisArbuckle Rookie
LoisArbuckle
Posted
  • Author
Happygirl, what is PM?

PM- Personal Message, got it! : )

LoisArbuckle Rookie
LoisArbuckle
Posted
  • Author

OK GUYS... I'm done.

I've been as close to gluten free as possible for 3 weeks and fine I just ate a slice of bread to see what would happen and within 30 minutes I was bloated, hurting, and puking. I have a good enough answer. I just wont eat gluten!

Thank you so much for all your responses. Please keep in touch.

happygirl Collaborator
happygirl
Posted

Hang in there!!!!!

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):


  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      129,991
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    Tony5
    Newest Member
    Tony5
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.3k
    • Total Posts
      1m
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):


  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • The Logician
      Gluten Sensitivity

      By The Logician · Posted

      Not that I can remember but my reaction has never been more than diarrhea and I probably ate a lot of wheat products for years not knowing I was sensitive to it. Dr. never tested me because he attributed it to IBS. 
    • Awol cast iron stomach
      Worried about being isolated

      By Awol cast iron stomach · Posted

      Hi, I have worked in education in the past. Based on where assigned and building crowding I made adjustments when needed.  I understand completely what you mentioned. I brought food from home in my own Pyrex glass container.  I kept it in my own lunch tote that I kept with me during the day. In the teacher's lounge/staff lunch room I would wipe down the area I sat at with soap and water with disposable paper towel.  I also placed down a fabric placemat prior to unpacking my meal. Unfortunately, one district I could never use the microwaves as they were filled with splatters and crumbs. (To be honest at that one school even if I didn't have this condition, I would not have used those microwaves based on their state of cleanliness). There were mini lockers nearby that I kept my placemat in. I brought my placemat  home weekly to launder.  There were times if the staff had a celebration with cake or pizza I would eat outside or in my car . As the  eating tables also had to display the  party spread. So the pizza and cake was on the communal lunch tables. Those days I just diverted to outside on the grass or my car. When I was fortunate to have a consistent schedule many staff "knew" my spot, and it was usually empty when I arrived. Occasionally, it was taken and it normally was by a substitute who didn't know about me/my situation.  I hope you are able to navigate this new change of building/assignment. I do know these days many districts have crowding and teachers often share classrooms or the same desk. This was often my experience whether in teacher or support staff role. Some districts you don't even have your own desk or space. I hope you do have some space to retreat to when possible. There often times is that awkwardness of a new schedule assignment where they ask why you don't want cake, pizza ,or always bring your lunch etc. For me that happened in every job education or business sector as often times I was the only one with this condition.  I hope this may have offered some support to lessen your anxiety about the new school year  assignment change. Best wishes     
    • trents
      Gluten Sensitivity

      By trents · Posted

      People get genetic modification confused with hybridization. Wheat, as has most of our food crops, has been altered through hybridization to make it more disease resistant, more drought resistant and even to increase the gluten content. Hybridization uses selective breeding/cross pollination to enhance certain characteristics. Genetic modification, on the other hand, uses a "gene gun" to knock out certain genes and replace them with unnatural ones. In some cases, plant genes are replaced with animal genes to achieve certain properties. This is what GMO is about. Have you actually been formerly tested for celiac disease, either by blood antibody testing, biopsy or both, to rule out celiac disease?
    • The Logician
      Gluten Sensitivity

      By The Logician · Posted

      Thank you for your response. I have had several different antibiotics over the years and none affected my sensitivity to wheat products which I assumed was due to the gluten in them. However I do believe this time it was an antibiotic I’ve never had before so if your explanation is correct it would seem this antibiotic (cefuroxime 500 MG tablet Commonly known as: CEFTIN, 1 tablet by mouth 2 (Two) Times a Day for 10 days.)  could be a cure for my sort of sensitivity. I assume the hospital IV was the same antibiotic. The IV was ordered because my blood culture showed bacteria in my blood. I remember hearing years ago the gmo wheat was found in some products but I guess that was a misnomer. Believe me after over 20 years of putting up with this sensitivity, despite the fact that growing up eating subs, pizza and spaghetti regularly never affected me, I am so relieved to no longer have to avoid wheat.. I hope!
    • trents
      Gluten Sensitivity

      By trents · Posted

      Welcome to the forum, @The Logician! Many antibiotics have anti-inflammatory properties. By the way, GMO wheat is not used in food products: https://www.chefsresource.com/faq/is-wheat-genetically-modified-in-the-united-states/ There is a common misconception that it is.
×
×
  • Create New...